SNP president says party in a 'tremendous mess'

The SNP president Michael Russell has admitted the party is in a “tremendous mess” as the party was rocked by a series of resignations. [View email online](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvX5nCWtV3Zsc37CgN1QW6fBZck2XqdWMVBSVdB9gJx3rW4lX8911K_CN_W6rxk9l2NpFtvW7LP4t38x8PH6W994ncn2cFr2CW5T4GQK6KXBMvW2nNYbH8-JdB3W4y1gq42-W-9yW2LKNJ5210kpYW29bJr_5hh_T0W6RlGBL1yt6WWW8v9mTB7J4GcJW6KzZfq53q7N3W1HZh637Lr9pwW3fNLK473drckW6Q6z8r7JQM3WW9d4WFq87MgL-W7plmss6_ckcBW52lKPh51wQL4W88D5RX3ByVqdW4vDW0V425QHZW4lQb_z9kQgSgW7n40y691H5fqW8y5wSb2nWCFbV3JZbQ6Qnt6dW8ClTtr5RCZ54W2387DJ6ZDQjcW49ZnLG1g8h6qVLx7wD1J9LjwW1ZL-z852FPdjN5-9_V3W3FPPW7P29-m3YNSkgW5lfLFj1sPyNpW7pHNPw8L6TbnN8Jk_1T4gkyGW7R0RMN5Bsc5WN1TjzsgPkL6gW809P2J78DvtDW3_kQtj93xMytV42SkV91QX6pW2CsZ191jpqFKN4jm1JkmYkMTW15W2sr2zHYkf2zl1) [Subscribe today](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvk3q3nJV1-WJV7CgNybN83S7rDjsFyyW33kgDz9h8vJmW4jy94R2Nkk9GW8TxCFl2gmsJ_W5J5Crg2wndYsW39kyhh9c4fM8W1R7dYv50Ft8gW2QBm-J2G-RJpW5JVpQT5kq0YxW14CDPn4tKxztW9h8jFY5K-QXlT6C_76hWFgbW1yvjDq7qXgMXVSccCs4R8X9sW5kSNsR5LWwhhW2_sr524P-5KwW4GWplQ199zZKW2NbKBD50VwHpW19LFHT4-B236W2mBRl08zH42yW5_zQ2v1-tVszM1bg_V1bHCcW2zR7zR9fCP54W7qXSW52b9MTM31P-1) [Facebook](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvD3q3n_V1-WJV7CgCqtW3Gmj6Q7F9-bjW3-BSsq8mDqmXMjs3c67jFHNW5Gxnw97jT4mRW2VVykT3VLKd0N7yqKXwySkK8W573XhL1S48jrN1hfRKj7DxfYW4Xrbt_53QYNDW2XQC8C4QcMCrW45f_kT9m0DQJN8sG7k-hFfPRW7FlCDH7vYxfRW4WS26W9crFKWW7cKXq53PGCC1VC0lBF7YvsCqW51KnH76gnfSrW6Nn3bB4SRB7VW6JCWck6qwhmvW7L5B0P1J00kBW1tRq4B30HNcBW8Sk6CY6d7YB_VpydYW6nKVJBVLGwsn61T5qDW2J3pgH1lhmkhW4KgfDs6TLXGX3bMh1) [Twitter](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvk3q3nJV1-WJV7CgWBgW7PjM3k8b0Z7SW3b2vdW93bHQyW6HY7rM5QYM93W1zn91D3FyrBYW7k7LrH1lgp5rW2QRhXs1Vxb26N8LnFTN1Fh9sW4n6hq09hwPy9W4GCPn27-3-fcW3_NJKG28FrL5W66GsRc6Rvf2XW1Gf0314jm9m3W6SLcSM5q6DWVW8m4XqF5qY0HFW7ShDkJ47zpnpW9hN5WJ3grJ_tW8J-q645JfrQyW8RjNzq7mVbq6W4B5Y093X7MrSW8ghWL_68w6KVW5spfFD4M4mxMW1m2Xy28CqSzcW6H5GbK3YvrJKW2v385-2QVtWB3nl01) [The Scotsman] Mar 20, 2023 Good morning readers. How was your weekend? Welcome to a new week. Here are the latest Scottish headlines from [The Scotsman.](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCv13q3npV1-WJV7CgTkzW1DQYg37__3RQW1KPM9m1XpF4yW68T4mD4g5f9PW7zgKT27pD8_cN7j9Yfp1H8KHW4k1PqN1f_H6LW1J6gn82hZqybW5MKBgx6zT9bQW9btYd41lYxK7VCfV-r27xbLHW85GHg49ktYr5N5PnLnN5WDpQW37Tzq96-XF5SN6blHFPPSC_dW7l9FYP7WG5PSW20xwVX3GnB0sW6Wx7qS129j6VW76JkKK6N1V_sW90BCjQ5fYvPWW1HcB2W53Jy1TW2CHkrz5lrFpNW44XCLf1q5B0M36hP1) - Politics: [SNP president Michael Russell says party in a 'tremendous mess'](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvk5nCVVV3Zsc37CgVLlW3V-mdp85G4tCW2y52bG8vl84XVVQFG236NmljVdhP4D70T3LwVSM6qx86Q_8JF1M9SYc1c6fN1DgGK-t6R_pN1f5qP3SXYH7W8WYtZl72BvjVW4-NrW81ZZ9rpVBSHnh1npXpQW51XhNg80ZK6LVlSQ717v7HNzVvqPnn615DtDVc1YwV8tYMZNW2GXcRp1WVyL7W1_q4Z71zHt7PW7-7G0z7tWJWpW7L5xLZ8_BNQpW1QGqHk3rlJmgW5js6lm7FR2sMW5gVNR71H8x0XVJTqbP6qyzm3W1ryj4w5fQmSYW6JKD7767nbmvVDrkYF8cJ3twW2bVY655lxw6DW84m99Q4XVvZ-W75zGGF85XCydW5knTlf5pZc5vW4RlJQT7NR94QVfT81h5Zbs83W3t27V46fN_n4W3ymZk772jnyYW3_2HpL5HXcF8W7XnC5G6fxVQTW2nqKlH5rGMK6VQBNBD3ygfCQW8MS-5866Q6mHW3w8Z911g3j5K3brT1) - People: [Parishioners question leading Catholic cleric over multimillion pound funds](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCtL5nCVhV3Zsc37CgC1mV-4Bsz4XBmtFW6yqTPF8RlhsSW21R0kz6RkMwQW1RvW4_10d0hyV64h8c6LXRlBW5mjDlH8SwQjsW5ZMY8g35X5fhN34GN9hpnNfpN6knxc3rNR7SW9kRSfW52SpTYW6LspQ_3GQRR8W68dqS_7mpdDmW7VQHlF6t4wbZW4x1-6n7-YB06W7gMxHr3NfYkVW4Y6Ftb5wCbGLW32m30w7hSR72W8fFnXY47M9mvW5kWy6R5Gg-gqW9bdbds2D3TjnN2z6wcjJ3dYLVkfVQb6Z81DbW7NLDPB4BW44MW17KVzB452FxNVFnbXP6NY-VvN5QqmzN6Q4x4W1ndD5z1jG8lYW3rKk7m7P_Yp1W3w7gyf4nNCY7W4mpfgs6TCdW4W6-1Nzh63mq5CV4BL-l9gmwxkW5Xjwzw279Q_rW8M9DF43Vhgk7W5JKC6r31fHXJW6XNNts486xMn3hvm1) - Euan McColm: [SNP took its supporters for granted, and the rest of us for fools](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCtL5nCVhV3Zsc37CgL5hW5TJ67S5_ZnvrW3kjt5n3bHZStN3YrjVf9fVdYW3bbcMr3gNBbpW8JBKN92FCgC6Vf612P91y9CjW3TdQ4h8dpLqvW8yBhYx5yXSfFW7ngbCq5GnbkWW9dr_vl6yjP-qW3WNK5t1ky8z7W8_g1BV1WKzYhN4tpX-b1_C9YN3JbXczqDxzJW6ZtS6l8NvLk3W380JHN4FHqmRW8WqxhC6lD-gbW8HMWpQ4jvnsVW8NGcY_3-Sv1gW8vz0_Y4RhCt6W3bHMTX57BTnFW3dQTcc7JVk-wW63xvpX8mmB2RW1lb7B93GHtPZW8Jvkm07Dh0hfW51cR396tR_n6W8tBpY71vsvxhW8Hd8PL6ymJfTW5f6_B41rLGpHW2jYv3H55tjhhW2GgX_T8NLygcW8kF18Y95PPHpN4K6NJlrnbwQW4Csd9R7zV_JwW5lsXVJ6zCCG2W4LFZpw6bb96S31DZ1) - TV: [13 pictures as The Crown stars spotted filming together as William and Kate](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCv15nCVBV3Zsc37CgzQnW4ltQJH8pdLlrW5178252HklJvVbhTb27DMkVBW2NgDJy55D8ZYN6WV3D0j-g0rVz0zJS9gkB-gW35tlRX1NQy4GW7NLBlc7y2mVrW3zHp4j4SqB4nW53yCHG3FBmwNW8Kn5kb4zQD29W8J43NR18v_hsW6V-tYX4FjNrgW6qW5734ZfXBzW1GpCPn7X3PwLW7wy9-Q7HzG6-W1TMw0c6Gd5m7W6fD3BV5tpBrYW42j8VZ6V1KqTN6DyBCMrCYNdW1k0_-t899q0GW6Cw3h56W9D62W3bq6Db4CV398N1BP98yPzYJBW1w0DhX2g2bnKW1QDbkB5M2fnjW5q79Jr3DRkdSW3KKRMR5TvMsBW991xlP5sCpDqW5sPycH8bD1TpVG3Ksz78JPgRMPfv9Tl1BwpW7Qs3Xv8SXxpWW80FSgC31Q9Z1W5b7CR02fY_w5VK9lb85mm6F1W6XfBgJ94FwcGW2XQ_9K86ZVyd3d2F1) - Film: [Goriest battle scenes were edited out of Braveheart says James Cosmo](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCtr5nCT_V3Zsc37CgKpKW9cNv1Y35svPWW80p3q63bYSJPW5-7Q-Y4lpSnlW5x14V-8dvYq5VnPDpx9bvSbfW948bJF5NxYnhW7_5KJs8r1WMJW6ZNHFl5T3gCFW8DZPdL1M_-nSW2hsDsB1Y7WCyW2r-Z7p8PsqFbW2TkG8F3XL7NNW2dGsJB7n8gFYW47MX0_2zSVPQW2tLcl53MTmF_W2p_BK46tSdwZW1Jhsh35NTj1KW3L6sbN1hSTvcN5S9fyTZGYn_W2GW7d95r_8dkVx2F956KZx09W4myPR-8rZbpqW7Vhpr56rQGx1W5d4Bgw2C7_h0N47G_tSm_-2HW5GN9k44MdXsNV5st2l3C5d9cW190zqD1vQGdJW44fxqN8R3SM8W16WcNl1NS2WfW8PvRF692j2yYW7Dx00x123Sp3W3C0xXz6T0BmPW26nZvz7KB4MM3mr51) More headlines are below. Thank you for reading. Graham Falk [SNP president Michael Russell admits party a 'tremendous mess' and insists he didn't know about membership plummeting](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvk5nCVVV3Zsc37CgBfYW76dnzh6PC1S9W20V1ht86kmgWW4zHWQt8GvN_SW5jp1K31C8gJlM4yFWTy3pSrW3z11yV7zWsQFW3DZCMs7wgxvbW50ZdvR5p_hVZW4w4p5R34ynPyW720SZx6XFw6gW8kj1Pt4x81GnW43qT0H5X9CD5N7kq2DlcHSQJW6zfcHL5H2LwqN165cJfKtYPWVPYX5X77D54CW39bKf48VhdRDW6NMJx44FVJP4W4YSYqD8Csd46W3sXyd83JH_bgVm29dc21t8PpW9ccK2T1s_1x1W6558RM8dW2whN46RbfskkktyW57SGDP9fTFQ1W925pc-5h01TyW3hLXXq4ZyzK7N8bnHwNyjxhdN2ffZQV4sc3xW6s0Rvm2JK-95W6m-LJY69BsmCW6kWBpl8cR3MwW6sDZHZ3bwzTDW7_ZMN370xk3SW80T2wz2FQKT3N4PdYJJyHRP7W5fvXC57H2HqpW7ch5Cw2KrdscW6gGkry8-rlv5N8SmvnqL1KMV2J-1) The SNP president Michael Russell has admitted the party is in a “tremendous mess” as the party was rocked by a series of resignations. [SNP president Michael Russell admits party a 'tremendous mess' and insists he didn't know about membership plummeting](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvk5nCVVV3Zsc37CgPgtW38P7KN8Q0RvtW8KvFSf2qLV4YW8zHq9z2GJvSfN5838w9_hNrXVDDxr67XnKvdW4M89fj3gX61MW5mgt7c1dTgxDW5KXmB91RDHyhW8BBclb4Cl4M9W4vN6P127lKc_W2tRgb680xkzwW2tXgsT58jJ4JV5HGQ-80gLLTVJMLHC1-ggFKW3h3JNh14-TrmW3qPPN75d9tJkW86X00F2gw0tpW2RN91m2qdwQ5W6RLymG7YYHkGW3YMMVb8Q_PnDW4XD94b6QCZh2W6D1Y383ZFCCpW3ksyr-8dSYzQW1FbrSQ3sS7rxW7LzQ4-4w40L6N5_rH97tQ1lFW3ZY85f1DtZtHW7Y6wH-3dBmxcW5b-myN6g8lDVW8V-R96501ZHzW6sXH4J1P7-KlW47dBcK7Z3rpwW8bgf3d8Q9V91W83_7721DFTbJW3Tjrlr4T1ZqjN731w1yzMJC1W7VZKLD6hGG4wW5xh7fs8RfLVQVts3ZC8ynv_wW8s9sL06jXY3Q361B1) [Are you a business owner?](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvX3q3phV1-WJV7CgBSBW4drqxm2T98XRW3y9CNL87-yk0W3s4SDz97FrZ5W1rW4hc8-bRy8W7KNW244zwMF7MV39ZfHFfPyW3M510p5tnGyPW4NR1n42b8kFpW69WzL995Jzq-W5F4yX-5q9vm_W5TKxtb7KZSvBW52Td2f2jjXD2W5m__Py7qt_DpW1GF2H09hqFyLN1790Qx-J60TW7z8Cyt5fWFgBW2qjZV04gRyQCW801RKh7lHPsYW7JM2mB1vgbrJW7f0Mb13lG_czW5QfL1F7gcr_LW2sCHH15Cv01YW4WJ-Wr29RTqrW8bbk3Z4MF28hW2R8CkS2q42pPW1fwftb7BpRkHW1lTDXD49pbz0W4_PZCs8HR3s6318F1) [SNP leadership candidate Kate Forbes says decisions in SNP taken by 'too few people'](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCtr5nCT_V3Zsc37CgMf1W4S_FlH1Tw9MGW7-jdjj98xd84W1pcD9J3YxwR_VSn3rv1VcWk7V8RG5q7Rfp2NW7lZWcl7lxKRZW7jgTc42d5mx4N9570ThxxRN2W2ZnJ-Y7kYpFJW4Ljsf38BRJQKW7VHDy28FXlTcW4sygCV92vTfGVrl96C3x3_tyW94g_YX4_zVRqW5S8SHX5HntHtW8QmXh0616d4WW5m-6xJ6X8xGGW5QnbYF6R7RM6W3WNg7X3PwXfBW4XPw544q9Ds9W3rpFQX8hNLldW1-WQ-m5mNBdmW4_HSTZ2V9wt1W5xwqBp5Hf2HBW1MkKm29cNCr_M3nlWcRDNrBW1Qn8hv5mwljtVPKMMR7sHdHqW1DjWfR83NM6PW96LdTd7ZT3LRW3SVVg08MF3qWW11-qRs5q1Fm1W49RjKY6KvYGRW5559By1ZsbpY3mHR1) [SNP leadership candidate Kate Forbes says decisions in SNP taken by 'too few people'](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCtr5nCT_V3Zsc37Cg-SgW4N7VhR8gSDPDW5y_L4y7pzyHjW7MdZmw8976SSW8BW8yy6dkk1XVPyWQt4pwVNwW41JXNt1wYZsHW3_FpcJ7s_7V4W5ZY46p7K0kLxW6P2j-76k3DPZW1xNTcZ5WlPCNMZqqDGf3S5DW6SDCxj4bPT2sW3vcn6j4tQwGVW8pPnRL2tnRZHN2hd0QMx9hryW8R6KvT8SwV1PW8pr7g11-H1P5W4qR8xP3N_y9_W3sgjNB5sF50dW72-gW67gWwsMW19J2VK6VL6TxN8GPcV51bJHTVGZpzB4xrxhXW4l03_x8Pf0TkW54G76J7Bl3ypW2qx1Ky5yVcVgW34Stj25VFSjBW885vWF4VqPKNW4XWYHW6NDsbMW74vbjC3SzmCXVfjxG21-gftpVKf7Ht74jxGVW7ltDy_1lzG9fN8DJcLZvbw343nh31) [China’s Xi Jinping to meet Vladimir Putin in boost for isolated Russia leader](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCtr5nCT_V3Zsc37CgWlPW6b_Kcb7YmqsMW76kvYg5g64YsW78GyjQ4Q-kRFN8L29gV_1RdwW6JkNSM3q5SxGW2ZwypF5D-yWWW4qr8kr1h1zrYW5vW4Jk7HJrHFW6vyvSj67638RW6_MDD545-_ytV761Gv3KjJCZW4VZfgR5LbC_-W346tjH4R8dPlW3pJW_P8sgFytW8K6SQQ32Ql4TW76g3qk54fL1dN3lgkzbDjDzwN35CpydBNwf7W2y89yr8m_sW6W7cHM5k1kKTLzVMqNN884sxm3W6K9V372GhznpW6GKtnZ3fy-PSW6QgX516kV0pkN8Bg9YRfSTHfW237kBQ6-s33gW8k2M3D6_Cp_-W1D-L-Y6TgdRHW5_TnNx8VHPfLW2sv_jF3dLlYQW6kN7lK6nSf_DN2vpd1-S2_0GW6M7lqj2vpbJZW2fBX_63DgxLn3lgH1) [China’s Xi Jinping to meet Vladimir Putin in boost for isolated Russia leader](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCtr5nCT_V3Zsc37CgPPRW4k4QWg4L-Nb2N2RGVLV8S6TYN1MPtv8p4jwJW16T6hY11rFlvW8mCSrB52x4nFW7cbSSG5Y5yZ1W592FqF8f_k6KW82FFh33d3nBcW8sg-fr6nV8ZFW7x2fKn6CKCZcVqxk0z1qdC-yW96ZhxH9dXb4VVLHlsK4bxLnqW5nc1SC4vs62nW5LTX7z7ZBd9-N4R508SgQQjyTVrD128w9-5W4tJ-498NfV_dW6qWz3p1z1NDjW7WBnSK9f2WJKW67RMHD8RMn3bW6y4GCf2ZDn31W7Mb5hs1mT3XvW5S3D2N5M6wT1W57p9P14HNYVVW8LLbk18z4Xx2W4vMC0J1rsjb_W6Vrj7k6_DDHhW8jpSqj4bb5trW1H7Fhs8Kh_M1W7l0z621jXqYMW4CXJFh7BJl6WW8gQYCL7rq-PPW4BpYXx5w-1Ll3jcF1) [Scottish independence would prompt many to reflect on succession planning - Fraser Scott](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCv15nCVBV3Zsc37CgNP8VYRpCy2GwqhJVSWRl_4MvGC3W4GZYTf1q5D35W89YcLy20w5XjW3tNGRl5Sr3RHW4lrP5b7ZjWBtW850RjS11tsRjW1FC7tv6JZjxrW819Qh11yhgRfW2N_w6l58K-DkVXJGwm2_GNPyW5btLP02YZMnYW91tq4F1BzwlQW7C_Lv81zn_FnW7wXr-j6qtXQgV7pT8Z2LMT6WW96q95m6J_QFqW76THJN9c3-6dW6pdGFf3ZX6DBW1z8RWj2QV8fyVw6ySn4kdH5CN2MY--ffWQdrV7g-Nr24XCrlW7FBM1c5n-5qQW3Vryx34HJc0kVs6XmF4mWmhhW6sW2hr8-Jmq6N8zYmT0z9Zx7W8_YyHY51QKhhW3T10__5CVdQBW77clJk8Fml8KW1W_0779840MbW2m01XH1G-1qVW8nh4dB6yNQxkW5tL4Yh6mMny7W3jKrJx97THxtVVyYMV46hg8nW25Tk6W1zkD3V3dLf1) [Scottish independence would prompt many to reflect on succession planning - Fraser Scott](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCv15nCVBV3Zsc37CgDTLW6c40yx4TkPZdN48cS3fZw08QMV4NwqLMdStW5cj7HX1R3xqVW48FcVH8Gx7C9W4M34KD48XkN_W56VyZ38ZtFwnW4HDW7532HPG2W76L9Tf3XZv2bW5-0q347V5xGTW2G6XBq7kX6tmW1R-c8Y4rS-DnW9jQxXV3VTMwqN4Zvy3R8RnWXVhkv0r1jvPwXM5cH8YZRj6cW63NJ2Y6vtf0nW1kW0pR7ZKgfXW1kQRQK1V1xx7W5DzMr74HMZZ1N4BgTfhY4QfGW5mpGjf5T7JvnW3jNx2P1KtSHjW8SkDXS8-6-hxW9fP2NQ7DW_mkW5j3688546lhRW65W9CF116QQ_W3qW9xn7QFL9DW94Wth36jmnqgW2_nWGS38VWbVW5G3mPX8VqwX8W4BtMQQ43fYlQW3f1LdH2ByLBvVmyGmC52PRWXN7t5dNqVZKgXW2xdPBg5RY6nhN1738J4FbycDN44qNLLBNjkS33-x1) [We should heed the words of scientists like Stephen Hawking on climate change, rather than hard-left Greens](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvD5nCW9V3Zsc37CgJ_jVxv0tZ8rKVSLW9lpJnf3ywfrxW28JFNj5HWmmmN79V1d-J6X3NV8qtCF7WgTkYW8ClzYv8kV-DrW7wdZrG3_S3wCW8p71jG5FgWWJW2VXd6Q6bHTrkW5NzYFn7YXrkPW67cX691T_qJ8W73NmJV1wrMxRW1m24CK4kGlFZW4t0bGL3rtLk5W1XHHbY3KcmxnW8VrMfj5CpfnNW2yhTRB7F5pWBW7LlNMX3CZzbbW8SXTz93czjZxW2rF9346lRqLcW7VT9H-1GVrw4W8Jqb6T5hM6ZLW7Tbk3J5jn_zHW1J9P0b5jjtgyW5kBzJ81nnLFqW1YwC9y300YzrW7d-K_B4WTQ8NW1dGDsx8-g-n6N7LbMmqVJPqmVxw7vY36bBmRW4QyVwV8sXnQtMZKy8rww7GBN7K09pNwt_00W4TPk4d3G2mDRW85CmkT1n_gDYW2MKHd61RtBvwW7GjgvF6v89KRW2xQmGT13y88gVMVzX05kpLqGVWy0RG6zmyGHW4xrTys8HT8knW5BMMWW7tRPF23gMM1) [We should heed the words of scientists like Stephen Hawking on climate change, rather than hard-left Greens](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvD5nCW9V3Zsc37CgJNRW2bljXD47tCdgW2B0r_B5dtNZPN7X5yZZ3_hMTN29918hYn0J-W4cPfdD2b3xLLW3tJn4146DnD8W5LcqQJ7W82PbW2LWC6x36QhngW7PSMD76fpTzSW7TmcGv8SC00wW4jTL0s1cTwjpW8lNYLc2bLkT7W7gL9qS3Yp17NW6LTVCZ22MbLtW69ZWMg70XH2kW4QTRP46l4xvgW4lrPgH8Nl4-LW412B9B6_jtVkW25r53N1kTvkBW3bSnPn2mNTX0N4DKnM3drZKvW9fHDBq7W6DGSW8BY_pg6B9VQ7W3ByRBb39dsNFW1-Vwky5gr1b8W5xFP3W4HvTJQW3fVfMC8Fg1r9W9h7Hn57b-BVkW5zF4Vt4ycTJ-W7TLzFK3QjVMvW7PRvSN5Xq0FkW43d2k-2p_B9FW2g44m86Tg0PNW8mFcBT36C-xhW4yWp384Pc6DjW5MzN_Z50tWfBW9l6Ntr5lj2yrW2xfL-03W1SB3W5lbZr95LK-PYW3lg0sk1Y9xchW1TR85W4DlgtNW6mysM_5tQNJC37KP1) [Scotsman leader comment: SNP's culture of aggressive secrecy must be flushed out](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCtL5nCVhV3Zsc37Cg-QWW4fZm_H1_VqSyW1_G74-4qRShDW5f2x_D4ZsFSbVRnDvZ85Xc5MW2W8BSK3CyD15N7zg4j9FN922VY9T_m1Pw74VW23bLYp7H9MZCW3Wyw5P6t31JmW5SVqDf6B3QckW87L8Gj3fFk34W6mMwTS2NrK0BW2xXVlH3jLg3SW6krDZM53MZM9W52dtqB2pvxVHW7nBXqq8GKSX7Mr4wYyQ9HPHW1cbFhn8K_zrHW5rdKnl13dRLCW6Mbn5Z18GNl5VFXrQp4nX5T4VwkdJR7ltHycV1-Zp17n1mdSW1g5VgZ39RQL8VXb2SL3wG0QJW5dnpL02x0frQW4BpYTh79YjYMW8_dDZd4VDZCTN7QTGrjx85nZW2gJQjF78Gw2gW3_h0BG5v9_7CW76Ng6Q55b0bvW32RCRb6xSVfXW1XtvJK7MLtcrW6pq-d21gXTgGVjNrTR2cfpVZ32P-1) [Scotsman leader comment: SNP's culture of aggressive secrecy must be flushed out](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCtL5nCVhV3Zsc37CgDkdW2cYQ075GhtQjW78vMDH7dsn1hW3rgV3S5NQH-gW3H31504gw5ZfW7szS99650fwGW3S74D45nLpRRVvR20z7X4HjXN3Qh6M25hckKW2FM10Q49gRnQW6-PnGT347pL8W7Dhs8P3ZR-J8VBL0kY6xSDVyW4rRkMt6g8mZGW6vCwx38b4GwgW5Xx5SP5DzpY9W1H5hG15-glxMW7xdPT_2J50mHW2-dk3V68kWjXW1pJTnz1XLNF-W5xVNN19lLpmcW3y34bQ4Yt7mlW1bJ9T37PPdpWW7pTwpL1tlZlFW1Db5_76PVYzHW7tsdQr3YL2PZW51PRZn5vMFQ7W70V0Vw8xzrNZW4Fzyd66j_myPW84D-yj8240J2W7YvmKG8MlWXNW49HHND7kCrBnW6Q91NX6hk-JCN8VK6Rn3Y2xDW7JRVmk40DTswW24mVzN3TyDFkN63gyMlL0-Yk3g3L1) [Sir David Attenborough warns the capercaillie is on the brink of going extinct in Scotland for the second time](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvD5nCW9V3Zsc37CgF_KW5PBBYQ7Cnc-WW3Wq6D_1dgYrrW5xfvln3wz862W4F9sSZ6QCY1gV7sD2J2yKzYcW44XQ1g3q5jZXN8tvs09fYRtVW7WTj-s6QqsRKW5cHwyT1JGvd9W8Xw-Zs25ZKDPW1p5Y6f2fGqSlW7V89pq5Ppr5tW20TQrP7QY-r3W43d_395yyJZNW4jPtSh6Kz5TCW2NFq9H2RS9f1N405LHwwy9_TW50nLxN6prwd5VRcQ6r4BWVJDW6h8jwR7trCRKW5YzZ4Q4MtQ6JN2jq_2tz2pTvMpjW1bztdfKW3T_3sW8GNYJBW7_JlvQ777xfBW3ymrZ47gzLprW65FF3K8VgJzvN3C2M8RHfXj-W8WWY5p7QLc4WW1cStzc3jxXRxW7Bm3tj4ZZK3QW6shRbr1bZYJnW8ZDWDR4KmlfpW84dgJ_6QpFtfW3cQnx6984jfVW6fx5FJ5CQ-x0MJGH90qMJrHW44lN9745416MW88dL8n764nwlW8jqQjf7x7pwmW9l7Bqq4KkpC1N6QqtKzlKf4D38-41) [Sir David Attenborough warns the capercaillie is on the brink of going extinct in Scotland for the second time](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvD5nCW9V3Zsc37Cg-xrV411gd6L25vVVp95cg6WS770W1r5jlD26ql_pN6MNYB7zbWMPW2FyQts3qCKDJW5bXG773QJLs3W36vKx11pZC16W8nZrqM8PTDm3W57s7pq7nYtyfW252HVP5MXVWTVDT6gZ7RxlMmW6HL-g376D9DXW3Nb92040bCmXW5ppz9H5PHLzkW70sFR44xW1QBW3G2tq93G1CQfVjsJSr7gXqHXW85DNPN6FbK_QN3L-Md77GKwLW23kVp04VqxnMW1K2XZl3_mRNMW5hynm62tqDHyW69cBW51Bb03xW18wgx62k2GPwVx3B6C6Tyc29VZl8D52VdbY3W8pDyGc7Qxv8LMrw3VlB5wyrW60Th-t6DbC5XW18JX0X1h1MXzW7L83TJ6_slRGN8QBwY-fLP1xW97Bvcn9bDSTfW542t538qF71YN4r61cgftk_4W1Xt8jK5wq5qBW4SLlsG4cqm37W5nz7Wq94QHLJW5fPQDT1-jscGW5vHpFF7XCSkvW6qb8kN1F5R5CW78Hqc-117Sb_3bFp1) [View more news](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCv13q3npV1-WJV7CgH4LVK5Qt95NgckZVB46xY3kCtt6W4TTK6K6r911sW156WFw4S4yltW4Hrk1N3kGt9NW5czHrh2TycVpW3cG0Y67STKJ3W8kM5K04dY-llW93wk4n8wHWfbW5qwXWl5MJ4fFW4N836V18kR60W95Ltt_1FYy5XW8VtJYP2fCgbvW4XqJgc2jcYj2W5hgM_z36KvnvW7JvJqq1jd7hWW30bK3s6XZCX-N15PxQsbKxfxW8-5R8Q6V8bvWW3PrgkF40J0BXW1Gcfw281gZBPW5NyWNX6gPBrm3f-N1) You have received this email as you are opted in to newsletters from The Scotsman, published by National World Publishing Ltd. To manage your individual newsletter preferences with us, please [click here](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvk3q3nJV1-WJV7CgCpNW8h0X6w4j60r1W5C4N6Y4q4DjLTZZXS4Mhm5rW7Km0F77kh7cYW3LWkyt3hMX5ZW4NvD1053f42-W8B_PKc4p15s5W2CRVRM8lsh53W8mzQhP7m0Gw2W3jvLp96dMkvcW6MXYSS7qfHRjW7TtyRL4sdLc-N5scjvxbD4sNW9lhJDS5n_LjCW8wZdML2Pnt6DW5R5LZ33pGK_WW69pDXK9ks70vW2Jc9DS6sJfYXW7nK8Hr71NbSmN9h7HNZ808ybN2TtJlV1dYcRW5903gM77z5GbW4GZlrf62fnYrW5ptvb13czwZz32P71) and log in to your account. Alternatively, [update]( your global email preferences with us to choose the types of emails you receive from National World Publishing Ltd or [unsubscribe]( from all types of future emails. National World Publishing Ltd, a company registered in England and Wales with registered number 11499982, having its registered address at No 1 Leeds, 4th Floor, 26 Whitehall Road, Leeds, England, LS12 1BE, United Kingdom. We will process your personal data in accordance with our [Privacy notice](113/csmbM04/VVKr_B4bMHhTW6FwqK34-Lx33W6y9Q694Yl-l_N7dHCvk3q3nJV1-WJV7CgM7RW6_dBVP7S7RJzW45rWTP5nf7SsVyGV-84BzRqDW6QhNJX6_gzjgW49pjbw8TrN2JN4rnq28-4xZSW8gr-2t2BYt9QN2lLZzPLnXzxW1bw27P5P-KkRW4zB3Pd3bc1YsW36sCnX4mX0nyW2PljmS2g7nghVpfXKw1MbC6bW25HJws2NnDpBW3rBRk44w0TPRW1tq_TX2C3_20W67vkr88drJ2hW4bp9mQ1-pkPyW4_mdwS7WfwtnW25pZL18RDf9KW5CLq4j2nW1QrVMkr0G85s0fmW1gnPCF3zGrtWN44N3g9KMzwJ336m1).