Is there actually a border crisis?

Plus: Earth is getting ... greener? And Trump trial news. February 7, 2024 [View in browser]( Good morning! Between the House's (failed) impeachment of the homeland security secretary, the Senate's (seemingly dead) bipartisan immigration deal, and the presidential election, there's a lot of political attention on the southern border. Vox senior reporter Nicole Narea walks us through what's actually happening there. —Caroline Houck, senior editor of news   [A family holds hands while wading a river below a bridge at dusk.]( John Moore/Getty Images What's really going on at the border Republicans tried and failed to [impeach Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas]( on Tuesday as part of their plan to use the southern border as a cudgel against [President Joe Biden]( in 2024. It was [an awkward turn of events]( for a vote that was, in many ways, political posturing. Republicans couldn't make that vote happen, but do have every interest in making it seem as though Biden’s immigration [policies]( (despite [not being particularly permissive]( to migrants arriving at the border) have led to unmitigated chaos and that returning to the restrictionist agenda of former [President Donald Trump]( is the answer. Trump made this clear when he reportedly urged Republicans in [Congress]( to turn against the [bipartisan Senate border security bill]( scheduled for a vote Wednesday so that he could keep the issue alive through the presidential election. His supporters have largely fallen in line. But that Republican maneuvering aside, there’s a deeper question: Is there actually a border crisis? I would say yes, but not in the way that Republicans would describe it. What Republican rhetoric on the border gets wrong If there’s a single word that dominates Republican rhetoric on the border, it’s “invasion.” Texas Gov. Greg Abbott [invoked it]( in court when defending the concertina wire he has illegally strung along the border in Eagle Pass. So has Trump at his campaign rallies: “This is like a military invasion. Drugs, criminals, gang members, and terrorists are pouring into our country at record levels. ... They’re taking over our cities,” he [said]( at an event in Nevada in December. The word conjures vivid imagery of the US under threat from a foreign adversary, and that’s a deliberate misrepresentation of what’s happening at the border. [Russia invaded Ukraine](. Migrants are not invading the US under any similar understanding of the word. But Republicans have long demanded further militarization of the US border, and an “invasion” would seem to demand such a military solution. “Invasion” rhetoric also serves to otherize migrants, many of whom are fleeing difficult and dangerous circumstances in their home countries in search of safety or economic opportunity. It also echoes the way that Trump’s immigration policies often not so subtly played into white fear about the increasing diversification of the US population. Their chief architect, Stephen Miller, has [promoted white nationalist writings](, and Trump himself has a [long history of enabling white supremacy.]( [A group of migrants in the desert at night.] John Moore/Getty Images Something Republicans do get right Republicans may be incendiary in the way that they describe what’s happening on the border. But there’s no question that the situation is dire. The number of times US immigration agents intercepted migrants attempting to cross the border [exceeded 300,000 in December](, up from about 250,000 in the same month last year. That’s more than has been recorded in a given month in over [two decades](. Those numbers are largely driven by migrants coming from [Central and South America, the Caribbean, Cuba, and Haiti](, though Chinese migrants are the [fastest-growing group]( of arrivals. There are signs that migrant arrivals slowed in January, though US immigration officials have yet to release the official count for the month. Daily totals had [just about halved by the end of January]( from their peak in December. But such a decline is typical over the winter months. Cities are struggling to absorb migrants Texas alone has [sent over 100,000 migrants]( to blue cities including New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, Denver, Los Angeles, and Washington, DC, since 2022. Though these cities have always welcomed immigrants with “sanctuary” policies, they’re now struggling to absorb them in the numbers currently arriving. A big concern is sheltering people, especially in the colder winter months. Chicago, for example, has[resorted to warming them in idling buses](, and watchdogs have raised concerns about the conditions in the shelters after a [5-year-old resident recently died](. It has left Democratic mayors calling for Congress to take action that likely won’t come given the polarized political environment. [A border wall.] Rebecca Noble/AFP via Getty Image The legal system is deeply broken Migrants have a legal right, enshrined in US and international law, to seek asylum and are entitled to a fair hearing, the same as any citizen. But the legal system for evaluating whether migrants arriving at the border qualify for asylum or other humanitarian protections is deeply broken. The immigration courts, which evaluate asylum and humanitarian claims, are chronically underfunded and have a backlog of more than 2 million cases. In 2023, resolving those cases [took more than two years on average](, during which time migrants may be detained or released into the US. This reality doesn’t just arguably incentivize more migrants to seek to cross the border. It also shirks the US’s legal and moral obligations to asylum seekers. Many migrants are forced to navigate the process themselves: Unlike in the criminal court system, there is no guarantee of legal representation, even though immigration law is notorious for being second in complexity only to the US tax code, and some migrants may not even speak English. This is untenable. But as I recently argued, the bill under consideration in the Senate [doesn’t meaningfully address those problems](, instead relying on a broad authority to turn away migrants at times of high demand. Any reforms would have to balance the US’s commitment to ensuring that migrants are not sent away to danger, as is required by law, with streamlining the process. To start, the government could surge resources to the various steps of this process in the interest of speeding it up. That could include hiring and sending to the border more non-law enforcement personnel who are trained to evaluate asylum claims, as well as more immigration judges and court staff. And offering legal representation to migrants can make the proceedings smoother for all involved. Unfortunately, it doesn’t seem as though Congress is willing to entertain any such solutions right now. [—Nicole Narea, senior reporter](   [Listen]( “The world’s coolest dictator” That’s how El Salvador’s Nayib Bukele describes himself. Silvia Viñas from the news podcast El hilo explains how his victory this weekend is a blueprint for authoritarians looking to get reelected in a democracy. [Listen now](   NAVIGATING OUR WORLD - Drug shortages in the US are at a 10-year high: You can and should be mad if you’re encountering one right now. Here’s how to navigate it. [[Vox](] - When guardrails aren’t enough: New research shows that some of America’s increasingly massive cars are too heavy for the guardrails installed on roadsides. In other words, SUVs aren’t universally safer, even for their drivers. [[Slate](] [A river surrounded by trees.] Carlos Alonzo/AFP via Getty Images AROUND THE WORLD - A man in Moscow: Russia since the start of the Ukraine war has become [increasingly inhospitable]( to Western journalists. Tucker Carlson, meanwhile, is visiting Moscow this week and says [he’s getting an interview]( with Russian President Vladimir Putin. [[NYT](] - The earth is getting literally greener: But TBD on whether that’s a good thing. [[Vox](] - Hostage deal update: Amid ongoing negotiations for a deal to pause the fighting in exchange for hostage releases in the Israel-Hamas war, Hamas has proposed a ceasefire plan. [[Reuters](] CRIME - A new precedent: Jennifer Crumbley was convicted Tuesday of involuntary manslaughter for her son’s deadly school shooting — the first parent known to be held criminally responsible for their child’s mass shooting. [[Washington Post](] - Will there be a Trump trial pre-election after all?: A federal appeals court ruled Tuesday that Trump — or any former POTUS — is not immune to being prosecuted for alleged crimes conducted while in office. The ball is likely now in the Supreme Court. [[Vox](] - Unpacking our morbid true crime fascinations: Thinking through [Gypsy Rose Blanchard]( — and the coverage of her story — after her release. [[The Cut](]   Ad  [Learn more about RevenueStripe...](   Should you quit Diet Coke? Safety questions have haunted aspartame — the no-calorie sweetener used in many diet soft drinks and other low-calorie products — since its invention. [Listen now](   Are you enjoying the Today, Explained newsletter? Forward it to a friend; they can [sign up for it right here](. And as always, we want to know what you think. We recently changed the format of this newsletter. Any questions, comments, or ideas? We're all ears. Specifically: If there is a topic you want us to explain or a story you’re curious to learn more about, let us know [by filling out this form]( or just replying to this email. Your question might be the centerpiece of this newsletter one day or featured in a Friday reader mailbag. Today's edition was produced and edited by Caroline Houck. We'll see you tomorrow!   Ad  [Learn more about RevenueStripe...](   [Facebook]( [Twitter]( [YouTube]( [Instagram]( [TikTok]( [WhatsApp]( This email was sent to {EMAIL}. Manage your [email preferences]( [unsubscribe](param=sentences). If you value Vox’s unique explanatory journalism, support our work with a one-time or recurring [contribution](. View our [Privacy Notice]( and our [Terms of Service](. Vox Media, 1201 Connecticut Ave. NW, Floor 12, Washington, DC 20036. Copyright © 2024. All rights reserved.