🔴 Scottish spy suspect 'stayed on WhatsApp groups for months' after arrest

Human rights group: ‘No-one told us about China researcher’s arrest – he stayed on our WhatsApp groups’ [View email online](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSnb5nR32W95jVnq6lZ3pRW24vGcj5P_j5QN99KF49pKpZqW17J7xW8_LXxnW2_qgtS8zc8FPW6-tqL947Y7FtW78XNPV2RSQ-JM8XBMYJQDLCVxK5xL1TxzTsN8TZzRNv6C6NW4bXd5-1_G31xW4X8z8M73v-rQN1l7G0GC1RtLW62bKz92kM11qW2l3g6s2DW5kfW2Dcrdl2ntn1VN6GPdptpRrs3W7FlSLq4F8BbGW7kKTMR20JLdsW58yczP1LyS-hN84YsLrpHmVnW4KMLjH5zVvQ_VbpgJm1ngMkbW3ctwYX1SYBDjW6zTrM375cdQ_W2TyLcJ3FDKHtW4n4-Cs4j2Z9YW1fWHh_2VBQpZW19f7X98j_0-ZW3D7CrG3HZV4XVcPMWh2wKjyqN60mKJFVSPdvW2vh1p27-qbXBW6pbP9p3LhSpnW5fG1Jb31xWFQW31GP6v6Md4FNW53kZg348VQZQN6p4XPcD1pWcW7n_GkF6Zhdt4W5M79bJ3q4SjgW4DJ6Df6Cc9BdW6ZmfN-5rzfgyW6h6Fz_85H77QN1Qm6z8hg51XW2NgKqr2X5gcLW3vHmhy4WQq3wW2b8Q4h3mGZf2f7LZ97P04) [Subscribe today](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmC3qgyTW7Y8-PT6lZ3mLW5KB5TL5rZRn1N4ZPpLCJV7CbN4-MYWsLPjt9N5T0p9480hZKW6x9c0H3_ssldW3jb0fl5QwTB4W8-DlfW39kyNPW2qXBG-2rVy5hW3cgwR-8m7TRtW7VGX6l7zJh12W1gmJLq41B-twW6jkqzR1C1VnHW66CTBF5ZYvxrW4mFt8426FCl0W7GB0Rb5Zsz47W17_Npj218xYtW5_Ds9W24dGZ0W3DD3TG8DrPP9W4zWdY84_TryWN5vYYY_666hvN6xcllTcfsgfN8CtZnKJgT3tW5DP5kC8WG-1sN475QkSGXBqDW6xrMqD6Q8fJbN4plPfLxhlW5dyfBP004) [Facebook](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmC3qgyTW7Y8-PT6lZ3n3W2RBz-J6Z3bG2W4nQSp343qFNZW2l5rSG3_C4tmN35wgkddx2HfVDBYnC8hV2M1W4dVLcp4zWxRtW1Lf_4b6mkZDZW4gVPfv1mWqqRW11tqxs84bDC-VtF9-n6jNH1KW9f6Q4L42MsgvW8gjXZr2wq83gW83t8kD4VHjXHV-DFxr6HCWQfW6KXQDc5QRKkZW6RshvN1HHy6MW7Lv8q07HBZ6VN8MqkS3PbBhMW47-f8H3wtSrrW87zxvS6Y0PqFN7vqNHCM3VZpW1yfrNM83C7LmW8dzmkN8WKbRYW5NYjY55pLCVbW8LVb8g83KxfBW8y97TZ5Kn14kf6cC05204) [Twitter](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj3qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3nXN31lwSy7WWzKW4KdNnm3TLXRNW39sF6Z6ZZxkVW3zhyMP5jtX7rW2XLF9P3nTF7jN27F06p4M0_mW3sZL2y2ttM1LVnN3PT97XSlsW650Sr_4Dmy4RW4SjVqQ19PmqwW3JTbbS2SJlMDW50ymjM8-8vssW4HcDc23jR3SRW3KSmPk4YvnR7W6WGd3N2bLXKJW47ydrD2Ffy1gN5nvpcJ9frfZW3Hb-2x3CtF65W3BzdX_5L0Lm-W2HYfsp3h_YqXW86GskG3wrgGDW6wzlF63dK4tSN1Y5xK5FH8CwVQ-tz18M0cRsf2WRpfT04) [The Scotsman] Sep 12, 2023 Good morning readers. How are you this morning? Here is your Tuesday morning newsletter, brought to you by [The Scotsman.](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj3qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3mFW53yK4y6XT8qxW6tkxyB4PyKrJW2nTMfj1Y_85dW8pBqrT5rCS-lN95NM9vRPh8VW3zJP2C3YYqVnW6h80DP5dFPGLVcmd4G5dFscjN22nWn6N4y0wW2wY7k93HN55lM1Fk3pdt7vjW4l3y_99dNs-xW8Yvl3Q3bbJC-W650_by32tn4vW8lrP8x3rhDTJW15CYPl3R1vrfW7ltNQx4vDNjQW41xMRx7Ry09GW6xd8WB8syzVnN55fh3Q7sf_dW1KKtSW85JvLVW14Cpn219w_szW5NRDYJ2DPKXSW2fRHbN8Y49RTf13WnW004) Here are 5 of today's top headlines - Premium: [Scottish spy suspect 'stayed on WhatsApp groups for months' after arrest](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj5nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3nkN5gTCXqZvzwQW2Yf75W3PFM55W311KWz1cQvF9W2_M7j26pCfmlW7CQ_zM2PFlcWW6J0LXd5WtFcxW4z1BF43LyrrXW2h0Qhv2WpHMTW5FJkBK2rXDLRW3cm2TY3vPblRW4LS1BP8gy_RgW3tld9z5t7_PwW5w82Mg1stbq2W992plf1sXkFSVQNKGK8MxMddW1J61ld2NTq6GW95nq9729FkFBW643QVF7p6SNzN6krChtmpn8yW8gTP0s8tRr_fVKgQdm2pC6psN8DgQf9ZhMg-W1LmGB97hLp2QW70Gj0n6XkgbwW6CJ79G1pdgn1W43XH6B43NbxyW7qc53P7WHJSqW8lT2F_6Rq7Q5W1NrNZs4fJJzPW8y9hvq54fmdNW4Wsb-31-QT29W5BPK-p4SSK95W80Lh-R6GpGQ2W1Lybvw5LZB7mVKWxxd7zp58xW4TKW225rvFnjW5T1lQT67y1-6N2707SW7zYnHW517qLg6183ccW6xmYLH8yHn6cf6GG9Nz04) - [Football: How Scotland can qualify for Euro 2024 during England match](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSm05nR32W6N1X8z6lZ3p1W970Dpc8gFGlZW4K4QMn4zQ3LhV-gpc97_CTSNW53PvFc6mYTnHN6Sf8pBzfL7VW7QHVFK8gXwHPW5RqtZM8pdQ5dW2cs2Gq1thb9mW6y0vtp19VlzjVS5Lfj8Fly_xN4L3Sqq3_3gBW53QJwk7235gpW57CXxF4DtWdbW2Fq2yC6xY7_TW9cTKfG1dCrwDW2Ph8fm5y7HtZW3hSMhv7tdg08W19ZPpB6BX3J0N6vy0W4Fjn2XW6FCBf91WrgMDW85KTq18w9qtLN7ZlKrQxwt0yW6t4yJC2SnmR9W1M7jSG99qsWYW2D7W7m1pbYLgW7W0NNQ4DsSHbW8cmM4d1cxC3kW8tnBSd46l0l_N6wlTJYXdDxnW68ZNP_6Tc7Y7W2SBP-Q3xlytqW7WpVtJ310XCXW960Mrz847ckPW6BStKr98z-JYW2xWqtG8GXthYMPSKH1v1JMjW9g-l9S5vCLnyW760qqr8VRBqLf6LW54404) - [Columnists: Drug consumption rooms wouldn't be a game-changer, but would save some lives](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSm05nR32W6N1X8z6lZ3nwVjGGLK8wVMX7W2xCctX1B16_SW7tTkwF7KvPCBW7kyywy5vgNR9W2Zr0Z75YJXx_N7vXPfyphPQcW81HyZ714Zwr4W8Q-bNQ9gHVSdW6fR1hK50ml6JW45pMWy4CCvfyW2nqpSf4dxgxgW2Y4sH06f73tDN14KmYqRkhH_VNZwmt1cHRpFW9hSwMY6b4WgLW1SzGXj8BXv8CVB6j8X2Dmd6_W4rdNP11XQYVnW7mm1Hr8NJL_cVPxVpN319YBSW3QtNDx74rSctW9klCWt2BGtGQN4NssQxSgW6dVfFHZ08lspSKN5fVc9wfLrgLW9c-N_P3vXjTwN159cjY3hRyZW9jDlzC693t65N2-RcT6Rg-JLW2l_vKX6nj6-jVS_26F2WbJvtMvhHJ6LXX-0W35zrck4BZlTGW1dW36X3Kr_5pVjd3357DwPbqW6tP8vf3RL9SDW7fBVLf8tNxwhW5LkXsf2r_3bLf5mRG-R04) - [Scott’s Porage Oats Man: Who is he? Why was he replaced?](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSl65nR32W50kH_H6lZ3q7W6DPR_5481GLkW9djG0d45WrvlVgw-c252gxvQW7QPq2T7S26mKW5jzSBy89jvF5W5gTqWM77dc68W4rpxGN3v9F85VN5Ldv7TWxyBW263F4L3NDFBGW7q5JlX5cv6w7W1b8sqt851RVSW5fKnsX9k5LwcW5p-6Y96LLlTyW77PFR_1kVl3xVyv5lb6FsTJtW1FMTvJ6hcXnDW7HT2_L4nWZ1TW1JpmRs7htwfBW83lW6v7WSBpmVk4s-c6K9wHTW4MSmPD8ZqfjnW5NHSr76mQqdbW78ljQL4R4g70W107w0N16YzG5Vw1w202tR26xW4FHnSr65Tl84W8sMLnl4pCdtVW5vd2Wp6h7qLFVG2rhl3W31y9W1H2c0j4pgLFYW5QK6vg19dGC6N4PjTbDSxZCYf4trzgx04) - [Film: The true story of Hollywood movie that saw amateur traders bring Wall Street to its knees](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmC5nR32W7Y9pgv6lZ3pMW5M7q9711By10W2c2q_t3nsX7FW2B8H8n3SYXz0N8XS9ntf0ScnW8ZVQ2Z46qg8MW4M58n05-bzt8W3B4Lgq4r9F7SW1m9FH24dB2psW87Bbks7kDlqDW2SDSwl5_GxKqN4VY4j39BFbzF3Ds_Fnzyx9W3fczWx7YnQP0W5P5HcM4GHV3sW1SSk_n21g5YTDHnGkctHK8W7--BHs4kQ8vyN2NYZQfSHC8HW1VmJ236BCxJdW1TRSYy70mcY-W1NSSqX73BQy9W7vv_pT7xlbJqW4qD8tV1jRYqbW97QmhR6JYCW8W1XQZv55HVKG7V4yqbw1j9qTnW83M44y8wBdcSW4CbN5K1DkxCwW2wBS5G6j-wxyVcQjs_75MPjXN2zzwDcK3v6WVjdDVW4WRb40W4KT2v88wltlpW5kwj9D5gVhKVVv6cqk4pLP8TV5Y8yZ2-YBxFW244J1q4NxznPW3LxwVm2qy2TDW5jPHtd1nXktlW4T2T0Z4sz3V7N65brglMNPc6W1W5FfW1f7slkf72V_0H04) Thanks for reading, more headlines are below. Graham Falk [Human rights director says Scottish spy suspect stayed on WhatsApp groups for months after arrest](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj5nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3n4W5NhN8j8VzkY0W4bF9m93YYdq3W3F33vP2PNJPVW9c7N1S2LFGxYW6cGc2f5RqfGHW8FcHL77hHrDpW2YGGS15sJ4yRW4FnNgx8xj6z5W3338hw4jJLqCW5s2yRG3FRZFrW6lYQRs7z5M76W32x4xn2ywdgbN5bXQQyz_blYW1M19FC4GXyC0N1MC2c4M5twgN19-36BcB-GrW2fGmlV5v48kZW6_ThXq7xJ_G1W6ghZYr8F70VlW1291Fy3FvPtTW2Q7SrB9d9ZL_W9bJQgM8BQZ5FW8_q4DW2n53kkV-_v-43KYLs5MMr6Q-52yDyW97LWbG3jY01YW1bwvMn8Hf1m5W8N7Spj3SwtCsW3lZpJN2H-z_vW96DdB84c-SG4W2ZQMdw8kndHSVQ-ycv6Z7_4WVZ0s4v3Sx8jVW1ZDV-V18J28wVd_1lB5qT8HhW1RpPcl2wbzdfW8FS0Q_5t3hv1N1Z77cP5VzjNVFJqJw2jMR7HW5D7rYK1XzF3Lf1qSdX204) Human rights group: ‘No-one told us about China researcher’s arrest – he stayed on our WhatsApp groups’ [Human rights director says Scottish spy suspect stayed on WhatsApp groups for months after arrest](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj5nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3l7N2frZZdpYvmrW7r13dY7QWz9fW4jSGtQ2ybH4_W4d7Jdv10Hz97V8MrYD5VKNQDW6C_Jf21S7MnPW6QQ6ms4-hXz8V6dGpz4DCxMlW2x17s86G3ms7W8dDXTs2G_gqCW1qyghF8qvCrlVXTgmS7czB80N3WXF_HDJ-sxW3hgNpc2BHjRPW6dNX5q6y8LrdW88bkWy53FNStW4Yr1pP3KfppKW5l-MKZ65v9sVW5CWkyc4lr9f9W7bl_P52vsbRvW88b_Yq3VKWpbV6_VMd5FnTb8N7M4hvK1yTG3W7LDR9D85CmwNW19Vw-Q5fllkNW4NsV6f38b14jW4jmcV82BLyv6W4bZymB3mV77rW45z8Z172YTFZW3t_LkM4j8mM3W2-K-vD5jj5PNW1p5GnW2gDfVbW5PWz_f7nZvZRW67_8bW16SNfbW1V9-9t1HStnYW8DNV0b7SZcxKW2XW58B2jxsNQVlwHnh1C9FqlW3-Bx4-4bgmd7N5Yxw9F9NXBbd-c-RC04) [Are you a business owner?](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSnb3qgyTW95jsWP6lZ3kBW4HyMVS59xDLLW5YsbtY7Q8hf_W2Gzzgp6D1SBlW7Nd2Zf5FtxvbW1Fy1MV55ZDzpW3NSm0P6xtGxhW6FjVCL2yYT-kW6WWfl423fwWSW75G5N37yVN5_W78Dzbq3P-k04W5d-3Rq2H-G-jW16yMst7YgW6PW3CvP5_8T13-kW2qkqjP7lWQBcW8f0yCl5XnXW6W2MNVXJ6GSRlQN74jnt1Fg8LBW2Vb3wy4HDb4gW7z36v66qLjx-N8LhyvVq1CC_W47sfFX85p_QZW4hsZ9L8W_KbcW21jHpL2g30k2W6SGmcY2sGzbgW8qRfbd6hkMRJW72sp1P40DMWqW8jyvLc4D2zf9W1Y_YKp63FKM5Vm8Sdj29gRP-W6Mbw6f1j3bPDf1hT-VK04) [Readers' Letters: It's time Scotland had a chance to vote in government that works](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSm05nR32W6N1X8z6lZ3mBN7cC4CjZMMDqW2SrFbH7plV5cN5nww1zkTGDgW6xlnR66npmBfTMwMf5qhW3pW7wy-cH8__dz_W1fbqTR2VSDnLW7wkCkr3d6rJnW4sSYYn7qGvPqW5PskRZ9lV0VMVzJJ0q6mD6kzVRr2m48h1GpzW2vWmPc21XnTwW6fMws83R33b7W10DxtW2v6tyjW1hz22V4zx1Q0V4MBJm44M3rfW3vGMHn9bXXDVW5CqD8V3h8tK0W5tp61Y2Hw5YRW1R99pG8-P3K-W4PNYd43hH2kwN42vBRG-99zSW2swRXV3Ts6s3W3W-1Pn618JnKVg0zWq2frMLNW2xTgr088YH8XN1VR22hqn6BQW5jnH9f7Xt-SfW2GTrQp2SV89BMwpcV3WLn4VN76g0GwWnm0bW3pmYZ11trkq2N1xbPJ6RmSsfV_jNZt6k7BSZW940y252TP5N5W6_bfF93BC_GmW4hTMBv554FCxf6QP0W004) [Readers' Letters: It's time Scotland had a chance to vote in government that works](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSm05nR32W6N1X8z6lZ3ncW7djpzD8wnq79N5dFRKQTWkBQW7mxxWw74Npm5N5Td_W2BB53WW8cLjCZ1SwNwgW1T7GQ78kCRKMW5PcpYk7gT1ktW8V8fq72HwvTfW88gsYk2g84ZPW5qbsW22R0mPCV1hTsY2n1R_RW2lywvK63jSDWW11G2hP61-Sf8W1BXS--4rPX98L9pLQVw7j-W39f2zB3142YYW8KX9kG5DlNzvW57MLzS6GdGgqN3wr7T31964WW5yH0P55lmk6GW512Y-G2wmwZSW3Gv4-J6GLphQW9cch2y4KCt2PVJgYhs2r_kzTW1Q_sTy90H6tKW3t41Zy3ypGjLW7fWf_l6vF56gW94lDqF3qL0lRN5gH2pdWvtzFVYrgLZ71JJknW5bFmMS4q1dnVW6tNTGs7DnmFsW6Z5jBW1C953bW8_TvTw2wz-QlN2YtlSGbx7mzW7rWZQC4YfpqvW5Gw6yy2Ykrc5W3p7B3C90QgLYf7tHbd004) [Article Image](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmW5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3kYN3zj6fF_fPwpN57t7hj4BXY6W4JGQBn6sjTVgW2QqXZW7BBYBYW2SR0Vr716-3pW6j-0f570gSzcN6HJ85tRNhPfW6jxflX3VBZBPW4DlWLz93BQ6hW67Mz7n6lT1tlW4T2v0_3Nb10BW6DC96W6bL1s0W7C7FyM41_JHKW5v-w877PnQfyW7wtFdj7-C3KsW2b1DJm7yn4T3W5LpNt72jN8G0W6BzqZF8T49-nW3K9rSJ55WmhdN6Ttw82SxWZ6W8kZ-JB32pqb7W5xDlPN5bWP5qW1BLFZZ8pByn3W2k9dwJ3Y6Cd4W1F42wK4Pw96kW820BKz836mTGW1zFCP66tt9GvW5F4BGd5WFTH7W3Y0fxv3pC18mW7R9YGL8YDS38W8lXDF_7wJxhDW4g9Wtd4mWZLLN55ss_9fwXX9N8CPNZQybdm9W2Q3RmL2hZKlWN3s2B3h60LZVW500Y6X8fKs11McC-XfRGkD8W40rXsr74RHsvW7s-DF78HhR14VtY0d03m3lXSVfHQ5m6jSt-QW24qbhJ1CxqWNW17B6qk24bWzlf10V1J604) [Take a deep dive into the Scottish housing market in new Property Podcast](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmW5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3mXW3jtY9b34nr4jW4QpNGc14Mq5PW74-ynf3LvGNjN8m6GP7_ndGgW2N_p5b481dTVW7NCHSC4rL_hmW5D8ryF34l5LrN8k_gp1QwkvfVtjldt5dt__7W6kr8nW3clPjbVWWlq_5g7CG_N8ZZs3rbpWysW5db5SD2P1sYzN97_h6pV9b1nN5Gx2xCNbQpNW77Q7z48r3pPKW8tZmG56JLBl2W7_R8Bv1rpLmXV_LGyB1htfqRVFjcB15VQYVZV8qmGY5ZDP7XW6BQ-D34HwT5bW30dgGd7y9ClnN5KRMHlLFZQhN4n9QYhpNngdW13P-L-4NBzpqW3ZV75B65tbs8W1gbF6n7QrNgqW2VSqxv2FTQgVW7X6wvk4nxVm0W7DM8Qs1wZqxBW1ds4jj57TCWGW8Vs_Fk4khcf-W2YYSwm2XPh39W8yQnj61HxVFlW75vj115X2lqNW2WHccl7JpB3KN2kBJX3rfTzKW5v3mGq2bMy-XW7mv7QQ76V_3xN5Pp-7-GVKwNW8YKLvp27d6HxN5WzYDK9cHtpW3mv98M247vMbf96NWq404) The first edition of our new Scotsman Property podcast is now available, made in partnership with DJ Alexander. Promoted by DJ Alexander [Scotland Street Volume 17, Chapter 7: The Man in the Rhododendrons](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSlq5nR32W5BWr2F6lZ3p3W3xlLmC2Jyt2yW23s82f3pH0J8W3n2-QG1tC7H-W6vrv3h7l9Ss7W3nD-PC7mG0nzW6YnLx62bwNyKVHGwDd6ykmd5W408T60359gZCW8smgv51TB_dwVMvwSj7CKFrVW4vCBm21GLSd7W3bQLY16G1KH_N6MMsHBh2VsMW10SPh289LqtZW73Qy4C5s4zFcW7JWh5K5Q2Fy_W7Df2n216vS37W5rSTqw5HPHRMVXnCdG1LRkLcW4NbjPh6QHP5pW5h0J7Q5qh4kCW6VVJgD48MvC1W7jn5t_68c_d8W4Yfkj49hs37MN28wtd8JSD41W6n9hx55bL9wbW1D-mhr3ysM-yW1BDPrv6qWs-kW4KnWlx29CSGJW5MbRzM1C091MW5_nw6b568xw5W6fwk4C3C_Gw2W1fCt7l1sXC8QW4RMCTf7kbtzzdMLv8004) [Scotland Street Volume 17, Chapter 7: The Man in the Rhododendrons](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSlq5nR32W5BWr2F6lZ3lSMdpDV4xwXB3N6cB5SW4T0-KW61NJyY6K0B8CW3ZvTXM2Y9sgmW6F5kQB6mR6X4W3PZpnT3MvdjTW608jjm9d5mW1W3MJrLv1CnZ0CW36tQ172TTBsFW7-X4pN86hM6zW1F61dp3jxjNnW18XFZb73WvgRMGxGCGCFqbLW1xMzBS5VC5QLW4rPQCT46zVVvW73ggfs7VGxrrW8CKM-478519gV6nsPj43wDjnW6Sf14p1RsxbxW227pdG7cBqRvThdr28TxpTVW93nNw31zxkPRW21PpDy4nQxnyW8Sf6tV41lVdjW42gQXX5WdrRtW8Xr7Yr4Lmlm3W2mszTg4LbkHgW2nSl-S8zWYJHW92qwwV3dJ8fjW6yrlgz1-h1wtW5XMXzD6D1qk4W2ynyKQ5WKrdHW4xTBlK8tYbHhN5gHY7mPhTXyf6v-3VP04) [SNP and Labour class war on private schools doesn't help pupils – John McLellan](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmW5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3pNW6-wftZ9kdb4VW3sglLX4pjbNmW2PgR1D8M6f8mW1vBfYS4rhQ17W4crqWb47bzJ2W7syrlJ5kLkg8W2NySBB1lRPtkW6BTbNL7B44lrW940GjT5dX0skW8J-_jt2t7nfBVSt6Qm5gyjKtW8b8V_W41mPn6W3xCNlD8XfcL_W6Q0FYX470vNZW32rSDS3W-KqdN53Yr9YL1syWW5cqXcp550QFZW2rMG-G4gvyM_W8X4Nwb2_45MyV3PZXq6wb5HrW7Kb5P56wrXVmW45rwZ322743cW3Qn2nc7Ys2PLVJ66js3F-njTW46_hWj2jQ1dRN2BMXYVJM7WkW5Lm_Y86y9GNtW6TN3Ch8DrSZTW2KlWkN8P8VQ0W76hk1X2TWpDnW5PFGzd5gjm3WN3LDfdmmwZQtW94B-Mq2h1-qsN83Kq96Y2ZG8W1Bb71K7LnDVBW69wtTx799YKqW4BWh335rwmhVW31Lldb98zVs1W95JGdn97ysLNW2bPrCy6_-gtmN6Cd61tQlttbW268D-q8BDVCfN4v26-6B0ZbXW9cxn1_1-4FDZf8BShPC04) [SNP and Labour class war on private schools doesn't help pupils – John McLellan](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmW5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3pXVlb99x2TyGCRW4yBm6W3hB9DxW4X4Vyp77R_GbVhX-3N4CWjkPW6qBqfC9j0bK1W2g3PR18p06TjW8XvbF_5TZht3W5tYK5N1N9FF1N7k_CnBjQ0T4MR-fKctQSjGVF053X5Zmx0wW4FFhbt5GDQL_W5q7HjV1tvQ10W5dTrXg8F9yxgN6YxXR9LHDhZW1Lj8Sg6mk6TJW8xwTdK7RDpSrW5f-cqg3-x-P8W4Z8k0K6VQHLPW3vwXwP1Rq1YQW3dTYt79kY4cdW4NKDQH5Nmn51W6DNbt74cCF4MW7Pcf0q1dp_pPVL24vf30VrbQW5DhDm47t_VrJW6Kyg6d5Fg-cdW4dB6zF5fPm47W2HksLq18tVdpW4y7XCz2GBWcDW8YfyMN6KZy7bN3nFwPQR8vwQVtvPq520cj_SN5KybVbMx4tKW2N5wW58nMGxrN46pS3z3-j3YW2F1hRY7CGMwCW10-Bfj8S4ZWtVXmhTc7lhBr-W2drt4L1xHywLN754wzbqqK4sW5LjfDf1CqmPZW87Kp0h5lR9ZRVQ3_qZ57BJrcd4d2TH04) ['We intend on taking full advantage of the trust shown in us by our investors': spacetech scale-up Krucial lands funding](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSlK5nR32W69t95C6lZ3mDW8r_BRK3-Lh6NN8895-2H1XV7W7SFVhs6qFp6RW7rX32j5-L_SxW7PlJqG9hRmPTVXXXVG7gbWQ7W4RXKCt4dVHbKW122DfF30GMyMW5yRy1N3Jcp6nW4NPt2W4K_J9BW2Q9dsH3Yn3ChW4x6CrD7gZrZGW7jwfkV2bhhbWW3lvqfJ5zxkb5W6Vn4-v88qwcDW6Y4lN2868CRKW4z8gr17qF_FMW7N1CTX1t8bDyW53CJWV1Y0c1gW4MV0dw2g0ycJN2MwWmzRpqKhW5m71hD1nlvD4Mr8_jVFNFPwW4hhG4J3tKhl7W4PLFpv7y74jFW5_tRZm1xG-cfW8L1DqZ5tv0D_W6Wkldy1S0THMW3PQxwG6GkKYfW22Mtw74sTL5jW7CMND83Cs4rbW1ZKST57t_hGXW8gR3Wc1HF1ZSF7X1qP7v2dmN8zfss7L76P_W8YrCCG8FxDjtf2vtlFn04) ['We intend on taking full advantage of the trust shown in us by our investors': spacetech scale-up Krucial lands funding](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSlK5nR32W69t95C6lZ3ljW7cw91H7sWxhMW4Dn2Tg2jKghVW1PPtTv23r_BjW4rQS3j3qfDwfW6dxsy92ml-W1W6Dw64T8MCzfPW44QFtf8rJnqnW6fz6Dh62YytXW87zjtM6BNnJ-W1MmmrY56zRJPN5npWXlLfmQDW4rxn8m5V5XcgW6JGPF-3Kn8sMW5FHq-V8Y9thbW7KyMYC4-L1mlW1BYk0b1TD7fjW2Mdwdg2MCWDbW63Rm5Y2QzDHQW30qV--4kcSkLW2rGB4M42drnMW61LFYj2vJMhQW7BMMx55zBn3kW8w4Zq24P4_4tW1vyqyt4bCMQdW3yfMH67dC98zN59Qthml7ZCFW337Phz1rYhltW6XxzL74R0GxzW95r2_l5yLMBSW2KFvB91wC_zDW83k_FP5vMQCkW42wGcH8d7pxGW7zdJXP5RwH6LW2nfZYR30QQXZW72_9m71FZv1RN8hwq5Fk_4NKf83lXg804) [Dundee's V A museum is a wonder of Scotland and worth far more than just its contribution to the economy – Scotsman](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSlq5nR32W5BWr2F6lZ3l3VGZx_h16tRs_W1_0QmL8z5ZSqW1hYybK7hWCjzW6BzJTc3LZqQpN24KmvYkp2N-W5qqlHS49JqjYF8zsjsqSYjpW3q9RB137kJZqW8xzPdf8G8D0YW6LBKPM47x_NzW98wP5S2dw2vsW3gHd9X6Zwmm1W3r3DC17SNBkLW7S6TkX3y36GpW8PrLFP6g-h78W3zrVGJ60K7QyN7H71GhTrtqBW2SmnV124jVJsW6B5wg03mz1F1W7YG5Qg61KM7QVbCnsY5Vv0y0W4sgdrF7x4j6JW99zLW751k0c_W6S48Q-7fLn4FW9d4M3D7HKvL8W8rNyNJ4Kq63LW2V_Ksm5DSxCSN5T25DMH_jPGMMQj1ZFTVZkN13YVKJQ-XjXW8bvt4H1kmG-xW3VjxrZ6qw57RW7xFlBl4VRhByW1krDLm76YGL-f7P70Kn04) [Dundee's V&A museum is a wonder of Scotland and worth far more than just its contribution to the economy – Scotsman](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSlq5nR32W5BWr2F6lZ3nmW5CT55v3jBxnKW2mJlZt3znm_YW3QdlBP2FQWQ7N6XvcVd8ZDzBW5CK7F92Vz-PjVp579y3MnwsCW70C2S87h9lgTVH1nJJ4vq4Z7MsnK2qsyf6YVm-TLW4F9DBsN2WHhyx8MpZDW4DHblw7jkQZ3W4j21tr3jNSm7VwdxKF2wLlPXW6Z0BYZ2TVdyFW2N-3_p5-gTd-W4Bp6n54bzXY5W5Lk-0C2_g1rWV7ZFZQ9dlpZYW6HNBXg3_j-9nW3W33kX2-6h3gW4GGxCg5-0yjjW48kX5q93Y23zW43mzRd73T5kYN62JYJGD_CL_W1YTh3J7RhRpbW14XKMW8BGPb6W6FBt4L8cj_v1W8tfRz63rv_tPW4vS9bh1ks0c9W6M6_NS2zVx5GW44Lyh-3mBsYRW17WnfN6yycdJVQG1DV6lr0TTf4j7WVT04) [Scotland Food and Drink Excellence Awards showcase how diverse and creative our food and drink industry is](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSlK5nR32W69t95C6lZ3pnW8Gdl9h59RcSbW8PNdDL1KlGjnW52H_TV3n20d9W3Rb05v1BmLdmN4RWt_GP-LCwW5WG-1d3f7wrNW7FGl4p2hMqpRW37d7d63dC21LW61YGY07pqFlVW2S6Cvm4B1Rc1W63FFDs3NmlwMW6k18153rg2p1W60KsGv1St36JN5ylKbnn1mL7W1rG7654VVLPWW4VFTMJ9gLHN5W5WzRh03VJY0ZW4sPYF774vLW2W5yz1Xg2THG74W9hWQPr4JZ4ZcW4R___r8btrdjW2Kg6gn7nt4c7N5X9GYPk5TMQW7Ds58f5GFDkRW4Pv2JS1167lTW3X-s5t7zRBnTW1n20jn1fSn4MN2wzlJZ5HjzDW1JCTsr253pxVVWNg8892FBtSW5l4Bc06cs-4lW831YH22KMtBtVTwQt88Djx6wW1JYKpw6bN6bHW293s1b480D77Vq_ZFr25sM-rdQ1gwg04) [Scotland Food and Drink Excellence Awards showcase how diverse and creative our food and drink industry is](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSlK5nR32W69t95C6lZ3mqN7dyY3gZq4sWW33G_WP7kMxWfW582kX971rxxnVK79q13YKtVZW8fSnmZ6tPNbgVzlRvv6txsTMW1JCVWS8XpW3cW6rmhM-32l9tDN6B_xVxpQHy6V6dc-p6BQSYCW8NzmVg3NcvcFW8lb5-p16RGr5W2j3-tK4q2sQdW5L-6Wd7gvHtHW5w95pq97QbfNW4-xDNx3GpQZ9W6gBZPj88gfvDN5PtmVs7nM8tMBSWNnMpmd2W3MlTPg1VZWFKW8vWsTW8-9bstW2yfh0069VtQ5W1XQqZn7MfWbZW2g_DT_5s0_RsN8VK7GmqRQ68W98GfsZ8zMKXkN3pMWNFPSNjfVyl5fF90P5GMW7NKNSJ21YhzgW7F_F3l5FWM1mN5-63kFcWWCNW592-SK6B6_h5W8PnBss3N25RxW10qrZt37tMXXW3X67Dx2BK49TW1hWSNj3tPg4Xf6N1FCj04) [Interview: Andrew McPherson, The Balmoral - From tomato chopping to running one of Scotland's most famous hotels](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj5nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3mKN1hvGGPMF8H7W2Wdjns5VLwBPN3DWCtRM542hW66QwK72gyLCWW6V3dBl5xdvNtW7WMp4V6tDPVCN5QBL_9f02QBW4clCWg1qg1mbN85pKd32k8HRW8ft8hx2Y6-lQW6KBpTC5FqxFWW2wBWsn1XZVVBW7S-qcg6Jz-j_W5GFh8Q18d08qW5SKqPg7K_M5_V3hL0G80v6XfVJXDDD703nJcW6zGrp15HlMQkW47vhX91fn6S8N7pD1fFLGZ90W4kTKpZ61m77zN4F4b6_WzbtNW1rvmGG8-mh4dW2QXF8Z1DR02MVY1_zl6Q4Sk9N6JHQfqYvnLTW78bgZJ1j47jfVp4MT-3y_ZYnVl3phR4G8GXvW3KcnRh3mfp_qN244R8Ss5Vh5W3qWWXx8-t22tW7n-vj81W6zmRW8wM6QX1xky-qW5YjWbh28KB03W6PxL0x29vMZCW7Kg9QZ7mjxf6W909pHR6Dg7sdW21Qg2h22mvlyN5sZ2x4zy_Bff5Xy9qW04) [Interview: Andrew McPherson, The Balmoral - From tomato chopping to running one of Scotland's most famous hotels](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj5nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3kwW5YyQZR6kHZ0kW5D1-jR70m6fYW6tfDf03YR_rdV6bss45Qsgk_VRLgQP2c_Jj9W7y8tgz9fKkdsW3x8Qtp27Bj6nVZc-hn14fw5BW99k8R8869kVzW7l242f2BWLpJW7jwLgW11Gk0ZW6SsQ3M7xcvtbW149SVT67xT6CVKtt3P4R8p7bW3BYDnX7TY-PjW7Fx4Dh8wjHfjF3tWynpYhslW8VNk_L7Ndhw_W4FjNR23hPhRhW2pBCwz93tHx8W2vDjwk98c-VcW2GHXWT6gZNnDW1LxCpr2kK_43W6b3Rzb4D8BwFN5q5P5GLNgklW8b5W8W6zrB78W4GD5886Yxz7jW4bZSgv6rvwJ5VgDPfC5dPy_8W6q5tJS1H9zJMN1J63nn4GDQkN2Nb6SPvxxx9W4BYx-g55xHjZV___gD78-KsrW5WS4pr7dVcyBW4nRs3h1SbcX-W5pZ6kb3XnGfwW99DJ-H96jnrFW3v5R-36gZ68FW3WkK4W46zsVGf5bxMyF04) [Scotland's overcrowded prisons are an indictment of a society that jails chaotic people who struggle to navigate life](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmW5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3mQW1NMG7p17ccg1W3GgHGL7HrtJjW6VKzCV8b8LqhW2yT2Yt82hDq7VS7pXV5V-t3NW29qWlT6YXDTfW6p68b77gV29wN2cR71L_TNrlV-pHY56c273ZW5xV-hh1vwBy8W27-bCj3S5-YmVFClKy96B6prN34TNdlX3dPvVlCQnJ62yM4ZW6KmwDg81NP0KW1jbH868YLXhPW2fzL7c2vJZpLW3sznMh34-k6VV6T0cS6C7HJmW4pHjf97F2ZbTW6nFszy6P54jyW7fg4HS8xlDXKW2fHTNW59w3cvW8H3WLC60CWB5W1xynRr4ZMWy2W413S3R9jnkbGVGbl861nv6mjW3C49__506Y84W8TCldc83jhttW2GVPRX3fPZzNN6FXvwtF7dc8W17GGHZ2PBXFQW5M4P5C2ymM9tW2P9NBs3TBb4FW52Z7nh88_y_WVqQ7jl4ZDkfbW4s8Sn07DpLxVN83kvPwYgcQJW8HTRV53VNn9zW91VPcb76wFcSW8kY8gf93kbqFV41mSM1Q3-7xW7t11SW1yWcKRW2kjPBJ6VK9XRf11wbKx04) [Scotland's overcrowded prisons are an indictment of a society that jails chaotic people who struggle to navigate life](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmW5nR32W8wM7ks6lZ3mdW4JCgYL2b-z0bW1yk77J7R4vNZVgw1jf1JCN7sW6BMGvr5SqWdvN1TSNFQJ-4WbW6b6hzY7stsThW1D3gld6z1Tj5W7k4Tt56jsGXxVw90g21zfRsnW90jgtB1jXRxBW4yrGns7QygcHW7jdCd171dLSsW44jfmd7c9L8sW1GqZGL1SZckBW5-rW3990Jh63W2f2zxr4DMY7nW1vyVJ566PSfcW6mKk5n530GdMW3Bl9Kk7pBbkNW2xqKc04SPhhdW6hrv_-2_61RTW886ctf63l5t-W4MfT-81GsCRkW65cnBd62wn5nW7nqKZH7tCdzQW8zCFMP8LhlYBMh0FgsnqVcWW1xLrhm2lMXvDW1kztF79fVRZHN20DNg4_M2YdVw7xPy4l7gVDW6n_0RT1y-m_jW7nlMS94KC1nWW3f1lTc1JXsFGW4gd1RN4xd4fJW5hglyB60GVk4W8jPjHq5Mmm14W1rMyM24jDyRXW3Y3nCx7sjtFWW46HTQr14mYlRVn_gQq5lqzCYW3zQNz42zlZySVp68cT3pYFJKW5xc0JP9m1QsFdml_zs04) [UK Government labels China a 'systemic challenge' as Humza Yousaf insists 'precautions have been taken'](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj5nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3lJW1VW4gn2RVJyNW2PL2t28-kt4wW7BfS8S7fDPvKLMFBy3025vW7GRH4g2xLGjnVYKkK07BKCMGW2SvnFf6dnG89W7vz71N80t_msVYzt1l8K3L21W99yzyn77n28JW3PBvgK8fCGy_V4WkSQ2y0shqW8j680b6g07yvW8LbB6D3gzrTQW4CH7gh3xc5nGW37RJLW4g0vfQW4MYm8v9c1Jy0W1XZS_n32xQwXW5gMTDd6z-JJ8N5TzVzjrkj-QW46412G1jMxBLW5kvHPV4K1D5tW57StZw1pMMHDW4dL-6C20yhpQW2VwCqX7lSKKBW3xdM6r13gY95W1MpssQ63JCngW2TbVLm4LC812N4-gs-SpsDG_W43vbrV1fHgqWW76VqRp26JYDhW6wGnvD66RpC2W20jhdk3b46tSVp3CJt7J_jn8W4kkbG78b7K1rW1sCnvg5zVFqyN5zz1hsmMS3CW8L5YDf3_RWMYW51jLVq4qwDY5W2CDvc43l2T66f4ZCjmg04) [UK Government labels China a 'systemic challenge' as Humza Yousaf insists 'precautions have been taken'](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj5nR32W7lCGcx6lZ3nWW3vMzh22LBsYgW8c2yJy5NmNn0VT7g7F6zpPfyW5k7LKL27vC2TW9dGx-P1qPm8pW1zLjJk7dHt-gVF-mp88X8pztVywB064sPYs8W6DckjJ5_ghfYV6P5nT483_qKW1BHTd-3xXVV4W26V-6G84JQPWW7mKFvf80QtXSW6lqKD-2yS6zhW72k7tS1fTYWjW6MN1T311X_8zW2wdrwN1N4BqgW2_jJBX4BB5g8W46Dqvc58WdDmW7vYN7w8pD1PYW2X5D3t6NTtDtVbV0Zm7p73K-W1w9NbY1H1dd4N5MvQvspRj50VmN8Rg5Z_3tkW7s1Gk_6KSYbKW4tpRFR4kpdTYW5KMTFC6MvnLcW2rT9Xv5CmM9fW3YCgJG5tbmmpW5TqZzK4j2K-zVKQNj-2CqMKFVj_7-Q7MPJPrW7jlR2C1J46N-W1NXCHp5bCH69Vd1y-B3s6FW9W645hGq7r7jt_MTHvmW3JrH9W4TJj1z4q6_TFW2vtfZx3B2klBf6kt_kg04) [View more news](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj3qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3mwW2zch0X2CrSzYW72NjV461ybY-W75YX-k6LCdP7VB71j42P7FVrV17Btp4jyVZ9W1WCW9Y51Nb-NW2mKBlk6qvrLNW7txmLs8pdVVBW1RqSQ02rY6yXW91MWQ14BJfMnF8lWYcPpkPsN9dj8w92WP_mW36Dv_H4kqM4YW3pcpqq5skl7lW4K6pSn6NWxvQW6Wtq1n7j-R0LW8fLTjD9jPpLkW3K-wms5RpmFCW4c1xNX1TDM0BW8Cd07H8xpD_nW8nljH_3XbnnYW5Jth1W2-GPJDW22LFVB74nSksW7LnpkC86yghFf5YjwZY04) You have received this email as you are opted in to newsletters from The Scotsman. [Log in or create an account to manage your newsletter preferences.](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmj3qgyTW7lCdLW6lZ3kWW1l4F4k2LY3SMW4BVk0t24fnspW132fJg5VnrPsW7GSZ6k9hZYL_N775-4Wz_sj-VsmXXB2Sk_-RW5wZZh15YG54zW8pP8QV45zZdkW8XDYys91HBYJW5--dvQ88Z8h7W7_23LX37bBBXM6gLxc8RRQ6W8j2btz5S9JX4W680Lf465ZryPW3g1YlF1FHWcwW89Vh-084BqmdW2B4yJG3n6NNmMdW8m-NmPFMW45kQFM6QFFYCW8PNQMK1p1bLjW4rmTsB6p2zbQW2gvgZL47mMz_W6zd0Ln2W4StrW33Lrfk31mCysf4P3hYW04) You can also change the [types]( of emails you recieve from us or completely [stop all]( emails. [National World Publishing Ltd] Published by National World Publishing Ltd Registered in England and Wales (11499982). Suite D5, Joseph's Well, Hanover Walk, Leeds, England, LS3 1AB, United Kingdom. We will process your personal data in accordance with our [Privacy notice](113/csmbM04/VX858l1L2sZLN4z07fFSQ5GSW3V7XmG53l6THN5SJSmC3qgyTW7Y8-PT6lZ3kPW5mXxL32s0qN9N9jCWbnpJnptW4h8CW551j7MKW4Vh36Z6QQZ0zW44sWyF6QsJsbW8W91md5PThFTW6z7q1j8qH1knW9jTbv02QK_-ZW2CVV_g6kJggHW7TvBSr67PLgnW69w4DT8Pv5zwMsZTMGHhKCwW43l11k7TZR7VW6vt8WV5yNdq0W7GZNvb4Wr3GqW9dMlz573g-NlW4sRxVS75_lC3N6ZgKnwvn6XkW57_9Sw8hDNfJW2yCnW83m36f8W8ghXCM4PGmSBW8MZwYz7lG1VYN7rJMZzhYYCjW3dlMvJ2Zv-VGW8NlhpN4952VDW681MCq8C8R7Rf1Fp9Vv04).