How to avoid spreading misinformation

Unconfirmed ≠not true.   Thursday, October 12, 2023: Hey readers, Today, we’re providing ways to think about rampant misinformation on social media. Do you have any questions about what happens next in the war? Let us know [here](. — Izzie Ramirez, [Future Perfect]( deputy editor   UP FIRST Don’t believe everything you see and hear about Israel and Palestine Ronaldo Schemidt/AFP via Getty Images During any war or horrific event, many people — including politicians and members of the media — are quick to try to figure out what happened on social media. The problem is, what’s posted isn’t always what it seems to be. During the [Russian invasion of Ukraine]( last year, livestreamers reposted [old videos to TikTok](, claiming they showed the latest from the front lines, in order to get views and trick people into donating to fake fundraisers. Particularly on poorly moderated platforms like X (formerly known as Twitter), it’s hard to really tell what’s true and what’s not. The [Israel-Hamas war]( is happening right at a moment when the nature of misinformation is changing. Yesterday, an X account claimed that the Department of State evacuated its embassy in Beirut — but [it’s not true](. I spoke with tech reporter A.W. Ohlheiser — who has covered misinformation through dozens of news events — to walk us through [how to think about claims online](. The lowdown: In war, it takes time, sometimes a long time, to verify eyewitness accounts. A lot of that has to do with the effects of what’s known as the fog of war, where people's situational awareness can be affected by incredible fear, shock, and the need to survive. That’s not to say people on the ground aren’t telling the truth, but rather that it’s difficult to parse. There’s a checklist we can all do the moment we see or hear something, says A.W.: - Understand the platform you’re on. Loads of platforms are prioritizing profit and engagement over reliability. Right now, for instance, [TikTok users are using an ad feature to promote videos]( of the Israel-Hamas war, regardless of veracity — just for $7. - SIFT! Stop. Investigate the source. Find better coverage. Trace claims. People get engagement on questionable or untrue posts during breaking news by tugging on emotions and beliefs. If you’re immediately feeling anger or another strong emotion in response to a post, take a moment to slow down. - Check in with yourself. You don’t have to view horribly graphic videos or photos to process what’s going on, even though it may feel like you want to know what’s happening as soon as it happens. The stakes: The churn of good and bad information is supercharged in high-stakes situations, A.W. wrote. This week, there was a huge debate on social media on whether or not babies were beheaded by Hamas. While reporters were confirming details, a narrative began that perhaps the beheadings hadn’t happened because they hadn’t yet been verified by news organizations. (It’s starting to look like they did, [according to the Jerusalem Post](.) “Unconfirmed,” crucially, doesn’t mean “not true.” “My sense of how this developed was that the initial story came from IDF (Israeli Defense Forces) soldiers, as reported by Israeli media,” A.W. explains. “Some journalists, rightly, pointed out that these stories weren't enough to confirm the horrific claims that were made, and urged caution. But the story went viral, and the conversation then quickly devolved into some people wrongly framing it as ‘misinformation’ (‘unconfirmed’ would be more accurate) and others were kind of using it as a litmus test. Meanwhile, journalists on the ground and reporting from afar were doing the work to verify, which is ongoing.” There’s something to be said about not wanting to jump through hoops as a media consumer to know whether something is true — it can feel dehumanizing. But as the war goes on, and as social media platforms change, it’ll remain important to be patient for [verification]( — that is, the painstaking process of cross-checking sources or digging deep into the origins of a photo or video. It defies human nature, yes. We want to know, and we want to know now, but the harm of sharing false information often outweighs the satisfaction of our knee-jerk reactions. [Read A.W.’s full guide here](.   CATCH UP How a tiny island is adapting to climate change Umair Irfan/Vox While no country has escaped the effects of rising average temperatures, Dominica is one of the most vulnerable. The small Caribbean island already bears the brunt of climate events that have killed dozens of residents and devastated its economy. Climate reporter Umair Irfan traveled to Dominica to see how the country is adapting its traditional food systems to withstand climate change: - Nearly [one-third of humanity]( lives within 60 miles of a coastline, which makes Dominica a critical case study in how to endure a warmer world. - Dominica has a footprint of 300 square miles; the majority of that land is [too mountainous for many types of industrial agriculture](. But cassava — a versatile tuber — may be key for its food strategy going forward. - With more domestic food production, Dominicans also want to cultivate a local food culture that is as much of a draw for tourists as snorkeling in the bubbling [champagne reef]( or relaxing in hot springs. - The task is not only to protect food security as temperatures rise, but also to preserve what makes Dominica’s cuisine unique against the bland homogeneity of globalization. [Read Umair’s feature here](.   VERBATIM 🗣️“Only by grounding our vision in universal humanity, the idea that every life is sacred and all people deserve our respect, can we ever figure out a way to break the cycle of violence dragging Israelis and Palestinians into hell.” — Zack Beauchamp on [how to think morally about the Israel-Hamas war](.   AROUND THE WEB - Thousands of Afghans are dead after three earthquakes rattled the nation. Entire villages were turned to dust in the deadliest quakes to strike Afghanistan in decades. [New York Times]( - Negotiations between actors and studios are suspended. After studios and writers struck a deal five months after the Writers Guild of America began their strike, the hope was that a deal for the actors' union would quickly follow suit. That doesn’t seem to be the case. [Guardian]( - Sam Bankman-Fried’s ex-girlfriend and top executive in his crypto empire testifies. Caroline Ellison, considered to be the prosecution’s star witness, explained how the FTX founder pressured her to commit fraud. [NPR](    [Learn more about RevenueStripe...](   MORE READS FROM VOX [A traumatized Maui will soon resume selling paradise to tourists]( [We’re in a new Gilded Age. What did we learn from the last one?]( [The true story of how humans are searching for intelligent alien life]([It’s time to replace urban delivery vans with e-bikes]( [Today’s crossword](   ONE LAST THING Enjoying the Sentences newsletter? Forward it to a friend, they can [sign up for it right here](. As always, we want to know what you think. We recently changed the format of this newsletter. Any questions, comments, or ideas? Write us at newsletter@vox.com or just reply to this email.    [Learn more about RevenueStripe...](   [Facebook]( [Twitter]( [YouTube]( This email was sent to {EMAIL}. Manage your [email preferences]( [unsubscribe](param=sentences). If you value Vox’s unique explanatory journalism, support our work with a one-time or recurring [contribution](. View our [Privacy Notice]( and our [Terms of Service](. Vox Media, 1201 Connecticut Ave. NW, Floor 12, Washington, DC 20036. Copyright © 2023. All rights reserved.