Independence hard sell at general election may backfire badly on SNP – Scotsman comment

[View email online](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfW5nR32W95jVnq6lZ3pfW7yKpd68cCC2VMhl56QJBwfXW6bHJfx4bbn48W40Cqv25gVHdGW4Kt3wt4QNZWjN37TJ8dFPYhdW5s43h08GPQNSW61bWjF1NTDnkW2rjHKq3w_4lHW7x0bkT80bm25W672Bs39c569gW33S-q75cFpTTW82-w863p9TR3W50-Txt6xvpk4W5HHFVX7pDhyRW2FXNcw6G8X1lW97h0yz1DSfjqW36wzCv11hftwW8BJPzk9cF583W1Grdyl2-jY3XW2C7PVc5jBN3xW22ZJBm6KPKGgN6GgdJJDMtZ0W1jKrX24NSP7NW5J8P432vZcXdW3h9D0-7g7Y3SW6j83Zs8MWPrpW7pNsmf2gqZD-VL2KmG6t4hc2W28Jh-h1sy03nW2jCQMx2XbFx1W2wcN2w3j9BlGW7kPjrS46tMdGN2Lz8CQmcJ7bW6gPhLy3Qn3qLW7G95dv12YMT0W2C2l192DZhnFW3z3xZs32_TFvN1TVxMcCtGVLN1n91JrsT_8ZW4V_D8-4dCSBKW92zhG18YYkQSW5Tx8MF3_y3WbW8lVQlJ6KxNXPN5WLpXnZxwx9W4Bf3fM5DZ-PXf94h-Hj04) [The Scotsman] Top Stories A round up of the most popular news stories this week. [Independence hard sell at general election may backfire badly on SNP – Scotsman comment](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf05nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3m_W26m3XV94pb7jW9cDCKC4vcYP1VSpWFX6JKp_HW3dr1z21zDkhMM_p5z2k5676W1wBLpY8F84ZHW3_ZYdb3XPhdhVBvhWw7G_zVQW25hjqP3b7G-QW1CcFDn7vm_D0VC7lLY8JjKTMW3K_QJx39QZ4cN3bYT5TSrgy7W3F3-GZ5vDDxgW9472n57kcF63W6qvnSk4SmNmSN1yY8xT_vwbxN8jv1lf-hFr1W4tM36x5MRQMQW6XfJZR8dGr0_N1-fF0Bk2nGQW5KZdPd36FMrCW9lgYR_3nSwj9V_szLm1MTQZVW2SYt_Q5-Sy7PVYv1_b6s3g2LW6lZjJc54Rr1vW5TG8PN4fZgkzW5wV1wl9j9wBPW434Hhj8-KNVWW28F1CK1Hp_Y9N71NYqfQ55krW19MRQQ3MHFRNW4Jvfq37jQ5lBW3cJ7cy5WnXmWW8bcNyq70RP8GW6hMb3Z4tGs9bW4q5XTg6MFNG5W7T0kZD1vB2JpW7ZKJPV69kYHwd9R3sn04) [Independence hard sell at general election may backfire badly on SNP – Scotsman comment](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf05nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3nMW2Qw3tj7dDK-nW2-mMZZ4_vT7nW360_-M1GRt7FW6W14zq1dyKgnW11Pk1T47LkdQW4p0Hhc33FKLMVPv_ky5tDV1fW6TnNyp8Mk1q3N6Pv3ZJ8_KW2W4yYfPG5-2f5KW4BFrfx4s7Sl7W1hQq493T-8JSW1SP-r46C58dZW2DsWHF2_5D1GW692dnq4rN44SW2DV6nn2-6pS7W4g1MBg3WHSdlVtgL9K8Qgy-6W82PNxr6_6WsGW8xck821jcQcGW9c1mGD21_c35W76GD_D8fMKcrN5PzWf1S8F7MW3Rz2YS2s1ZLWN2Fw717WzMghW5H6Qct4471FkW52P3Gb6kV1LQVYs-YS3GkRcbW5GsWhZ1Rr4-nVVh5b080h1MqW7FTLzP7F-hskW4rrhPs3WmhR_N80DJrYRjjH-W7f6snZ8_0HP5W8wXmLD326SbFN8YC1Z-HYprSW8lGKbn2NG09DW8DctpW2YCvhXW2JJGvd4Bzf7CW3PkST54j2y29f6psMB604) [King Canute-like response won t save us from the growing storms of climate change – Ian Johnston](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfC5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3lfW632TK55GZ3xdW8vRb396T74XRW1dphQ14V32sRMJ2-gypBwbcW481jx98fxZXjW1D9Tqx1vMTfsW6nwPwH6PS9rbW8-45Yv8K7KX6W6C6pcV6q-yz_W6gv5sq7bj2LDW7y8Png4PTVfHW7MlMZS38cMg_W5qX5pw3KJRBQW2f0h8d5lXHhwW2b8q7V29Y2V1W5R24zH6XJHrXN4qNHqyGMP5ZW3ZHt_m2G1l4_W2n4TQZ4kB67CW2rG2n73_x0glW1XyxDL6BLbJRW1KTpbx4CjH_bW8ZzmC24Sfk7dW2yrz2G2wbnBLW4k_J-X3SPgRFW90Z_GG8fsc-RW2kFWXd84W27-W6Yg0nP4XMQSKW7p3lF75bzswXW1cpR_38zqcx4W5KHvlD3XwWLpW4Ft6W43wf3MFW57ZSYz8SJnXDW4L80Cr1jB6TXW7NNFmq24jCTfW1YWJlG3m-2CCN8TwKbr_CyWgW5gmqY94JWPxMN2fKF8PsdGzWN5VLwmk82TRbW48RB976M7FzDW5dNz5H5ZKwmKW3xqg2J3Q7cNkW38P7Qz2Ww41rf6-WJjR04) [King Canute-like response won’t save us from the growing storms of climate change – Ian Johnston](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfC5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3mRW1sLMQR7WJpknVJL2bk4lq48DVmw2SY1zbGCNW8bn6c434c8RpW2-5SdH3vvFXcN3lVV_6KcztSW1M4Kny5JwL8PW8ZvT6s43R4X4W31f0H-3czc8YN30jSQCRjxWfW6jVlnt5BLpSXW1X-b3J165G6TW590pJ98jFPjFW7nflPh828csLW8S9B755ZH0cPW6N-pq38gBJJyW8wDVtJ8gztgvW8Wgj206s2d55W8tDwLx4YJNn4W3JcMQd3Hbtm6VsNRLl5R57SjW5dvbYD47Jv2sV6t_0z7Nrq3nW5_q2bP2rtfzMW42152N4dgR1hW7xX70-6yJ8mTW1d0fWr3nkGpCW39W6PW51PnCVW2S4X4L1hj_KFW36rTWY1dXsC9N6W6BWJ_0q2WW99v23m1_xZvLN4GVP2V3dYNgW4QWPBm2pQvmmW744yPB137DYqW1gjFGf7DnGKTW54LK8K474MX0N8fk41BdtKswW41c0N88Jf47QW8fzJ367_4kz1W3rpwQp7h18hTW3PLv-B98h38sW2ZDy_37DQXJKW8BmMfM8KTgMWf4z5DQY04) [Article Image](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfC5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3lBW49SVRy7SK_CWW1_9VFr2XJJxmW31c7W720wpsjN8yK26683BpkW6NqXSD5vtsX5VykmxT6gQ2YdW6vt7J11X-41vW6fwTzM28_dvFW1NHG2X8SHhmxW7cP4qX7GZ75WW3MXzs876_FKdW8M164p8Qj_DhW4tJlzk46sMLgW7DBQYB2lsK50VMk2Ss2xRglBW2vQS432bLRckW78vMwz18d_CjW4qPMD77PSbz8W1VrJgS63R-1tW7g6BSD3ZWrHsW5hlWcq2KSfSrW4PwFbg7tTCnZW13RFdJ7bJgd9W5_2Bfh3d5rBHW5xGBKv1Fg78zW4hF-g46ypVQJW5xz8m64M-bfxW6fhm-b2vTrbPW4WQyCR6BQnZLN2pN7MzlRcYMW5jp27c3h8-bRW72v92c4JvTpdW3mtWV04f1TSzV71LWX8Jh4x3W37kPjG3wyVYDW4kJSJD97Fc_9Vb4Bpp6yc7TLMCY-gWP7cwYW2DF9vp2cW8cMW9cq2Q62w9gTsMYYxGsY28s8W5p8dN88NDvD3W7WXrRC73pRk9W3Z_qzF1Z-HHff3xxTpv04) [Take a deep dive into the Scottish housing market in new Property Podcast](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfC5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3kDW87hn5C3ttpRtW3FwRGH2dYqNSW8Pp7gx2hBHcDW5H4r0p1bGt4HW4lCMLZ3HgsdVW229_p88rmtHHW5qKQFY4lCKmFW4kx3Jy5jCq7gW1Xj7k1696gmNW2Hqk8n6rM7R9W1gMgcs135dvYW34BZdN5y9q55W7FMD0_43msKCW3yR66-6hvqD_W8fPRHW1Q_gkBN4pBbdVSCBDpW3Gj5k16-dl6mW3fcHZ72MnyT3W7yfR-552F00fW3gpKLd44WVJ3M-6_Gx_S_dqW6h6nhm9bjr34W4JcdrN1T4XYrW6grLqY6XSkNvW4gBfPb7HmgVqN646-N3mgfpXV1yzcQ6gn-_pW7V3rcD1bj3YwN6V6gPyF0GYfVcffj01Q_K2jW1Cb9BV5WXQNzW1zk8rR7pf1FNV-4cmJ2k-lRsVVXqCL6QswY8W6FKcMN2zXHStW26jfX07HrfV3N4KdrF1hM62cW59pdMS56DrDZW272PTS7qSVnwW8K3F7w2j2nb1W5dTTGl5J3gkxVsHTHF97GBKBW8GMfcB1p3rhYW2w2VfM5zlQZRf10cGJz04) The first edition of our new Scotsman Property podcast is now available, made in partnership with DJ Alexander. Promoted by DJ Alexander [Scotland s online black market: Social media sites used to swap drugs by patients who can t get medications on NHS](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf05nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3phW7hLhpz64HyJVW5gl4Yc8-mfNqW3hJwgj5rRY_7W34j-6L6cRnqWN4dzdQtS8F_pN86Gh1lfnt3QW22Gwgt8KCtQ1VbwKsp1lFP9qW5YDmVD6d_WtqW6fTkCV3cNVp6VZpmRf5T0s2_W1_4t22412pKTVSP6Zz8rXdcZW4VPJWt8CqQFQW1FScpQ5Pc4tCW7Zcqxs7Y0dT3W8vXKN-298ZFhW6qbD5R2wXbwbW8QSsn6141-kcW468xDv8w7j1YW2SPQXh2MmYGgN7Rns0L5kWLmW9jLWLS3jVJRjV9WFLC62XRZYW2gdKrk75BHXdW8f2JYt4jtHmJN7M706cdhh_-VgyY2444-LYpW8S9Xss73qbKhW4lsY7t15RZsVW6k3djg35HczGW41DS7R35LbjKW1bVW-l808fX1W6_C2G333gRZCW3zHy6X2jHlgfW2jZg1Q4W_R5yN7tc6hpgTQYfW7X1r-l4xFWWPMlwTWvYghDrW50k2Cc2KS7sxf5s5b1b04) [Scotland’s online black market: Social media sites used to ‘swap’ drugs by patients who can’t get medications on NHS](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf05nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3mGN6bqqcqNL4LSW6l2jT83wQN6gW3QB2T94qLSmwW3bQbbg7bZJQfW77qSNf2l32zpW3CDMyd5q26-MW3ph7T920PB60W680MGB8RSRP9W1qxMRf51tGD9W36WJq083YPzcW3st4Lc1F8rPRW3Qskhh1kgbRwW6Q7hBT3r07mxN1clcLnHzmfgN448C_hRcH3pW6TtYhw88rZm1W5qJn5d3cq4d-N2GTSrW72PCVVLWjS14nw7qbW738WLy6L9_BzW1HL64X25SJJyW2vSzNS3FKWjjW96w8nV44NJrPW1wWWKT5ln-HQW46CTVz1mtbR2W2rlDd43kx4DGN4555TS3by8PVq3dg_69h-XGW4D6p-B6mK0kxW8W1LZ632n98jW8DBn3459wxKQW98DNJW6dV8wNW1-VgW_3SDCf_W6kX-Dh62hbJXW2PK0h38JNcV8W8D0-mX6sjv_yW7-z0TY3GTY7DW6kKJ6Z1lw8yQN1kkmzYLpXW-N1t6qFFP5nx7f58rbSl04) [Flynn says SNP must re-inspire voters ahead of general election and party will target northern seats](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfW5nR32W95jVnq6lZ3pcW5c8-4S1PzwNWW93gXvx1qMkj8W1bqMxx4d8d4VW79Kt1B8M07s5W6qc0vk5yvsBcW68q51N4cVJFGW2ml-kz1csvfQW7jzyTw4JLR5dW9jhDV02r6FvgW1ShghV2-qwvWN1mvt3xd7xjgVrTYP31p131vW27KM7q3KGW_vW5SzmjQ956pfKW2GR8cP3r198ZW1yNdLZ2Gx56-N8sJzCqCrSfzW2fqKwR2shMYYW8F_gZr881GL1Vtd2zx1QfnpXN8kWYYd1jF_ZW5mYK071fz2C7W4j6myY1f67SzW8q17Bk2fKc0TW6l-MBG5pKPXMW447PRG1jx_xHW4ZTdBH7W2ctFW1H-kwn7_xQ1hW2xZqgV3n_BCmN2BxFDtQqt4LW3NX9SM6t4r-VW1lJGxp1-wrHLW6Zn3dR5TKhJLVlfkmF8SZplWW5W_rp0397_ddW7YccjN6XxhS9W7Hn7PD6FhpNTW8ZhfKW77TcF3W7YGk_c9cFZCcN8Hbh5DZCv0sVCwnTR8j-lzgVNSzHD54GrctW17ZwYw35Yg-rW2X-0sW8RZqTFW1Yg4Jg89BlXQW815-9F78STtQf2YLyb804) [Flynn says SNP must ‘re-inspire’ voters ahead of general election and party will target northern seats](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfW5nR32W95jVnq6lZ3pmW2bkhjP2n1GymW99jTqr6qTbY9W4K3gmF96zB0-W2WxZts4V53H6W3YDr_P5Vcg35W2gjt_06N0ttRW6dsmlM5n2_dTW2JDKJg7tntHGW48s1z_4vXhXHVP-ZBx3LNn4mW8y8WVl5hwQcYW4nVSXt6_Y9_NW86q1Dk4rzj54W8X9PRh5-BS-hW2f_Zqm8v-gJBV32LDC2sRjY2W8G1G233JKfx2W3jNSfv8XgR-ZW7hkFBp6fZjQ7W91v3n34Q3FN-W7JQ4lz491JTdW3V_Sfz7K206SW7p4vV22wvcdpW65572Y7xkrSdW39tnr66tjd3-W3dhxgX4CJGXMW5pGSXV7fZtQGW8tRfTJ6_zzMDW74_Hlz79khlNW2y6NnM5yDnk8N7sgwbfNw75SW1BHlz72F8zP3W6bv19s4rgZjYN7tHhNdW_nq6W4kxqht3Y9Fx5W2GQRlB65pkJyW3Dv7Lc21SFmkW5gz7sS1xwVWkW8R88SJ3Fj7H0W24BKmR7SkFpYW8JnrQ85VdpSjN32WfcldlhxtW1Wb9Ll9l9hKSW2BcwvN3JdSzpW2g8dXY3R14qsW2cYFxt5TR6fMf2G0-C004) [Nationalising Scottish port could give Scotland a bad reputation , trade body warns](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgdq5nR32W69t95C6lZ3mzW4dVLmX8HjCDTN1jF_j3XwcMGW99YfVl37RDzdW6JD_3V5k3hbSW241wWG8bs27mW8wX_734sfj6VW77xPSB5Vh6YZW1P-ddV4lb9V5N8CL6gsGc9h7W388xJK7p6hxGW878-yK6xPV-MW87q9dS5NBBBCW19F6v760Zhy_VyTYKj47gcHnW5yptNJ44tLj5W5PJ2Ph4Rs3pbW5FVZlT8HKQvwW5nT5d52ZFjzNW4D9kGD8jmyGrW82LFmh81VpyWW5H35nL163ZN0W6zfQq01nGRp_W7YfhmL8G8TZ9W3m5B5M6DDxd2W3yBLCp2mFPTKW801fXb810yjfW5zxbH_4vnZRFW8tstBr7wcpWbW7ymPGn36nXmYW8QJN_b1gszwfW6hMPlV94pdQTN97FTxYQnFcxW518hxj54csBJW5kVyp856TgNhF4HJNwkvFdzW7kZgTk3K20mPf8W1fZl04) [Nationalising Scottish port could ‘give Scotland a bad reputation’, trade body warns](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgdq5nR32W69t95C6lZ3ppW7WRvzq2znHx6W7Hl3Rq75T4yRW85LYrR648G8fW1VsttL8wF_xvW4WTy_N68tKdJW8QhVrY39BbJcVF6Skw2X3Fc5W5Rkmpq1dCLY7W88Fhv67wB4bZW1M524W5qXTNdW4w6-2R5J31S0W5gxzhb7pN7xVN3wz1qM9djfBMv9vg2WkQVRW3zGV171NktYQW6cKQlB6glDQSW4-gMZX1gktQmW2-RWfg8jbZnLW10GlH58L41lZW5wbB1C29nwpLW2djGHp7gTvyHW3RYY5T1C6-VSW5QK5gJ95rMzQW77x0j46vbk2yW58Zlqq8yl_KPW5_qVKW2lQbNyW13xvkr6hdb2-W7hS9V26txWsKW1x2fYW5ZfbrrW7h_4D-1cvGF7W1XN10g8ytRLmW8LPr7l4jRmRCN64vcm4FFzYDW32XCVN4LK4trMHCW7wLHH3YW7zFWRF6BtVmPf1gwZnn04) [Neil Gray: Medical unions tell new Scottish health secretary to move fast on junior doctor pay and NHS staffing issues](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfC5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3mWN8H7T8v1TvCVW3T4Cy57YVLzzW190pPS7kv7_MW5mY1715vl2hHW20L40Z1c3kn3W5DC1f41pWy3WW6LCKTB8HzsdgW370_QN7FkmTYW9hHk7T5t1PNQW8q09SP7Hp8RfW3KWnts4jvhZyW1bJlk_4RvwjWW5tKg_42FdgDbW2nXzZG5y4xLqW7rJzT-70B5prN38yyd-C8FvlW4mBYr82yTNGRW6CBwF11dkypkN4vsnyHf7GcFW12B2-p2jqp-QW6m_z9j56j-0VW3BV7cl15frxWW13W7j57NmRvlV-KJVT12V0d6W3Z51SB1NHSvmVQY5p14Gg-rhW6bbkTj4xml8sW55t4MR98JBHnN3H-Pdjv7JG-W2sDPSC4fqtnGW32rsKZ1ChFdgW82gBMW6k-64BW52GYht4MhBnhW2YjFjs5FtR5CW8dm7Lv2jcv36V89yPT56fVx2W2mgHpX1xhQ_tW4ssVM8427NYFW7Q4C0l9gk6tkN5YPmStlLG0pW5r28DL5rPRSTW8BrQh05Dmty9W32y3ln7V6gjSW67xfgL5y8pvQf45mwZv04) [Neil Gray: Medical unions tell new Scottish health secretary to move fast on junior doctor pay and NHS staffing issues](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfC5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3nXW5KnK-L6dd9QJW2gQ0pC8BRB3CV3mbFc84Bl3RW7XRjrM3Xty79W2ZGKTL39yQXnW7P_TZ05pv-C1W6f7Rhs7N2SYmW4c7sqB14_VQtW6h4tfc4GFN3mN3K5QdY_g71HN3C69VC6Rt2_W2-c0tN8T5q_lW60twRl2dTCtnW7LCDHj2gk21WW9bT5FQ7CdyQZW3kN-Kj1z_WjvW1npvT16n-H_VW5vDJVT6yG3zvW5VhHBy43qQdXW7mQqvz20rRbxN59yt1YYqX1mW4Yq3_G3DqJY6V9g8BW539mrYW5SCcKv2lr29sM-R_4fhrJmpW7ds6rC3HjVJCW2WGFRs4F50l6W4-4mX93hbvldW6TJFDW81-KJXW6CrG165300kmVv9RFb3YNQYCW9fHl-Q1J9Q-8W3KDJdd5XT-pKW50JmGn5V8RRBW824KD61XvKCFW7FrMpJ55qqWfW90CQmj3r9kmtW6vQmRL8h-b5SN17yyG6BvtmVVNBrt96wwCl_W6KrvqP3cZtcbW6RvcN83mP-tCMZK_T3CtDHBW4ddptc7VFRw2f4CZZNK04) [King Charles III: Cancer diagnosis leads to huge surge of web traffic to cancer charity websites](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgdK5nR32W6N1X8z6lZ3l9N8Yhk6tjm8t6N6QlBQdDBnbdW3zt_P12K4-bkW2RK9FL7m7kJzW4xj_4n8tf5KSW7-ZVYP95Q-k0W4Qlfrg2nfygfV91-bC1zkY_ZW38BL8588vRQhW5V4thm8M6ph-W4j83TS7HSqh5W4l2Rhr6Y8yNkN6tz2jlzhqKGW6mXCYP2SSZ3TVgnv805Zyh14W7Hz_vS1zXVkLW2q1BDP8wlGYtN2Y83v9CmNY2W8rBDsK3-TYXKW5lS_X6841k32W3N52td18JtrQW8nK1Fk2snCz_W1skdx272Tq-jW1RlM_p4r4_GJW2Nz9GS4hN_N2V56ClL1mF9ZkW4rLQfT272z30W7q-0FQ2Dm2MVW7g58PZ30rhJKW6sMtMS21R2qlW2zC18M8ZQWs5W84TzqW7kkhgrN42nj3w_Rq-vW7pJKvV83nQgsW1kSccX5_HdN8W66MYw7834qrHW91FVVs7M2hZPW4Q86pK6pN49hf4_YMwT04) [King Charles III: Cancer diagnosis leads to huge surge of web traffic to cancer charity websites](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgdK5nR32W6N1X8z6lZ3pXW7F8lVj8mSjnmW3VGs6h8KQ5VhW8y0mBq6rJmfzW86fFxj3xz01jW39lSdP7KHZJxW1-V59D21dySQW29flcw4GvNX6VRT_Hd1PB3r9W2qcXVT4jtJ8wW13jB1l4Qf8S2W8XrF9S9cp6tPVyYWDt3RQV76W8FbJkN2MkM-pW4psltT4bJQgQVZpGdq2Z6JKSW2Nv0WY3HLGNbW41HmCn2qcD1yW67Ynh74gCRT_N7BtV9qCqzk4W78WSgl3k_69RW8PPM1m8f5TbdW6f_sr65wTCDbN3v6b4_y1yxsW8ZXdrn55L0m7N8pbFSfYPhRsW3zWfQv932jFPW3XNMKK8G6ZfvW86xhsD51YF_SW7yMnTD30bX52W2R392d5BWlX1W4XNGz289BWHkN66G5G-TCWBxW2jCcTQ63Zv-wW8Wc8k_294s5XW1_WtjH3bQbh8W785-tc5B0g63W4cCzYb5PRn0_W3-brRh33VgQYf7wvPTH04) [Labour’s £28 billion pledge is dead, because optics are more important than hope](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf05nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3lbW8DZbfR1Pzkh-W1s-_M87CjWH_W9kzc7s8_6hCmV_GmXl10RB3QW29T2p42YhFNNW80Qy6V8cx8xdW2JDYBm5gQdkcN8q3V5pk-sJyW56pyd86v_vPNVjpkTm4l4Y4zN69CCBDhF-NFN2g3hL_k4VZXW3TnR116KZzNyW6-y1Mm8dDhb_W7-vVq-8-th3GW69KjJv6FZcJ-W8nyZWD8qtTYVW850dQr6MW3nTW43BXQj67mpxBW3VHtP_1Vq_KXW6TthQV69wj4bW1YnRRh3WSJvnW1Gj7tz5-8XKTW6S7bjB8vl557W8rqyWs4vcyFBW8s_mpk93S7hKW2CpzKL79_1D0W4NNjNY833BDSW4fL53j8qvTvtW233G-N5QXZvCW47Q2WJ57lNjsW3mnLfp2P4V3bW2FqPNZ2Q4blNW8Sd47f8rYxLQW6CSZ765HmyLGW3tkdRb3wrM8CW5FK6Zw38NtFZW1xNxZZ1H9_gCW4GD1Jg1gNy2LVqTChm5tSmXcf80c8wK04) [Labour’s £28 billion pledge is dead, because optics are more important than hope](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf05nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3l2W2YQpt289XccmW9kBhDJ3bVSwnW2xbZKg1qZDpKVRTWLd1T0H6nW9cJl1F784JTCW52WJ5x7HTBQ6N6Q2TS68D3JRW5tsyvw1zllKHW1CrM8V29ZdXQW453KcS5bkW3pW14S9nX5ZHLMqW4mLC4R4GgNQhN73YTtwrrvMbW3X3MXc2Jb1f1W6s2F3z8G_RYCW6Pb1Xk1JjxF0W6Wf7Nv8LYfVRW3ffQSN33qNY7N5z105lNZ0tMW10C-wz6dVY2pW4sdSQl19F9-2W8LvCMz6Cz3GYW1hJ2hr4_M9LvW79ytXF2syZ14MrXmnVgvnQZW8Fmrn971MGcBW4RRzPS8ZsBNJW6vlV908_B85LW36S0vl2DZ7X7W21J3j916Vg7jMXtQxHl50klW71Cp8W3t6vn9VpGqgB3Qml0RW4SFFL75t-h18W5Kh-Kj1-xjr_V-kLW44s5GhqW3JXrfP80f9DyW5YSJ-M1932LTW3f63qX5ysRCbN8KrNxlkwx_zf6xrQxH04) [View more news](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf03qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3nLVgtTV-8g6xfXW3BgpWK75qvgtW1TSRVB6NYh0gW7nvsdd5_WbTbW48-yz_8fC2sTW4_NKr78qc9VWW4ST-DT8DKXWjW3gygcz6sP47MW1F2fY07Zsv_5W91jcpH6cWpkCW8c9G7n6Yl2w3W7DS-hT6RPML_W7dfGqj7M0TR6W4pqjwx6KKRwrW12-9g16h8N3QW8QqBvd78FNGyN8Gx46HRhhS8W83Kh2W90MbbMVwrv0B3JT-lYW28pxGr6M4cCJW6x__dn8Qg-VcW2-Scsk22KDRQW5t-4Cv1nFpTnW6W01ln2vnMHKf46Crsn04) [Subscribe today](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf03qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3pYW5RJPWL2hf30RW21bTFC3vpnYsW7sZYtB46R-jZW77G49T5VjsQtW32vqf98lq8HPN3NwgpQJ7JqJW3klHdr8DJKVwW7HQ12-8s6DtmW6rVSq88tPY98W3kHWYl4kd1frW5RxqC84VGKVHW34ZRkZ3KwSTcVBVKRz6sSr5dW8WsSyN2CPlt8W86M6B73kT1RmW15NnhQ1y0kRBW7WH93H5KnFX3W2qDbzc77GC_BW23LJqB1bg9KRW4wdjbx747Bs7W5LK_xM3JVkLRVk2B7z3LYrqBW18jVnn1r6jGSN4HGZWHRknf6dkQXTj04) [Facebook](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfj3qgyTW7Y8-PT6lZ3lrW657yzp6wgP4yW3sMFzR2Vl21-W3jgPVg8MQ2YXVmpbvK7FhwBBN40p0-dM6NkQVmwg9H8YBbTWW1xJcTj5BdgtdW5pS-033slkknW12jkfg6JbvfwW5c8wj_3QGVT5VVMP-J50S5chW7y7sGh6DLL5hN5mn77b9s66cVjFCC34kQ37gV9Rtj3761pWWW9jVRtf2QcGblW3mH7cB6LdDnsW4Bwt1T4Xj7ywN4M0SLTjtnMCW2Ng8gb5_2GP4W2ldmby9dhGNnVLGVfL7YlVRYVccgLh3x_mJJW7XfjXj2gYjfGVWp7CP4tqMF_W694fK97PstSNf141-Vg04) [Twitter](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf03qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3mBW1w6Dlm6lk2vbW6zpZlL9bGHznW6-w39l5BjrwLW7Hs3506Y8HVDN4LZyqNcncT6W8t8LYp3ryMWSN2r7JyJGynvwW7xVjky8LWhDPW5JJYMm339QkDW4wP7rr4wjlX-W2YslyX1YWGb4W3-7Pp83-scxrW8Hf7Xk2xr9zHW8yXBX-50lGrBW1dLFdz67cN7RW44mzSn5D-FfrW2Jw78Z4nsWMTVMwLYJ1dMwhNW3Kgb812ckc0QVrz17y1L2mhvW7QL_z_4GZ8PKW7b--zV1cWTXwW88q-mq7wzLQtW48MMMY8n7vY1f6jx-l404) Important Notice We will soon stop sending Breaking News email alerts to users opted into our Daily News send. To continue receiving Breaking News email alerts, please [click here to update your preferences](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgcR7S_YxW50l5tj6lZ3l_W4TpvHp6xrr_XW3R4hSj1XscpnW5RRPdC45pZG7VjfSvQ8wmL4JW78yHWw8v8x8nW4GZxw_6nT6m3V7-MxH7rzjgyW5rJmZr1zbCssW78Qdlp20SG9RW2NZRCX41jvNrW4vJnYB29GlqhW5mFn412cPP3ZW6109hj7wYfs8W1pMYcY4gV3q5VvWmKT1X440hW1kwZj_1vnY9BW6YHl1J5BLfJ6W5Wr_Dm3j9pNFN76wzq8_JsdDW8Z35BN3gByh4W6tG3sF2tb5tdW1fPJdl1wbSZRV6Wx8k3D5n91N3PgzHwh7LCyW926764498VMpW6-L4Hn4fXFtpN7mFSGWyPXbFW9g6nsR2RmQWlN544sqT6nZqhW53SPVq5tjKVbW8rg3yk1cW_ypW2Gc0GQ71mRmDW25SGsZ77bYtdW76szLF1sLpkcMNK6_4LSQsNW5hKPT15ZcSxKW1rPdwT94ZB-MW2HM_M-1HCXHdW5H4Hmv3j35RNW8Mxy7X5DGhDmW6dV9rS4HgQGzW14-p_V7tmnD3VbQxCx5TGWxlW7sWB1J3kj3MdVmG0R515RPMXN2QhgC39ZSCxW8SZPWL2-71FHW7-S3F25NZSZQf2ZPzcq04) You have received this email as you are opted in to newsletters from The Scotsman. [Log in or create an account to manage your newsletter preferences.](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgf03qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3mtW7RpsG74YYHb7W2v-NxC8KFhB6W2v1vnJ8rYNsNVHc7jj4gyn1BW2fdxvF8Vk9PjW1S5QRS2cj5n6W3HbWz06dXSJ9W3RmGP06qdFbtN1_bnmjBFWsBW5wjMyn3kM2FgW4F-qCd5tz_HYV8Wdms6QJP8yW17Gjg-6f8TqHN6C8sskBmvm2N5KZQfx18zSgW19kTR84BZ5yGW95Xlkh14zXt4N3jC0JwG5bKNW8_vrN44ZmRq_N89kz35KdfYTW41XT8D415gn3W54bM7L7C_HV5W7wkYF69j5mr5VhKQx93qlgxyf8TN4w604) You can also change the [types]( of emails you recieve from us or completely [stop all]( emails. [National World Publishing Ltd] Published by National World Publishing Ltd Registered in England and Wales (11499982). E3, Joseph's Well, Hanover Walk, Leeds, England, LS3 1AB, United Kingdom. We will process your personal data in accordance with our [Privacy notice](113/csmbM04/VWn-b91MtJdvV1lWvZ4lhcjkW1-ywb159m-CXN4CDgfj3qgyTW7Y8-PT6lZ3p3W3HDvXz4lySXJW2h4jpJ7f9tFDW86Sw677rgWRBW7_ljc688GmYpW5bVYr06sCWnGW6Bm1p61_XWj5W1YLQdx8Lzj-HW5__79m4wFKVdVZjTfr6dhrQ7W4jYjDQ1B8K5BW34zGNl8Bk9lkW6yzGvs7NcHWzW9ltjL18TfhK0W42_KWC7kyvCDW7KHXQ76df5RxVG1BV96w7wtPW4XnD7x2fSB_PW2Pyspm3r-Lg4Mp-G-0XnSfpW7gvjJF23pd21W6ZyN8r3k3Y4MW1htrtX4jGLWGW6nr6pS2SdzYLW60M9b-69_7bvVVbVy4727sbhW2f8Y3P1kH8z4f8vnHRM04).