EXPOSED: The Great Money Myth

What’s the Ideal Money Supply? [The Daily Reckoning] May 11, 2023 [WEBSITE]( | [UNSUBSCRIBE]( EXPOSED: The Great Money Myth - On the verge of another bank failure?… - The ideal money supply… - Then Brian Maher exposes the “Great Money Myth”… [Is This Tiny Tech Stock Poised For a Major Buyout?]( In recent months, a wave of huge buyouts have been announced… >> Elon Musk just bought Twitter… >> Microsoft just bought a $10 billion stake in ChatGPT… >> And Google just recently made their second largest acquisition in history. That’s why Business Insider declares “the biggest story in tech is the oncoming buyout bonanza.” And according to one Silicon Valley insider, this little-known tech stock could be the next big buyout target… [Get The Urgent Details Now]( Annapolis, Maryland [Brian Maher] BRIAN MAHER Dear Reader, What is the optimal annual increase to the annual monetary supply? Is it: A: 2% growth B: 1% growth C: 0% growth D: -1% growth E: -2% growth The answer you will have shortly. Let us first glance the doings on Wall Street… Heavy weather barreled on through this afternoon. The Dow Jones Industrial Average went 222 points backward today, the S&P 500, seven. The Nasdaq Composite — dspite all hell’s angels — posted a 22-point advance. Why did two of three indxes retreat today? It appears another regional bank — PacWest — is in a terrible way. Its stock careened 22% upon the revelation that its deposits plunged 9.5% in May’s opening week. And this frightened the horses. Reports The New York Times, by way of understatement: The new pressure on PacWest is a reminder that two months into the banking crisis set off by the failure of Silicon Valley Bank, midsize lenders remain under pressure, largely because their battered share prices are leading to worries among customers. In March Jim Rickards took to his rooftop and shouted that the banking unpleasantness could endure into next year. Jim remains upon his rooftop yet. From there he shouts the identical warning: You should expect these bank failures to continue and morph into a full-blown banking crisis. Get ready. Next Wednesday Jim will descend upon Jekyll Island, Georgia, to penetrate the dark mysteries of the Federal Reserve, hatched in that very location. Jim claims he is returning to the “scene of the crime.” You can just bet that Jim will have something to say about the banking wobbles presently underway. We encourage you — strongly — to listen in. [Go here]( to secure your spot. (Clicking the link above automatically registers you for The Secret of Jekyll Island Livestream Broadcast, but does not obligate you in any way to attend the event. By reserving your spot, you will receive event updates. We will not share your email address with anyone. And you can opt out at any time. [Privacy Policy.]( But to proceed… Let us return to today’s central question: What is the optimal annual increase to the annual monetary supply? Is it: A: 2% growth B: 1% growth C: 0% growth D: -1% growth E: -2% growth Have you selected? Here is your answer: The answer is F — none of the above. That is, we have taken you for a sleigh ride. We even heaved forth negative growth figures to confound and astound you, to direct you down a false trail. That is, there is no ideal rate of annual monetary expansion. It has no existence. Economist Frank Shostak, he of the “Austrian” Mises Institute: It is widely held that a growing economy requires a growing money stock because economic growth increases demand for money. Many economists also believe that failing to accommodate the increase in the demand for money leads to a decline in consumer prices. This could destabilize the economy and produce an economic recession or even a depression… The idea that money must grow to support economic growth implies that money sustains economic activity. However, money’s main job is to be a medium of exchange, not sustain economic activity. Can a free and open market yield a monetary dearth or a monetary excess? Within a free market, there cannot be “too little” or “too much” money. If the market is allowed to clear, no shortage or surplus of money can emerge. Once the market has chosen a particular commodity as money, the stock of this commodity will always be sufficient to secure what money provides. Hence, in a free market, the whole idea of an optimum growth rate of money is absurd. We invite you to revisit the fellow’s concluding line. It is the rock of the case against the monetary planners. Below, we build upon that case by further exposing the “Great Money Myth” that, alas, dominates the economics profession. Read on. Regards, [Brian Maher] Brian Maher Managing Editor, The Daily Reckoning [feedback@dailyreckoning.com.](mailto:feedback@dailyreckoning.com) Editor’s note: [Next Wednesday, May 17, at 1 p.m. ET, Jim Rickards will be taking center stage at one of the most exclusive clubs in America.]( Clicking the link above automatically registers you for The Secret of Jekyll Island Livestream Broadcast, but does not obligate you in any way to attend the event. By reserving your spot, you will receive event updates. We will not share your email address with anyone. And you can opt out at any time. [Privacy Policy.]( It’s located on a tiny island off the southern coast of Georgia — Jekyll Island. This club is a place where one of the most important meetings in history took place 113 years ago. It was a meeting that shaped the world as we know it today. It’s hard to overstate the importance of that meeting. That’s because it led to the creation of the Federal Reserve three years later. It all started on Jekyll Island. Jim’s returning to the scene of “the crime” to show you why that meeting is critical to understanding today’s market. And he’s inviting you to listen in. [Click here]( to reserve your FREE spot to learn how a secret meeting in 1910 led to one of the most powerful and elite groups on the planet — and why it matters to you today. Clicking the link above automatically registers you for The Secret of Jekyll Island Livestream Broadcast, but does not obligate you in any way to attend the event. By reserving your spot, you will receive event updates. We will not share your email address with anyone. And you can opt out at any time. [Privacy Policy.]( [[CHART] Could Inflation Hit 20%+ In 2023?]( [Click here for more...]( Take a close look at this scary chart pictured here… What you see is the money supply in America… And as you can see, the number of dollars in circulation has exploded in the last few years. In fact, more than 80% of all dollars to ever exist have been printed since just 2020 alone! Which is why some say inflation could soon explode even higher than it is now, to 20% or more. And if you’re at or near retirement age you must take action now to protect yourself… otherwise you risk losing everything. [See What You Need To Do Here]( The Daily Reckoning Presents: “The argument that the money supply must constantly expand finds little excuse in the facts”… ****************************** The Great Money Myth, Exposed By Brian Maher [Brian Maher] BRIAN MAHER Men spin myths as spiders spin webs... Eve and Adam munched the apple, Zeus kinged Earth, Washington axed the cherry tree. To these fantastic fictions we must add another: Money and wealth are synonyms. Money is wealth and wealth is money. This myth — this deathless myth — commands our attention today. Murdered and buried 1,000 times, 1,001 times it has stormed from its tomb. The very gods envy its immortality. Man chased these gods down from Olympus aeons ago. Yet the money myth lives, breathes, prospers in A.D. 2023. Inflation: The Birth of a Thousand Illusions Explains Henry Hazlitt in his masterly Economics in One Lesson (1946): The most obvious and yet the oldest and most stubborn error on which the appeal of inflation rests is that of confusing “money” with “wealth”... So powerful is the verbal ambiguity that confuses money with wealth, that even those who at times recognize the confusion will slide back into it in the course of their reasoning… Yet the ardor for inflation never dies. It would almost seem as if no country is capable of profiting from the experience of another and no generation of learning from the sufferings of its forebears. Each generation and country follows the same mirage. Each grasps for the same Dead Sea fruit that turns to dust and ashes in its mouth. For it is the nature of inflation to give birth to a thousand illusions. China first went chasing after this false fruit in the ninth century CE. The results were… predictable. By 1448 CE currency — face-valued at 1,000 — was trading for 3. By 1455 China turned to silver to cram inflation back in its cage. It did not revisit paper until the late 19th century. Meantime, Rome clipped coins, famously. Kings, princes, prime ministers and presidents throughout history have bitten the same Dead Sea fruit. In each instance it turned to dust and ashes in their mouths. A Thought Experiment Money does not create wealth. Money no more creates wealth than yardsticks create yards. Please direct your attention to 18th-century philosopher David Hume. Imagine, said Hume, that a benevolent fairy drops money into every pocket overnight. Instantly the money supply doubles. But is this society doubly rich? Alas... it is not. The money supply has doubled, yes. But no additional goods have entered existence. The new money will simply chase existing goods. Thus we can expect prices to roughly double as the fresh money runs them down. The late economist Murray Rothbard: What makes us rich is an abundance of goods, and what limits that abundance is a scarcity of resources: namely land, labor and capital. Multiplying coin will not whisk these resources into being. We may feel twice as rich for the moment, but clearly all we are doing is diluting the money supply. As the public rushes out to spend its newfound wealth, prices will, very roughly, double — or at least rise until the demand is satisfied, and money no longer bids against itself for the existing goods. And so we come to this question: What then is the proper money supply? Money and “Price Stability” Should the money supply increase each year to match that year’s increase of goods? That is, if the stock of goods increases 2%... should the money supply increase 2%? Many would argue yes. It is the way to “price stability,” they would say. They concede that an overproduction of money relative to goods will yield inflation. That is, if monetary production increases 4% while goods production increases 2%. Yet they will likely tell you that gentle inflation is tolerable — even healthy. A slight brushfire in his wallet spurs the consumer to spend… which adds a figure to the gross domestic product. That is because consumers will purchase goods today knowing their dollar will fetch them less tomorrow, that the fire will consume his dollar if he holds onto it . A little inflation can therefore keep an economy on the jump… and business in funds. [Shocking Backdoor Crypto Play – LIVE on Camera!]( Crypto millionaire James Altucher just received a strange box that could COMPLETELY change how you look at cryptos: [Click here for more...]( He opens it live on camera, and shares details on the strange device that’s delivered everyday Americans over $1,170 per month in passive crypto income. [Click Here To See What's In The Box]( Conversely, an undersupply of money relative to goods works the opposite effect. That is, if money production increases 2% while goods production increases 4%. Deflation means people will delay today’s purchases. That is because they expect lower prices tomorrow. And so tomorrow’s dollar packs more oomph than today’s dollar. What is the ultimate result, the evil result? Goods will wallow upon shelves, stockrooms will overflow… and wheels of commerce will slow to a standstill. Under extreme deflation they may stop entirely. Thus deflation is the grand bugaboo, the menacing fee-fi-fo-fum, the ultimate devil of monetary economics. The money supply must therefore increase continually — lest deflation menace. That is the theory as it generally runs. Do you question it? As well question the reality of Noah's Ark… Russian perfidy…gravity itself. But is it true? Is deflation really the supreme monetary evil? Why Do People Keep Buying Computers and Large-Screen Televisions? Consider, if you will, computers. Consider large-screen televisions. Their prices slide lower year after year. Yet computers and large-screen televisions do a very brisk trade — despite consumer expectations of falling prices to come. Where then is Armageddon? If deflation was so vicious... why do consumers continue purchasing this gadgetry… rather than waiting for next year’s prices? Thus we revisit this question: What is the proper money supply? Is there one? Could the economy even rub along without any increase in the money supply whatsoever, if the money supply was frozen eternally in place? Paul Krugman would yell blue murder and denounce you as an agent of Satan if you suggested it. But consider… The Mystery of Prices In an economy of fixed money, all goods and services must bid against the existing money stock. Some prices would rise on supply and demand. Others would fall on that same supply and demand. Consumers may prefer product X to product Y this year — for example. The price of X will rise. And the price of Y will fall… all else being equal. The maker of X will therefore profit, even in a world of fixed money. His purchasing power would in turn increase. But what about the maker of Y? He must lower his prices. But the consumer is the beneficiary. He can purchase Y at a reduced price. His purchasing power has therefore increased. And so it goes, back and forth, forth and back — and back and forth again. We are led then to this throttling conclusion: The argument that the money supply must constantly expand finds little excuse in the facts. If prices are free to seek their own equilibrium, changes to the money stock are unnecessary. Any amount of money will do the duty of any other. “We Come to the Startling Truth That It Doesn’t Matter What the Supply of Money Is” Explains the grandee of “Austrian” economics, Ludwig von Mises: As the operation of the market tends to determine the final state of money's purchasing power at a height at which the supply of and the demand for money coincide, there can never be an excess or deficiency of money. Each individual and all individuals together always enjoy fully the advantages which they can derive from... the use of money, no matter whether the total quantity of money is great or small... The services which money renders can be neither improved nor repaired by changing the supply of money... The quantity of money available in the whole economy is always sufficient to secure for everybody all that money does and can do. Here the aforesaid Murray Rothbard — who learned at Herr Mises’ elbow — affirms: We come to the startling truth that it doesn’t matter what the supply of money is. Any supply will do as well as any other supply. The free market will simply adjust by changing the purchasing power, or effectiveness of [money]. There is no need to tamper with the market in order to alter the money supply that it determines. To repeat — for emphasis: Any amount of money is as good as any other. There is never a screaming need to add more. Thus we declare ourself heretic, raise our infidel flag… and train our cannons on the castle walls of the economics profession. In conclusion, we petition the government to shutter the Federal Reserve — and point its members toward productive employment in private industry. Their services are not required. They never were... Regards, [Brian Maher] Brian Maher Managing Editor, The Daily Reckoning [feedback@dailyreckoning.com.](mailto:feedback@dailyreckoning.com) Editor’s note: [Next Wednesday, May 17, at 1 p.m. ET, Jim Rickards will be taking center stage at one of the most exclusive clubs in America.]( Clicking the link above automatically registers you for The Secret of Jekyll Island Livestream Broadcast, but does not obligate you in any way to attend the event. By reserving your spot, you will receive event updates. We will not share your email address with anyone. And you can opt out at any time. [Privacy Policy.]( It’s located on a tiny island off the southern coast of Georgia — Jekyll Island. This club is a place where one of the most important meetings in history took place 113 years ago. It was a meeting that shaped the world as we know it today. It’s hard to overstate the importance of that meeting. That’s because it led to the creation of the Federal Reserve three years later. It all started on Jekyll Island. Jim’s returning to the scene of “the crime” to show you why that meeting is critical to understanding today’s market. And he’s inviting you to listen in. [Click here]( to reserve your FREE spot to learn how a secret meeting in 1910 led to one of the most powerful and elite groups on the planet — and why it matters to you today. Clicking the link above automatically registers you for The Secret of Jekyll Island Livestream Broadcast, but does not obligate you in any way to attend the event. By reserving your spot, you will receive event updates. We will not share your email address with anyone. And you can opt out at any time. [Privacy Policy.]( --------------------------------------------------------------- ‘Secrets of Jekyll Island’ A LIVESTREAM Broadcast with Jim Rickards & Danielle DiMartino Booth [Jekyll Island] On Wednesday May 17th at 1pm EDT you can watch live, exclusively through your access link from the comfort of your own home, as two of the world’s foremost thought leaders deliver world class economic insight. [Click Here Now to Reserve Your Seat]( Clicking the button above automatically registers you for ‘Secrets of Jekyll Island’ but does not obligate you in any way to attend the event. By reserving your spot, you will receive event updates. We will not share your email address with anyone. And you can opt out at any time. [Privacy Policy](. Thank you for reading The Daily Reckoning! We greatly value your questions and comments. Please send all feedback to [feedback@dailyreckoning.com.](mailto:feedback@dailyreckoning.com) [Brian Maher] [Brian Maher]( is the Daily Reckoning's Managing Editor. Before signing on to Agora Financial, he was an independent researcher and writer who covered economics, politics and international affairs. His work has appeared in the Asia Times and other news outlets around the world. He holds a Master's degree in Defense & Strategic Studies. [Paradigm]( ☰ ⊗ [ARCHIVE]( [ABOUT]( [Contact Us]( © 2023 Paradigm Press, LLC. 808 Saint Paul Street, Baltimore MD 21202. By submitting your email address, you consent to Paradigm Press, LLC. delivering daily email issues and advertisements. To end your The Daily Reckoning e-mail subscription and associated external offers sent from The Daily Reckoning, feel free to [click here.]( Please note: the mailbox associated with this email address is not monitored, so do not reply to this message. We welcome comments or suggestions at feedback@dailyreckoning.com. This address is for feedback only. For questions about your account or to speak with customer service, [contact us here]( or call (844)-731-0984. Although our employees may answer your general customer service questions, they are not licensed under securities laws to address your particular investment situation. No communication by our employees to you should be deemed as personalized financial advice. We allow the editors of our publications to recommend securities that they own themselves. However, our policy prohibits editors from exiting a personal trade while the recommendation to subscribers is open. In no circumstance may an editor sell a security before subscribers have a fair opportunity to exit. The length of time an editor must wait after subscribers have been advised to exit a play depends on the type of publication. All other employees and agents must wait 24 hours after on-line publication or 72 hours after the mailing of a printed-only publication prior to following an initial recommendation. Any investments recommended in this letter should be made only after consulting with your investment advisor and only after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company. The Daily Reckoning is committed to protecting and respecting your privacy. We do not rent or share your email address. Please read our [Privacy Statement.]( If you are having trouble receiving your The Daily Reckoning subscription, you can ensure its arrival in your mailbox by [whitelisting The Daily Reckoning.](