Rocking in the free world?

Plus: Airport lounge access, TikTok therapists, and more May 20, 2024 [View in browser]( Good morning! Today, senior correspondent Joshua Keating is here to explain something that might seem off about Biden's foreign policy. Also, a heads up: I'll be off for the next week, so editorial director Bryan Walsh will be taking over Today, Explained. You're in great hands! —Caroline Houck, senior editor of news   [President Joe Biden speaks from a podium in front of US flags.] Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP via Getty Images Biden promised to defeat authoritarianism. Reality got in the way. When Secretary of State Antony Blinken strapped on a guitar and [took the stage]( at a Kyiv rock club last week to sing Neil Young’s “Rockin’ in the Free World,” he [didn’t]( [amuse]( many of the [Biden administration](’s critics, who questioned whether the jam session was in good taste at a time when children are starving in [Gaza](, and when Russian forces are making [rapid gains]( in eastern Ukraine, partly due to the long delay in delivering US weapons to the front. But the song’s eponymous chorus (Blinken skipped the [far more caustic verses](, which make it clear that Young was being ironic) is a good representation of how the Biden administration would like its foreign policy to be viewed, particularly when it comes to support for Ukraine. As Blinken told the crowd, Ukraine’s forces “are fighting not just for a free Ukraine but for the free world — and the free world is with you too.” Almost from the beginning, President Joe Biden has defined his administration as locked in a struggle to push back against the global erosion of democracy and “[win the 21st century](” against authoritarian powers like [China]( and [Russia](. He has often described this struggle as guiding not just America’s foreign policy [but its domestic priorities](, saying America must prove that democracy “still works” to deliver economic growth and prosperity. This type of rhetoric only intensified after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, which Biden has framed as a [test of the democratic world’s resolve](. The democracy versus autocracy framing drew a stark contrast with [Donald Trump](, who as president took a narrowly transactional view of foreign policy, had chummy relationships with leaders like Vladimir Putin, Kim Jong Un, and the Saudi royal family, and undermined democratic norms at home. It also drew a more subtle contrast with Barack Obama, whose signature foreign policy achievements — the [Iran]( nuclear deal, the diplomatic opening to [Cuba](, breakthrough climate change diplomacy with China — often involved doing business with some of the world’s most repressive governments. “I believe that — every ounce of my being — that democracy will and must prevail,” Biden [told the Munich Security Conference]( a few weeks after taking office. Putting that belief into practice has been more difficult. [Blinken and another musician playing guitar on stage in a small club.] Brendan Smialowski/AFP via Getty Images What’s the US actually doing in the world? In practice, the Biden administration’s foreign policy has been more conventional than the rhetoric suggests: “Realpolitik from top to bottom,” as international relations scholar Paul Poast [put it earlier this year](. The goal has not so much been to defeat authoritarianism writ large as to compete with and contain particular authoritarian powers: China, Russia, and Iran. Sometimes, as in US support for Ukraine’s war effort and military aid to Taiwan, this can fairly be described as standing up for a beleaguered democracy. Sometimes, as in the [upgrading of relations between the US and Vietnam]( that came during Biden’s visit to the country last year, it’s hard to see it that way. Conveniently for the US, Vietnam, a major American trade partner, is increasingly wary about China’s territorial aims in the South China Sea, but the two countries have very similar political systems: single-party, Communist regimes without national elections. When the US convened a virtual “summit of democracies” in 2021, a good portion of the coverage and commentary focused not on the meetings themselves, [but on the guest list](. For instance, Hungary, a country whose government was backsliding on democracy and the rule of law and becoming increasingly friendly to Russia, was excluded. Poland, a country whose government was (at the time) [backsliding on democracy and the rule of law](, but was staunchly anti-Russian, was not. In 2022, the US hosted the Summit of the Americas — a periodic gathering of Western Hemisphere leaders — but excluded Venezuela, Cuba, and Nicaragua, all authoritarian governments subject to US sanctions. The administration’s principled pro-democracy stance was undercut somewhat by the fact that the White House was [simultaneously planning a presidential trip to Saudi Arabia](. The Saudis, as they have from numerous previous administrations, evidently get a pass when it comes to Biden’s freedom agenda. The president famously promised on the campaign trail to make Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, the kingdom’s de facto ruler, a “pariah” over his role in the killing of journalist and US resident Jamal Khashoggi. In 2022, with the war in Ukraine putting pressure on global oil markets, Biden and “MBS” shared an [awkward fist bump in Riyadh](. More recently, the administration has been [pushing an ambitious deal]( under which Saudi Arabia would formally recognize [Israel]( in exchange for concessions from Israel on [Palestinian]( statehood and formal security guarantees from the US. The US hasn’t agreed to a pact like this with any country since Japan in 1960. Then there’s [India](, where nearly a billion voters are going to the polls this month, but where moves by Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist government to [sideline its opponents]( and [crack down on the media]( have raised some questions about how much longer the “world’s largest democracy” will live up to that title. The administration has been [conspicuously quiet]( about the democratic backsliding in a country it considers a vital bulwark against Chinese power. This soft touch has continued even in the face of compelling evidence of plans by India’s intelligence services to [kill the government’s critics]( on US soil. And finally, there’s Israel’s war on Gaza. The administration’s arguments that countries in the Global South should be doing more to back Ukraine and punish Russia in the name of the rules-based international order [fall a little flat]( when the US continues to provide weapons to a country that even the State Department concludes is likely [violating the laws of war](. This administration is hardly the first to fall a little short of its own rhetoric when it comes to democracy and human rights. And it’s not as if Trump would do more to advance democracy or human rights if elected instead — not when it comes to [Israel](, or [Saudi Arabia](, or [any other country](. But the sweep and ambition of this president and his team’s rhetoric make it hard not to note the inconsistencies as they rock on in an increasingly unfree world. —[Joshua Keating, senior correspondent](   [Listen]( Amazon’s garbage book factory Vox senior correspondent Constance Grady went inside the seedy underbelly of online self-publishing and lived to tell the tale. [Listen now](   INSIDE - The world of TikTok therapists: Inside the lucrative economics of TherapyTok. [[Vox](] - That good-good airport lounge access: Inside “the competition to lure affluent travelers with luxurious lounges.” [[Atlantic](] - An implosion at OpenAI: The inside story of why the company is hemorrhaging employees who care deeply about making sure AI is safe. [[Vox](] [A Palestinian woman stands amid rubble, her arms turned upward and a sad expression on her face, in the remains of a city street in Gaza.] Dawoud Abo Alkas/Anadolu via Getty Images ALSO IN THE NEWS - The UAW vote we covered in Friday’s newsletter: The workers at the Alabama Mercedes-Benz factory voted against unionization 2,045 to 2,642. The union has alleged the company violated labor law by intimidating and harassing workers and has already filed charges to continue the fight. [[NPR](] - The controversy over Gaza’s death toll, explained: "Revised data from the health ministry turned into a debate about the war’s human cost." To be absolutely clear: That death toll remains devastating. [[Vox](]   Why are we spending so much? Americans say the economy is bad, but they’re spending like it’s booming. Vox's Nicole Narea digs in. [Read more »](   Are you enjoying the Today, Explained newsletter? Forward it to a friend; they can [sign up for it right here](. And as always, we want to know what you think. Specifically: If there is a topic you want us to explain or a story you’re curious to learn more about, let us know [by filling out this form]( or just replying to this email. Today's edition was produced and edited by Caroline Houck. We'll see you tomorrow, when you'll be in Bryan Walsh's hands!   [Facebook]( [Twitter]( [YouTube]( [Instagram]( [TikTok]( [WhatsApp]( This email was sent to {EMAIL}. Manage your [email preferences]( [unsubscribe](param=sentences). If you value Vox’s unique explanatory journalism, support our work with a one-time or recurring [contribution](. View our [Privacy Notice]( and our [Terms of Service](. Vox Media, 1201 Connecticut Ave. NW, Floor 12, Washington, DC 20036. Copyright © 2024. All rights reserved.