Humza Yousaf hits back as he goes on the attack in second TV debate

It was as if someone had turned the volume down, but left the TV on, such was the muted attacks in the second SNP leadership contest debate. [View email online](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8lt5nCWNV3Zsc37CgHKDW3cqjln8hQVnHN5QVKWm_cM8DW2hDCkr1xD2qlW9f67P09lhmDtW4qdMfZ62gTdQW1cXwkx8Lm5JyW8FcV_G1DlTFhW21shgV7_hj3nVkH6cf80K1-nW74GqYH4DnS7dW4gQNyy2P1VgCW9lj_YZ2sHBkGW2sjqnl4WDsb8W5gJYF_77NyytVwp3Qz6XKMt-W8y5XcL2jTYzVW4xwv0Y8S-tTcW5CtT151-f11sW28Wcmw1tPP02W7cJn1z64D3TTW8DpDQw4wmjCmN4BzTBYBTqv9W745bvz2JHVb5W21-CCw6gmSqSW6gkQcY5X2M5wW80RQq93YX23HW1NzQPQ438ztLW58Cm5K6-KGb9W1NX48l1SDyT4W2phpNF6JjYb8W3Hq-Py3frmqCW1677y37Gq9h0W7D33044yW7w1W8Y838B5Byh70W7pmcXq5r8Q8FW638vVj4JrpSxW63zy_n5w1HGZW3jjpM_31MVYCW7nylRc56W5s3W2rQc_f5hdHgBW548Cx41_GX1GW6Qb--r42QM5kF3wFR1d1rdFW5cd8Kt2JPqkQW77hy5m5N4y_0W7dxcrc5Ygmk23mCH1) [Subscribe today](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kB3q3nJV1-WJV7CgJP7W62zYVM7F2bFCW7k5lBM4Gc6pQW7DV15D5lnrbcW7J2gG21h5DTGW7HN67X3x93BmW65w6PM6rX_CxW9lGG1X99_604N1sYr-v3j5-wW1wyG2x1MXxbPW1kYcdF1HTfy3N7sv_dC9MxyhVxp8T35ZNc3pW39VK2M3WLwHBN3bmRyc_5y8KVpjJ7x3cSvbwW2Q9nMm3mbJDRW4CYGl16bKj_yW2gsXLX5gvnC-W1lm4cs8by1NkW87Y6rc61M028VWpvdt7QYh5GW2JsHxk8JlgmdV4B2K-7-mC2QW4jZThD8h6t_b3lPy1) [Facebook](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kV3q3n_V1-WJV7CgGf1W7V3czW62BfFtW2RXxWb677bDlW1qjPdn4yRTMMW6HlW3m1fql56W4tYXsb226c1XW2XzyNV3Gw6GjW4vFthr6FYZLXW5RG4-X5W_jwnW7qSnkt3ybvQbW1l5xb53pLJ7tVMBv_k3Z-12tW8RfTF13xGlf0W7NbZxZ7kWtB0W6yxsY84Vv24XW28GSJg7LtQKRW6lvk938hg1WzW5ckNX91WBZLmW5pCmPd2qgK50W6wm_K_4-RZK8W6S4q6F4qxHDgW3Wpgq736hhRJW2tMZ883fDZhVW111wWP1XmTz1W1yYW3j8LRPL6W9hN6S886yHv5W6CyLp38FQ7B33cSm1) [Twitter](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kB3q3nJV1-WJV7CgHnyW7Z94vK58wglKW8mmfcl5dKBcQW3NxRtl4QTXRMW4C_Gsm4QZD_PW7BwZMQ3lJ36SW2YjSSP3_R3SSW2s1SyW6XtGd8W9jsrvR504HYPW21xY0d3ntLdHW6KHLZB3bQQSNW7VMLRY8zFn4jW2kkvzc6RKf3xW2XQM4j7PWfTQW10LBzs8fwLg_VRMl423DxCFhW510flJ4nrm36VgHhW_5QyYQ_W5vh4lp5p4t8RW3f9yCS57H0msW3fXNJY1qjKp_VXJdZq7mz-YNW2Mfd-75xJr01W2WYK7s5L9gtQW6dCFPb508XJx34cW1) [The Scotsman] Mar 10, 2023 Good morning readers. Welcome to the weekend. We hope you have a great one. Here is your Friday morning news update, brought to you by [The Scotsman](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kh3q3npV1-WJV7CgPpmW6g2Sg_1vSqWMW4MSFNL1qPV5HN5cFK11tPRWpW7m4P075g2x8yW8MfvWt5-TS7DMqCkb7J_7TYW54JDWW7B3S9PW54XRLp1vzDlyW1PKFqV52FfQyW8MyBvL4SPWPLW3Kh6X44gRXpmW5xJgzs98fCjFN7n3JFWGR4GhW1wSg7m8M0q-yW5f6h0b2201MPW5Lz4g3755jxmW4Fv8gq4VN9PBW4RdZRB72k8wJW4z_11_2B5xsWW5vYH8m1-2-MWW8lH_jd7jYplYW2ftlgd2tlXSg3mVm1), packed with latest Scottish news. - Politics: [Humza Yousaf hits back as he goes on the attack in second TV debate](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgTYzW6VrN0D31wC2QW2NXwM63vHjLZN3l_srWF3w6-W2Xl1ts2JBG6nW4Lwf4g1C1lp4W5v2kYG56B6GzW97-tYX4lf66_W7pcYFv1RWwF3N48wj6gZYKtTW8Fctsn2b5SPJN6Dplv9nSz4vW7hK2Tf4SXZfBW8bq2l24YZthtW2znLZP8pmFSrW8kcwl71XHF2fW8swn_H7vV649W1WLl_K3-d-KZW8f-h1w50FRSgW8Ql2s85FRRvbW1-R6Fm7HVB_JW5TCSvF7hrKb9W4xBj5B95tsFzW11r0-86Yk76XVPsy5s2qwLGjW47hzjG6_7QNVW787z1q9f7QtXW3vJnXW4qzcNQW1-WVT_5PXHW-W4gsPFr6vhQGwW6VtXnF18WTPxV58bfz4j3Z-kW64g4GW7qb_wPW4WbJvQ6Sc_FZW2l31V333F4DGW2HVynz5_cFNPW3G1M9l2Jhgkw3nz31) - Crime: [Ex-husband guilty of murdering scientist in 1978 after cold case breakthroughs](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgV0yW6dbQpf5c8Y4KN67Xxdz9cM77W6136g75xQNwdW1jCVqL8ZbB6MW7WRNkR8lvb1SW3wNdT65KT7rBW23Q1Ww6HGVjrW3Gkvkb39ZlnVN8GRkXDl7swJW2n5sS_5D6cm7W7SY9_D1bqbyRW2NYWjH3w4V_cW8LWZcv6k2PCGW30gKBW8px0CSW3Q4bln1VkVb7W66K4MG7KjryWW49s4kd92Dk7hW9h-3Ny78Dq5xVxTgj_7ZV0n8W494x4t5JrSJ-W39gXJg98WbHTW33P6pD21WnH-W34yLxQ4ZCm5BW11HDGZ3gJL60W4Bpz_p2xvY40W3kFLq78NfxDhW3Xhsqs5sXt7zW1VLnQ92fhjz4V_1dnk7JGwmVW8w_BjY3JcmJBW73Zmr82-6ngTN2-R4GPvWB4vW3-2WXS427vVCW7JRy8T5P41jWW2Jd6Sl8Q9h9XW8RcX1Q436ldb36-r1) - Karen Dunbar: [I earned more from karaoke than Chewin’ the Fat](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kh5nCVBV3Zsc37CgC_xW4-Ydzn9dsbnsW94dq6J2HDvWrV1xB7c6Z5FQsW5FWvDG11Lx6fW2KjzBq6d0dxPW8yCQvv66TsXKW58N0wJ8vmcrvW2lr0_T2xJC3-W7Y_bSb5f04lkN3-tRxlj1rWdVwnnyx8XB15RW6xMwBQ6jWJ7hW1fwq4X92kxtwN8jPYB3wsdLfW2GfG6n8PVySPW5Km1Hc6dMQFJW60m1s720DMbKW8ZgSR_6DH5t9W7JRDbV2sn4FQW3YStLV90K34jW4zBKjv1gt6nsW942pBv93n1qDW1BRlH53txtQLW1DNtvs4JcQXqW8b4skt940M2wN6ggSxRJmKkPW6g6WX12Tl0s4W1r273Q5L5fqrW94QGHs7h9Y2bN8WJwxWSh9N-W8tX0922RKHs3W72BBqd4g5NVdW4f5XKV6rj6LqW89YqgM7tHjv5W7NMF8084NyhDW68Pky86qJWvpW5RXDsw2z3rl9N2KHsJxFGLHY3pK01) - World: [Multiple deaths in Jehovah’s Witness hall shooting in Germany](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8jJ5nCT_V3Zsc37CgGKkW7y2b6-7nTgsnW52N3fh35XZ_TW1B-kmk4kdS-TW6frYvq4s1g8TMmfMGrHgXnPW2rzzyb5Z2HCQW5c3Ss359LV4xW4-gR1Q2bcFg2W753q6T2cy-QQW5ggN7m8tCwHMW6MF0HL4Xb1hGW93RwKg7gYcBCW40NSQc7_xwqnW3KTF_J2RbZ6NN8lDdywSqyh-W9gw9fV1JTLk_W41Fx7T5CGchYVjPcm2918qkzW57B4Xj77LthcW2Zm86x7K2rMqW6F7h2v4l1YRMW10dcQf7DGn_KW2WT-ty6zv791W7d1X6X5whkyFW3n36c-4stWJ4W3hvLcm6_CJLqW1zXxWg4k-tKlM7S2ZRMVg11VPdXh81dkm4MV2WPwj33R6J7W5P4Q4B3PtgkqW5fRG295L3nl5VHdKlH1_xL0SW24cBWR47cH5m3hHg1) - Football: [Scotland star 'not good enough for Celtic' but move to Rangers a 'possibility'](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kh5nCVBV3Zsc37CgXkzW7f3DCY3-dPb_W5NS5tr3S1YMPW6jgvyv4Mt5vMW4GrQQW9jSxsxW7GZ4TP4JvHzlVzBr6Y8kSwzPN3rZrvTTZdj2VWyVQ44XHJshF3yBDsB7bg8W88xFw74vxKYzW3bJpF351vtGhW8wqlvT37rhcjW4ncjtB3t2b9YN55_1CyhMNlyW8WrBZL8mCv7rW6FvFNT3r3WF0W2vJYxG5nS1XxW95cNZ64g85zcW8qH3yD49bL-BW7YWWVR5gH9sSW30Nb-R2WxpRjW54P9Bf1V1rwQN33CmtZR5FwqVZPl1B3C7s-4W8MJsMc780tJDW6JjG2j5j7f06W5_bzXB68X8-vW4SpZty42D9nbW5nLwgj7GLtbGW3p6nGY6DsBBZW587Sqw8Nr4yJW4ZxGD27993KfW55ybyR5-nYqGW8G5Yvg5Y9W19W3Wt64M4QSjGmV4jfCv4ygmB1W1J05K05r9-ctW78YjCn6Ps4sN3dBw1) Graham Falk. [SNP leadership race: Humza Yousaf hits back as he goes on the attack in second debate](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgKXqW8mVnqf3sQLhYW2mR4FC5n62BsW20NzfN1G2bVZW6bN1y48SVsqkW7DWQqc1mjlLNW2f3Y-S6zLQsgN4XwSsrL4XvxW5C-GLc131v6HW78RqCy1fwVrRN8zWmX3_HGw1W2CHP7M1ZVy_SW7_5-bN3rtsglW8p5MnM2ZrQZsV95qmH2mML4zMQ66Kvy3mFGW709Y8Y9jQG4yW2-WmNZ5bjrSkW3TQhg73hL19xW5rspfx35gWcNN4lnrB5KyY43W6Hvkxx7q422JW3T5Vpw1PTP-jW2llk133k-6DSW2h5lkS5D0kXRW91FRQL2TghsdN1YYPBy65TDQW4Nr_nR7w43_DN55M9J8Vy3wxVWmkMC1N0L20W55fMmH4C0jrWW4ct6X58z4cFBW96D0Nm73jxYKW259R6_4qLt3VW2CV_M62Q7mqgW2t6RbZ2LpCfKW8dhCWn2Ksfnk3h6F1) It was as if someone had turned the volume down, but left the TV on, such was the muted attacks in the second SNP leadership contest debate. [SNP leadership race: Humza Yousaf hits back as he goes on the attack in second debate](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgJRlW6jgQkb1Ch0m4W8vMnq_6k8BJNW4pCCZx2h_Ym2W8S55y51MwS44W6yrJsh71G78_V2nDzW49RfWnW7R_1bm6Yr0t1W4PWXTM90Jb8RN8-yjf9Jr8z_W1GTggk39lvFwW9lbD5747bWHVW4SkNVT3J9Y3-W8s4bBM8Rf7VRW5gJpkV3t_qyBW5V1q7c4KZ1jFW6Hq1j62xc6ZNW5ML1j78djfvTW3k0C257cBWMkW1tyDJ87YwYXKW8G_5mN6xWVQbW8qZ9WS3Zbr6VVj4NnX2jMzV5W4T4pF36gjcq1W3T3z3B544p9-N4pSPtR-B3DcW1-bRC03cFk75W7TNP-V15L1KkW1Gf1CN4m89n2W97S_cb1j-LvzW5k6wQ86yt2QhN7DFJNJH3FdFW4xqspT4X61CBW8dZLC82T3_2BW38Shyz3PZRHgW7Sx_lb7bzNfRW8vzmQL2NCBs03kTv1) [Are you a business owner?](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8l93q3phV1-WJV7CgFt8W7vQ9Cj5MtpWHN15rrXGxJXwxW86BP1R8cM2S-W3BssND62rCJ4W6L_k4Y95PwKFW3hm6CC5GVGHYW3gH0q910PklHW5hMfRs4RzP_ZW4Mh2g484BThtW5XJttx3WfNTLW2-r72f3xnJqjN1LrX5FV2YTKW2Zs9mj7ZVCDmW6V1tpW59CPsSW4ZhTJj1Mjj1VW6w7hHq7NGGZwW2d_xL324bfxZW6cVK4X900rKjW4dx00w535Rw-W843fjR5Vg9-lW4405nj4f-FfDW4CtJHM32qdybW7tm5pZ96THvhW4FBTBX6m64KDW3FMgkz2CTBQbW7tl2hm3RcSj3W7Hr8zt57Xh1fW2Fj-5S276K7V3fJZ1) [UK’s economy returns to growth after rebound in entertainment and transport](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8jJ5nCT_V3Zsc37CgFbbW4jNH3Z4KXTx3W21NkmW6GGfF6N1fVzFB9CRqcW54H4lS8ZmXjnW8qPHS87QVzVjN5YJK-0qlsYpW91c2XQ2SFYS2N5Jlgss5f-pcW182LBd6wtPGQW1XRr6j2m8DgWN6yRsBTvYw1tW279z6J2P9stCW833jm94MPgHWW7HtbWV8s92VBW4MSQWn6G95xZW7Rf_HF8sHXn7W70Dxxt6YYYKzW22cY8H4DPhZvN8vg7mNCm5WxW1gG63L7vvq18W7yzjFf7HXB06W5tW3s-7NFW9TW1BxNb77Fft5WW5XDVQl3r4msBV3mMj41S5gdpW1V7zDD6C923zW4G7chW1fPV3WW6vwYzz57r7QRW3vSM7n8chB_cW8wb8G73Tm9mGW6nwThj8BG5ZyN1rm77KPK5S2W8G1D7c8_CRfjV7p-k75b2q5J3l641) [UK’s economy returns to growth after rebound in entertainment and transport](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8jJ5nCT_V3Zsc37CgQvLW5Pd1g83kLDRSW3sJyG785msgTW4Djssj3PWVz_W4zhXH392pyJbW7h5g641G8xjFW3jC2Gr30M4qQVv9-wY4VXBhjW7BXHhW346m5kW52lbnh5vFSwqW8ScL5k1GwDrSVjgBlh48GlqhW37k4sV1mwSrVW3xZh2J33133gW5dv5jr4cyFzLW8c4NRY3SLVcMVRNryQ7n3P1XW3TYYCp6k9w0HN3sGgGlcQ0c2W349qcM6dRGGjW48ft4y3GgQc0W3VL1jS3pvZgPW7Whv4d6VCvG5W8wqgW536yNtFVQsmf57Y1k0SW4BLYCG40F7MZW7cJycn32dcSRW4T4pfd1M3XN3W2G0XTt2MB5HSW99ySm_8-SyMYW25m9Mn4vdkjMVT1VLQ2Klc7RW1W9lPB4HWtg_W7Cp3BT8n3j1lW4zLT7l3jyGcP333Z1) [Article Image](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8l95nCWtV3Zsc37CgN9RW8MyTmv54gqkZW2ZwygB5V3myZVg8nlb6Qy5cRW85VjcD5D5fPKW29bDhd5PTlMKW7wmvgS1Rxsy-W6gRMs159YnKCW24kVCN9kdf7_W943HZK3K8NXPW5DrZx95H1TbKW1NDwWJ3P1PxLN7S9rn7-vrfhN3dydhGSQ2YzW2dlNsZ6tWfWjN3SC4q-s2lWHW3bMZ-q5SZnZ6W90-qYw31BhjhW69__1P8t6pCZVSkJZw6Yn8W4W7VWwh66HVm8VW1vgRxm4nV95fW6pbsLr2TcvkjW5zDHzf2R4t6TW3YpvD83GPybqW9j0wnW3tXbxxW4KySG82R5PSgW54vXvY5GZxQwW4zfFPf5fn279W3jr-pV47Gf7dW4mMlXZ6r_F1pW5sfY4R8GSzCrN7r6WwSFZB0YW6SwRz591wQBrW1ryVyp5CB24kW3SPzp47RdCG6W8xw8RD8fSx2bW5YCZHy87yRGSW8W4ZTX6dWw5JTYrQL5-qBWJV6mC8T7GjGpwW5vf8jZ6llZ8SW6BGPqb4nzWwxW1nSYMk1LxYyjW1rZ2gx4-pJj_38sZ1) [Steam train tour dates from Glasgow and Edinburgh: Prices, dates and how to book](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8l95nCWtV3Zsc37CgKlWW3Vnc-W7rSlSzW1RV8R06hrhNwW7zR3xG3ct50cW1w8bnT6bp4cYW7l6qrc8cnwWKN8QC3QtxzV7FW4xK6y84YH-dTVmvZXk3c9hCWW4tNCMG4mgzDjVLzZpP6zlg7NW2vHskW90w93SW7TlyQk3JMnP1W8FFp9P8NbTXqW5wV7d24FhPYmVLGvFp8c-MDpW6K9NHR7yY7jTW6nX5hk6p1VyqW9gWj0315TMJ-W6XgKYB78cBMtW3fqDZ_7yZzCwVmTFcp1JFKPzW8TfgJw7R6LjfVqG3831ZvtgkW8JMQz64LXgp6Vzb8zM1zW6bnW3dTkqD4y9dM6N72GpPk7w4j2W7GSGQd22r88GW3f89mZ6XbpyKW4Jd_Sw7qxzYgW4smzGJ4cP-swW95c1N581SJRgW7s36ZG7HvBkfW6sPNgb1CzNxFW4KRJ-z1X-Xc9W4KJzsW53LXX9W3Kg0XB7cd0pwVxn9WG83zXKkW3d0f013PKJ1KW9gk8h57jW9q2W4s1mj-7wgNdPW6Rk2BN5RzTl5W7xtp-t49xr04W5gFp748nnYTQ3kYZ1) Advertisement feature: After a major investment, enjoy the golden age of train travel with a luxurious twist on board a series of unmissable rail trips in Scotland Promoted by 21st Century Steam Ltd [The Apprentice 2023: Claude Littner returns for brutal ‘Interview episode’ next week](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8jp5nCTJV3Zsc37Cg-HXW3XLZjV14d3QtW1zFj-96ntrsDW5-WHVj8V284cW4Hff9v87-xwZW33NJqP4061XSW1TTwGv7FgVm2W4-Fnkb65jtK9W3snBmz1FQPvTW3NDwW56hHZ0XW34wSZ86xcyhLW6054wf1cpnZmW1txNtQ7DV5zZW37m9kw1W1ySSW42QrfV4ms99fW31Pg9V8cKPF4W13bj5N7tQHLHW2CLn4t300cw-W8Y5XNn1MLpDJVgGlWH4VCTDfW3yQtMX6-MT9RW6ytfs12C3gVmW7yJlqJ8l-3Z9N7Zm4Mj18JLNW7RL0h714sdXjW9bNl7b3V7LCNN2pxpT9fYGs3W3BCp0L5_xpDpW7Gfm9K26zYmFW33f34t1tc7MdW7FfZ3w8fxDlQW5t8sW33kXrRdW2LFc9m6_k0Nh3dpl1) [The Apprentice 2023: Claude Littner returns for brutal ‘Interview episode’ next week](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8jp5nCTJV3Zsc37CgKBdW8pMBYF5b2MypVfMMpB4VNMnJW5KLtVL5NJmKjW5N-R1Q32KtRgW4cHC2G6y7ywKV45lfz98DcBNW2BF0fQ2K2w1nW5y7Tmh1ySt6_W429kvf6sZ85rW4BhJZ96PVDgnVL4rlp487r9YN84NW9K1gsjcN8VnBTxGpmw9W6Q1YkP6RRXbPW55TrM23Px6ldW1W-dZF2M3HlPW74tlvw6Pg9F_W4QLLkc7lnYT3W94m9Hb7ZQR0VVbTRQf34FZqgW6tS3XC1HFKDZW2tm7_k78YH52W28bWG93L9BZrW5fjJr27wVkNkW4tqxdP15QV8gN9bSZlhhfyc8W8PtVn17NfXtkW9jP-MP5xvH_9W1Pm3_s3GJTSGW3fyqLT6W5hFVW9gvQXK7ycLzmW2lG7-h1pQKQ93mKP1) [Scotsman Obituaries: Prof Ronald E Asher, Edinburgh University linguist revered across the globe​](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgN28N8MHqpd-frNRW3QXSxr4mzG41W4Ldns83p-fphW5Qx2Gh8lXnQDW2fVYBG710RJ0W8ZQ1cL4rkds6VXvYMK8qR27YW6MBH8z7840HZW8XSxwl4BHRlJW5QQHHX2yPdLHW7rrYzw53Q8ZbW1rJkMn5ZyWCwW992lQr3Z-zbvW2VsJGc84zsFjW2WDp7t4Plr3hW3psl6H8RDwD8W3QGG_Y6Y0HNqW1Jf27s6dYypWW1_4fFD7zrVQVW47DRXH29nCP2W1NQt9t8nqj7mN1hQ5RJfmpPQVbG-VF1v4D3kW979GBG6mcBByW5KG4Ln84bktxN8kNB4gZN0R5V1ZJvQ27TZsjW7JPYmH4z3XvVW4tTY4C2CSPxbW4CqK7j2CjNWpN3zJD724MZVfW6j496w6VXy36N4CBBS2NFv3jMdPmhkX-mnrW1fZbwr95RLbmW2xFDhn4L2yk-37tq1) [Scotsman Obituaries: Prof Ronald E Asher, Edinburgh University linguist revered across the globe​](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgQCvW5HGtt77TWJKRVmmHL896f77WW89zNJ56X4SX4W68_L5p3yHRh3W2K8w8J6W4QpxW3pvyZn5tQ-HdN5VQ0MQ14jR1W5w6Bcp5kD4ksW63bFSD58s1QvW7qZ8Gk5t_B3bW1m_Z9Y1t-HYkN2sZWGS_mdhgW16Wz3f2Z5cq7W4Qd6Vv3lFP3SW2vWSSG96F2m9W58mnD73XM9V7W3JPg162zKLnqW2RKJ6R8R1QnXW33ZmNF4KDRQgVM2YPS12zX69W8TDbXM7svj4pW7Vtr1_5Q60QvW8TMdYX7nFvVrW2kdPVy73KCyjW1hnPKj130xXBW74W0NJ5GkBKJW8SqHb04YjxVBMHXCM1NbSQ8W3P5FHn1vjHRVW3f14Sq2NTGT2W5xsWFM69M2lBW7FxnHt5P1M8BW2WK-ct6zm4k2N8fgNNP6gqyCVbNtrJ3hWzccW84Jd0V7J7qF-35931) [Aberdeenshire Council budgets set for the coming year](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8jp5nCTJV3Zsc37CgG6_W5Bpzvk7qZCWQW3wr_1166BTMPVprVx61NmN59W9dLctG1l9vhLN40hzdqDfZplW7BszV18kd--cW6crbGx2fl7S2W6QjfPh2kgTkcVn4Jc22-XfPTW7gkT-K7JyTN4W8RDdP96g0P7_W7w96cz2bjnNsW5tBG3z549vLPW1W1yF41jx5pQW70b4JS24VrG8W5H9jY91n60RkW32d9Pj86W2p9W4hYB_h5MnW-1N1dZrDpbsb5KW39mFcd5Tlwq6W7D-kpd5VCQq9W8-KkZB6s9h1gW3NyBDc83QF5SW2HxG7t8FSw0ZN8vfGWbgclMDW1fJNr46cBrtFW52g4Dq2g8n54W8P10207ZxDQpW1MJ91v1hD68hW6fh0Hd8F-5Z2W8lrHPv7464VjW2dVCd85pcJ1G2-_1) [Aberdeenshire Council budgets set for the coming year](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8jp5nCTJV3Zsc37CgF_CW2pn03Y4f-dLgW1wVpfs4kLPRJW4kQqNh6TH7d-W6W6TNp7_7KYYW2qkbY84_170vW6m5rxP7JhgRmW44-jrV80JK8yW4Xx65B5wCQSHN3JpTJQFCYcSW2QRBMB1JX-BZW76G0tp7JJk0CW1501y532VjKTN2PG1RrZzlXTN4Qjgy1CRHkTW94_-1Z4YKZ-8W4txp1z4DZ5tTW6n_qJB41yVtRW3s55sW4_kG7XW5YTJ7q6yWBj_W6FhgjN4Qw9bkW9169GJ37NrtFW3sY4s_4N-T8xW1wwRRS18nFtDW2LZjVx18l7H0W2_3LK58zmW7CW1lRPCR3qYT_9W5mlsPj8_bFdPMkn6WThmK_ZW2DN4tk1Qr7TYW559Yzf1_Btz5W5lTlVz7CpTPZW5_pg-93kWpw13j1N1) [Humza Yousaf vows to bring arts and culture into ‘heart of policymaking’ if he is First Minister](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kV5nCW9V3Zsc37CgJDyW92vVsl46GZf3W4mJcTR8GP9R8W4FlZRw6fPWFcW87B0Vp6nxxDrN2R7g8rpldmDW5cTNGb7xjQ2BW7Yvgs_6fJ6xmW6Qd09531BpcqV2-DSN5npYb4W1djF7J3jrBTMW5zqtLx4x6pyzN2l-BDm3dGlNVpqGF56541xpW6_3J1m5GTX5FW1pY7Jc56VfrqW3vhG0349yBWhW7nrq1T3cb951W49X8GQ5pLqK6W1Tq2TZ4-_Gn8W63W-r34NywRYW2Vvxf_7WTXDYW6SLTFx77RtYpW489xV_1CvsR1W4N5Tlf4SkM3FW8dqQ0F1zqlR9W3jRld630yhz6W2gJf0m40C9mPW7xdMYr5jJtcjW1-X5Ql5-LPfdW1bfbxm3nmzm0W3dqfpx5bC_QKN8pS6bdtXxDJW3fbFXm5M_vxSW2Rpv7c5t6x3mW7GYFnT3hkYpNW1TWFz35tCz31W8Dw9_l7fP_6sW3qMDw06fyxYPW1H8JFD2NH8Q-W3LrC748sF73TVr7SFd5kCMtVV1n3fZ8QvbnL374W1) [Humza Yousaf vows to bring arts and culture into ‘heart of policymaking’ if he is First Minister](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kV5nCW9V3Zsc37CgLkmW4bZ2k84tdSvJW3R5GPg3t7-KXW78My5C8ktY4WW424Dy57rG29xMGJWMw4-Xv6W1p14H956CTQsW6Mz6B291LLWxW7KrHQh1TSf3BW7vGCMT2L4xvqW6VD3RW8Z2NxkW4rTC365xpv8ZW5s9DNb8D7cQCW1b-Btc5jww4JW7rM9l133wkhXW89Fgsk25kCjkW1jXhkH1BRbyzW8nchbm8wHdkNW7hmftM3VjQ2KW3vCv1m1CrYXwW1YZcgK7js2R5W641hj11FwDftW60G7-C7QBvcKW4QrQfW98vXMWW2vfhyc1dpL81W4Gf8Wy78vhqhMmRzqx5325JVQ7fGb961B7SV5HQ-k4mCS4bW8vXYdT313z42VKH5-Y7D2wcwW6wgCHt4PMvfVVTzcG95TN2lmW64HJ1C69M9mKW79TlzB2ZWY0YW7xzmTF7JqDW2W6ZHDQk4CVqZJN2qdJjghWf4HN1dg7LxwcT-TW8v7DDp3rbVxFW5YbG0k6nDbzfVg7Fvw5RjvB7W7q76Wb9cxWbc3m9Z1) [Scottish tech incorporations soar in 2022 - but sector requires more action to fully thrive, says RSM UK](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kh5nCVBV3Zsc37Cg-Z3W5yP5Kr7MDNMfVYtnJb4YcddZW4tl9Qf2djs7LW26Z2_y2K56xGW8S0Gnk7BVHzfW7sGjkz7C5smKW7dJ-mS3VjgclN7jmSmhBGDHHW9jGRmV5hc2MSW3VwCkx7_1VH0W3qr_438j11MJW3bcMHR3hrQ1LW192_yB55vgBTN6ps7H2-8R1CW38J4C08xL3gkW3hB8VX5pVtGgW1YSbXL9c7h54W5kKJgL8jFTmYW7w4bLW19kbFJVNW2SX6D2L5GVvJnyR1W-XgxW8SK-N63ctp0pW6g4Vdk3hm91-W2f59Dh1mq3ZNW2-4xKy8M52V9W28ptCj1Vr7g7W6NLTNJ2dgSTmW6-Bksh4FvF6dW5KxrLF4hZB-RW3T8pcW7NVHLkW2MjMr06mlqqzW3z_yWq5LqLHFW6zMnXJ7-QjX_M68YTgV1pjxW2NGwWG3Cf14VW36fk1d50rSR6W1zGwkS76Z5VgW8jWKRM6HMsQP394W1) [Scottish tech incorporations soar in 2022 - but sector requires more action to fully thrive, says RSM UK](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kh5nCVBV3Zsc37CgCjwW2zn7KK41C2KKVG6kwy686h3HW17wM-n32JbpwW4-7yKk7Swkc1W8m4KzP3JzRzFW7Cnlkp7VqZvTW40-44L3v89XXW7XLrDn1MxwWkV64JYM7Kr3rfW2DF9Tg5dB6d7W799vCg7SYPdWN3ScvbDHC47HW13YnH64QB83HW6936bM7CStBYW2m2-BR481qPFW7PhgRC75451BW2H5pVW2rNnwDN3ycnZkJpVJWW4L524R2QFGqFW1N27KB8pWFl8N4kS1Zyh2MzMW2Vkkm62lbzBNW2-ZHM-11SFrxN9j-bfHdv2Q2W4pP8Fg7QLJL0W3GfKGS2t0dT4W7YBGH467rcHhW1MzgTw4HSTzCW4PHFRC93hCNGVPxxBc4JWHDRN13qtfcSRqwxW2mwY9r9hlQ_5W3W1bg95g8sdnN7p8rGlgkvhBW4PB-Nb7ClCTJW7bnKHY543WjvW3T59p68y2zMSN5LB8H6hPFLr3pl11) ['Those with real ambition need a lot more support than [has been] on offer': Sir Tom Hunter's new bid to lift scale-ups](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgMMlW4Y43XF8KVW3RW5Ndwb25fWk1qW8dy20l2Xq4tMW298Yt8508vPcN6zsjCxVP1S0N5WnZkn1XT6yW2NTjgv7wyP51W71QZGX6VSGgRW77rj3y8th1WMW3f4hjl3D6Z4yW17QDNV2bpV9zVPy2Lg4qQ59lV_w4Hk7MR0vpW6vYM3L3PwsqQW1Q8XPd7sLQRhW9bwlbN9kwC3nW60Ct1B5LkGScVmG0K-2rfrT6W4sQ3z_2kgT9nW1tvPS93w47FJN2dC_SyM6WkkW8mpZch8bxyNZW2Y-XLB6m-7QbW50x7Xl4qdPfFW8MpdPr8kqqRkW2vw1kN3dDKxhW5t5NG58qpmyLW4_FdPG8QcDR0W5msG5L4KM17HW1Py6FZ8--PTQW2g6lwK2c-Zx9W3Gpnd79ctvtfW4zH3vY3Yv8l-W77VR-d5R0VCWW6VswMv95kgNNW4rfWZs1d_VQW3mkx1) ['Those with real ambition need a lot more support than [has been] on offer': Sir Tom Hunter's new bid to lift scale-ups](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgHwkW8gdRHG5lvlBpW1ShdSd2cWsgKVHvJ619lfBt_W3LY4wB2vVhvDW3yPjbD47B58bW15BsTD1gBSbyN2Sk8_mhmc4SW5nF7W75Jrml5V1nNqf606HhdW174Q8B4dXgK8W5x8_mG4w_lnhW4SSCcs2b23FfW1ccBlC8pqdkhW1JGx9L2HVqBSW8RdGxL3wpZTqW8mg9BJ8NhcdgW2Y9yqn5wRcznW5rV0Hd71VY6LW822sFl30lphFW58ZXGJ60V3vKW783Rtf99RPcZW3VLM255r19qfW4pZ9Hq2j2PFmW214Xvr7zRqkyW2YqzMH9bjqM6W3dsQC29bt_t1W8ynnjh2GbSb6W3rwlzV3gnxHzW5xMRYC5sQmZYW286rDW80sqjQW6SjBdk6LffDzW79jN163lg1H8W8pNqm71vxZkhW5wGYMn518TxmW38M2d447ZNxSN3g3RX3cFLRj3kc91) [I asked ChatGPT to write an essay on A Streetcar Named Desire. The result is just one reason why schools must keep exams](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgBHSW6tFPpF5T0YlhW8H7v-p1hKB4dW56--nX7SjyB5W2smZqd1jZHx1W665j744qHKZBW75D_3k1NBXYlW1wMjcL6qPzVsN8MhZff3fhkkW82ScpR1L4K1yW4FNDGP64PVl1Vn4YB47lsvJRW6HHll74rTVkqV_21Dr4bTQVtW7X40TS6yVFYGW6VR6jk2mZzbDW7gsy6w35kZCmN7b1YtWX_p-VW6P2F_c6DR4xgW5bHzVD66B4VnW5xlJHC3ckjgjW8HmpsR1qv6GFVxLztn1Y65V_W2P8R4_8n-yX-W7hlvQ82cbk__VJ_FRN1RtnWdW877wJz4wx89JW6VFZ633mNM-hW4nPWlV3rHllWW5KFKqq5CLppnW8DxRVM2m-PGRW5M9BgF4dGdgrW6ZdZcT53ZMGCW40SZqN5w_zK5W1ZN5gw63_3F1W6skYs866PkPLW3wV22c1mbkg13dcQ1) [I asked ChatGPT to write an essay on A Streetcar Named Desire. The result is just one reason why schools must keep exams](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgZ0ZW8gT0GR5gFgtwW6YYs6G3dpfvkW4tnBtr4Y1Q1yVsRr8p57KFhfW1h51RY7MYnRtW90whx82lFRSVW4KLkjH5x22k3N67tJ5bqx8T1N4CrZsryTV70W2RDfdC7kydCYW7MFdzK7hkRp_W76R7SK18dlTQW9hTSpd2h32YpW2Jc2Gm3r-6T8W4l9XX76ln_rYW158CzS6y_cZYW3Hwzw57YWj2QW2RCGSp98Mj1yW1vlK1p86gnNmW9dsdHH4CzTsmN7sxv6LzgFcWW4dZsCF1WrrYJW1_yRzS8XFTcVW8jndLP57XC74W4bQwVq945j2kW5j6SqG5gpKdWW3pGM9Q91XNh4W5Xx-9F4sblfkW578KVM1CZbv-VNx_lg5zbDgLW3bjFPH6DbjnLW4gJsdc3mnvTTW3hj6sf5wPHWvW4--Bpn84Yp_fW8fqpMN5Ycr6gW2J6zkh4LKTC-2lY1) [Suella Braverman's rhetoric on immigration is dangerous populism – Scotsman comment](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgXwYW6HQw4T6wNGHMW8_rw-R574SM7W352PDj1vYkLqW8DWZ-F6tKwQrW1jw5bf3CqXtKW6Zf38Q5bw4CxW8gRflk5vBJSJW84Mz-q31RG4rW29yqB_2y0jfYW52_sD361QpnvW3p7V9q2wfpGVW90tQMV7JQ1QmW1Br8ZQ1fG185N8nH4jkqSsPpW6Jf4Kp8Tk75DVGQcbW1HKvV6W5kJ2g21k7JZvW3c_Jl65VrksHW20nx602DcZMHW5pQJYc4YKF3GW3PMRjz91_NmQW74jg8w2S9qRMW8zd5p041bc84N7Ty5z-t4QHfW3Ml2pg1hC-gyW24cSDH882GQ4W1fjmPm8TZ_d5W7wM1cL2ZL7rlW5twttR94B9rvVWNzFq4h325QW5BlR3868T4rRVxg1YQ92_WQgW50lhdG5Rgs4KW2FvQrS6SH22DW1XP-q98mM1MhVbbbDn5v5Gzm3k0R1) [Suella Braverman's rhetoric on immigration is dangerous populism – Scotsman comment](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8j_5nCVhV3Zsc37CgM8NW6lqNq855fXSDW1M59gL69trh_W6Wy_R885B_WfW6Qqp3T5cS8bzW2gzgFv5rN0PwW2DfS937JgbJVW3j1HJW3BNh5tV7Vvyj3WlTNtW3qg0kC6fDz_9W4xWc1T8B2y18W5CvL7R8VGv4qMBvPyDNt_YrV4yjQB5xfYHxW5ZRsDb81f86wW2Kwwf64wtvZkW5vhzYK3cqmMsVQnX-v34HVmNW8x6Kcx1F71-sW1RkVls4n1t-yW6nr7J68QwYR4W1Zrspk4d90JsW1L1Lhb1yvbdSW6J2lsL6b8sdMW4Y8yjM5pwKTJVVdxxy7C_5TXW415d3p76QdnQW4fq4-r3WfwBHVHCCgx4vb4ygW3N5Lz13Lq3JCW4q6b-f7bgTmjW90RVLc7nFDSyW3rwK5J45fdshW6bWKqS3lljLNW2tGspn7-Lg0bW1mBQP81f_Y9DW3bqTd11Wy21836Lr1) [Kate Forbes most popular SNP leadership candidate with the public, poll finds](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kh5nCVBV3Zsc37CgF_qW5tgtPd1HdmwRW2tvJVK6vyJb5N5mWL9mf4K-HW2HZRRP4_lZ0PW6sMk-M9gYyVqW5bzPnX1YY5RFW1rRH047yFRGHW6g7TKN1zFSH9W8BBKJR3LKhkkN5y-MJfDbLsNW8Y9M5F3-Tzv_W2q89Gy4zpFdQVk_t7F58TKTnW8mKkBP5GbC2qN6G2Dg9YKmgYW62Wzm72HCkDJN6HJsQ0PcsD5N8gDSvytsmvhW5Sl9RT8487_5W96W6h56sTpWFN7WN0bfDMBrJW3jCtbh6G-_S-W6mYh3T56sqKrW4-wh_13BKx3pW94Llpy8ZYSZqW1yKnrQ5bHXY5W9f6d-C3tgCLqW265Ls51k2fYkN3WK36VGDS20N2pCwj12QTm1W7Z9nmp8WxQmZW94Jz046smFv6W4fV-C390bnGTW6vxFlR5bWMWxW8nJv5y8VH15XW2jgJSr6fwzxtW7jlQpF99JsrgW5Z7pCR3lvS7y3jYN1) [Kate Forbes most popular SNP leadership candidate with the public, poll finds](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kh5nCVBV3Zsc37CgC14W6f_ppP4Hn621W7wmRYk5Hs-fSW1QXtLK5XvlPQW4h5xgC69b3Z8W25nQb11nm0wKW3xS6338hW9F6W96Q1s84lrh3xW2mMZL21F480pW1cvLgC2zk3XvW2CQwL98RvbQ7VzZ6Jd9b9YBzW65jKZT2kHs-vM5pK254dybGW69qsxd74Rwf4W1C1scQ1qLk4xVRbnq78GJn1BW92mzpT2z8zrsW2NYG8s8JSmjNN87z4Mrrcl42W428glb3hbTpfW5mytNw1y-rRcW8Z9wPZ7tF7n6N9jdKY1jq48mW19GSRy779WpJVwvzR54-TFytN4Y_8p-YDJTGW2LY1DL2sqq2PW7zBFNL2_rjBLN4VdGrDd8t4yW99CQ2n5QtMYGW8GGnJ53kFt2cW6-8QTq2rcxHKW7xr4-s8yRVLyW4VfsRD1P302gW1vsR-N539lshW46wJxR7sGJBlW2WVhn26VyPJNW1dk85L3hQP403hyJ1) [View more news](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kh3q3npV1-WJV7Cg-6WN7yPTWN2FqcBW5K9CdJ66svP5W6Wfcf23gvnYWW18Ct6t7qRQ-5W8Ls6gN5Ln3N8W5h9VKh7hCGf2W33ZtR63gtKwgW6N0ZrL1Bv6F8W8fZgtc5GxhBwW7tcZxM6y-0BWW1V3mYN6t10KmW1YHLlm27bp9cW1Tkn5h62nSS8W23m4Gx8wtnyzW1Jz1H11lq1XMW4sL-Ws7HVDYRW8w2sLM65k575W3N8vr-4ft55fW1zrXdW1GXrpwW5JBsYm5Kvxh4W69kWtl75CLpDW2RKPCP7VYS8N3cym1) You have received this email as you are opted in to newsletters from The Scotsman, published by National World Publishing Ltd. To manage your individual newsletter preferences with us, please [click here](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kB3q3nJV1-WJV7CgFvgW3GFqG42M4hCSW24qLL894CVkbW6YkN-G8_BCJQW2hyzr02FwjjTW29GN2B4Kllv1W6rfL6H3DJ9TTW5kDr-41M3_hkW1v-Nwr8GyPd8W3VztYk2qFMGlW6vwHjC89KPQJW8YMk9B2q9jBhW4z33xw8_t-SGW6JZtMb6Khw25W4PMLby75ldX1W6xv9Ng739fjsW77ZPp94-8sL_N16FyngQbPqLW2sX5Jr4zqRzCW7PTpv53T4qPhW7Dn8Zp1SKWtBW5MNFw72xdqxwW1Ng1jh2628Y2W3zv7w28xz35XVvJnCk1W2Xck3ghb1) and log in to your account. Alternatively, [update]( your global email preferences with us to choose the types of emails you receive from National World Publishing Ltd or [unsubscribe]( from all types of future emails. National World Publishing Ltd, a company registered in England and Wales with registered number 11499982, having its registered address at No 1 Leeds, 4th Floor, 26 Whitehall Road, Leeds, England, LS12 1BE, United Kingdom. We will process your personal data in accordance with our [Privacy notice](113/csmbM04/MVSvtjnd-MSW2SgZ717PfF0YW3S9mTt4XZxLMM9V8kB3q3nJV1-WJV7CgHZqW3rQWWd4Tx6X2W17vPmw3170tWW2CZ7wN3Nt2dzW4HJ0S131rKcfW6Vsq-P9dvmG0W4Qhbgf29vWWWW1cJkd478jmLjW2Jt6tX588-sgW2RYZ4t5NXgFBW5mWblb1RDRjbN4n3T4zBBMSbW4gF8LK2XZznfV6Hdtv442MpLW1mT_961JFw5FW7hqSNc14ykNLW6dC2F44rCnT8W53YSv-1wgG9hW7STmn12_lFvnN4WFvVfQnVpZW1zt46Y5f89FHW5KHkpq6fk3JPW6Y4Zsb8tFG4gW3qzBdG7HN1dQW3SPhnp68flYW3p2w1).