The Evening Wrap: Don’t appoint govt staff as SECs, says Supreme Court

The Hindu Newsletter - Here are the latest updates and the big news stories to follow today [The Hindu Logo]( [Facebook]( [Twitter]( [Youtube]( [Linkedin]( [Instagram]( Friday 12, March 2021 [alt_text]( The Evening Wrap Here are the biggest news stories of the day [alt_text]( Welcome to the Evening Wrap newsletter, your guide to the day’s biggest stories with concise analysis from The Hindu. We hope you are staying safe. Govt staff should not be appointed as Election Commissioners, says Supreme Court The Supreme Court on Friday held that independent persons, and not government employees, should be appointed Election Commissioners. A Bench led by Justice Rohinton F. Nariman, in a judgment, said [giving government employees additional charge as Election Commissioners was a mockery of the Constitution](. The Bench held that people holding public office could not be appointed Election Commissioners and directed States to comply with the constitutional scheme of independent and fair functioning of election commissions. It said the independence of the panels could not be compromised. The court said it was disturbing to see government employees manning election commissions as an add-on job. The judgment came on an appeal against an order of the Bombay High Court, which had set aside the election notification issued by the Goa State Election Commission in the municipalities of Margao, Mapusa, Mormugao, Sanguem and Quepem. Quad is a force for global good, says PM Modi “We are united by our democratic values and our commitment to a free open and inclusive Indo-Pacific,” Prime Minister Narendra Modi said at the first Quad summit on March 12. “Our agenda today, covering areas like vaccines, climate change and emerging technologies, [makes Quad a force for global good](,” he said, adding that the Quad will be a pillar of stability in the region. Invoking the Indian philosophy of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam, the Prime Minister said, “I see this positive vision as extension of India’s Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam philosophy, which regards the world as one family.” In his remarks, U.S. President Joe Biden announced the launch of a partnership to boost vaccine manufacturing. “The Quad is going to be a vital arena for cooperation in the Indo-Pacific,” he said. [ U.S. President Joe Biden, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga participate in a virtual Quad summit on March 12, 2021. ] U.S. President Joe Biden, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga participate in a virtual Quad summit on March 12, 2021. Biden also described Quad as a new mechanism to enhance cooperation and raise mutual ambition as they address accelerating climate change. “We know our commitments... Our region is governed by international law, committed to all the universal values and free from coercion but I am optimistic about our prospect,” he said, in an apparent reference to China which is flexing its muscles in the region. “The Quad is going to be a vital arena of cooperation in the Indo Pacific and I look forward to working closely with all of you in the coming years,” Biden told Quad leaders. Known as the ‘Quadrilateral Security Dialogue,’ representatives for the four member nations have met periodically since its establishment in 2007. The four countries plan to establish a series of working groups that will focus on climate change; critical and emerging technologies, including working to set technology standards and norms; and jointly developing some of the critical technologies of the future, officials said. Trinamool submits memorandum to ECI on Nandigram Mamata incident A six-member delegation of the Trinamool Congress (TMC) on Friday [submitted a memorandum to the Election Commission of India]( (ECI) on the alleged attack on party president and West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee. The memorandum quoted various comments made by BJP leaders, including Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in the run-up to the Wednesday incident in Nandigram. Calling it a “deep-rooted conspiracy”, it alleged that the “attack” was “premeditated”. The party demanded an “immediate, thorough and unbiased investigation” into the incident. To underline their claim that the alleged attack was pre-planned, the party, in the memorandum, listed eight instances. Among them it said that two days before the incident, on March 8, as per the TMC, BJP State president Dilip Ghosh put up a caricature of Banerjee, depicting she would be hit at Nandigram. The removal of the State Director General of Police was also a part of this conspiracy, it claimed. On March 9, a day before the incident, without consulting the State government, it said, the DGP was removed by the ECI. [Trinamool Congress MPs Saugata Roy, Satabdi Roy and Kakoli Ghosh speak to the media after a meeting at the Election Commission of India in New Delhi on March 12, 2021.]Trinamool Congress MPs Saugata Roy, Satabdi Roy and Kakoli Ghosh speak to the media after a meeting at the Election Commission of India in New Delhi on March 12, 2021. Importantly, the memorandum cited a speech of Modi as evidence. At the ‘Brigade Cholo Rally’ on March 7, 2021, he said, ‘lekin jab scooty ne Nandigram mein girna taye kiya hai toh hum kya kare (if the scooter has decided to fall in Nandigram what can we do?)” The memorandum also quoted a conversation between BJP MP Saumitra Khan and Minister of State Babul Supriyo on Twitter to support their theory. On the very day of the incident, the TMC said, the BJP complained against the police personnel responsible for Banerjee’s security. By 6.30 p.m. that day, it claimed, the Superintendent of Police and the local police were “suspiciously absent” when the “attack” took place. It also alleged that eye-witnesses were planted. “There is a clear nexus between the post by Dilip Ghosh on Facebook, multiple complaints by BJP seeking removal of DGP, the unilateral decision of the ECI to remove the erstwhile DGP, the plan revealed by Saumitra Khan on Twitter, and the BJP’s request to suspend security personnel of Banerjee,” the memorandum said. After the meeting with the ECI, Rajya Sabha floor leader Derek O’ Brien, Lok Sabha members Saugata Roy, Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar, Pratima Mandal and Satabdi Roy, and Rajya Sabha member Santanu Sen, speaking to reporters, said the ECI’s credibility was at stake. Dastidar said the public perception in West Bengal was that the ECI was not a neutral body. Roy said, “It is not for us to repose faith in the Commission, it is for them to at least appear fair in the eyes of the general public.” SC seeks govt’s response on plea against Places of Worship Act The [Supreme Court on Friday asked the government to respond]( to a plea challenging a special law enacted in 1991 by the Congress government, which freezes the status of places of worship as it was on August 15, 1947. A Bench led by Chief Justice of India Sharad A. Bobde issued notice to the Union Ministries of Home, Law and Culture on a plea filed by advocate Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay against various provisions of the Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act of 1991. Upadhyay said the “arbitrary, irrational and retrospective” cut-off date bars Hindus, Jains, Buddhists, and Sikhs from approaching courts to “re-claim” their places of worship which were “invaded” and “encroached” upon by “fundamentalist barbaric invaders”. “The Act declared that the character of places of worship-pilgrimage shall be maintained as it was on August 15, 1947 and no suit or proceeding shall lie in court in respect of disputes against encroachment done by fundamentalist barbaric invaders and law breakers and such proceeding shall stand abated,” the petition said. The petition said Sections of the Act that dealt with the bar on legal claims were against the principles of secularism. “Section 2, 3, 4 not only offend right to pray, practice and propagate religion (Article 25), right to manage maintain administer places of worship-pilgrimage (Article 26), right to conserve culture (Article 29) but are also contrary to State’s duty to protect historic places (Article 49) and preserve religious cultural heritage (Article 51A),” the petition said. DMK releases list of candidates The DMK on Friday retained most former Ministers and MLAs in its [list of 173 candidates]( for the [Assembly election](, while fielding party president M. K. Stalin’s son Udhayanidhi Stalin from the Chepauk-Thiruvallikeni constituency in Chennai. In all, 187 candidates will contest on the DMK’s ‘Rising Sun’ symbol. DMK president M.K. Stalin, who released the candidates’ list, said it was a list of victors. He said the DMK alliance was not a political alliance or created just for the purpose of the election: “It is an alliance of principle,” he said. [ DMK president M.K. Stalin announces the list of candidates on Friday, for the TN Assembly Election ] DMK president M.K. Stalin announces the list of candidates on Friday, for the TN Assembly Election Stalin will contest from the Kolathur constituency. Candidates of MDMK, Kongunadu Makkal Desiya Katchi, Tamilaga Vazhurimai Katchi, Forward Bloc, Makkal Viduthalai Katchi and one candidate of Manithaneya Makkal Katchi will contest with the ‘Rising Sun’ symbol. Covid Watch: Numbers and Developments The [number of reported coronavirus cases from India]( stood at 1,13,31,416 at the time of publishing this newsletter, with the death toll at 1,59,839. Novavax Inc’s coronavirus vaccine was [96% effective in preventing cases caused by the original version of the coronavirus]( in a late-stage trial conducted in the United Kingdom, the company said on Thursday, moving it a step closer to regulatory approval. There were no cases of severe illness or deaths among those who got the vaccine. The vaccine was also about 86% effective in protecting against the more contagious virus variant first discovered and now prevalent in the U.K. It was about 90% effective overall, combining data from people infected with both versions of the coronavirus. Novavax has a licensing agreement with the Serum Institute of India for commercialisation of its vaccine. In Brief: Eight leaders of the Samyukta Kisan Morcha (SKM) reached West Bengal today on a three-day visit to campaign against the BJP. They will address five rallies, including in Nandigram and Singur, where they will urge everyone not to vote for the BJP. The SKM also issued a letter where it said that a defeat in the assembly elections will force the Centre to repeal the three farm laws. Evening Wrap will return tomorrow. Today's Top Picks [alt_text]( [Mamata discharged from hospital]( [alt_text]( [The contrasting fortunes of two Dravidian majors in Puducherry]( [alt_text]( [India, China to continue military talks on LAC disengagement]( [alt_text]( [Justice Indu Malhotra ends 2-year tenure in SC]( You are receiving this email because you are a user of [thehindu.com]( If you do not wish to receive any such emails, [unsubscribe here.](mailto:rm-0bfbvaw4bf2f90kauhrxfebysa8hk0f@newsalert.thehindu.com?subject=Unsubscribe&body=You will be unsubscribed from our mailing list.) To ensure you continue to receive emails from The Hindu in your inbox, please add newsletters.th@newsalert.thehindu.com to your contact. If you can't see the mailer, please [click here.]( Group Sites [The Hindu]( | [இந்து தமிழ் திசை]( | [Business Line]( | [BL on Campus]( | [Sportstar]( | [Frontline]( | [The Hindu Centre]( | [Images]( | [roofandfloor]( | [Classifieds]( Copyright @ 2021 ,THG PUBLISHING PVT LTD. [About Us]( | [Contact Us]( | [Digital Subscription](