From
nytimes.com
Email Address
nytdirect@nytimes.com
Sent On
Fri, Sep 28, 2018 07:02 PM
Email Preheader Text
A cloud hangs over him now View in | Add nytdirect@nytimes.com to your address book. Friday, Septemb
HTML
A cloud hangs over him now
View in [Browser]( | Add nytdirect@nytimes.com to your address book.
[The New York Times](
[The New York Times](
Friday, September 28, 2018
[NYTimes.com/Kristof »](
[Would you hire Brett Kavanaugh?](
[](
Erin Schaff for The New York Times
Judge Kavanaugh is clearly exceptionally smart and a capable lawyer. He also has a record of lying to senators (more on that in a moment), has attracted multiple allegations of sexual assault â plus, he has resisted an investigation into the assaults. [The upshot]( is that I wouldnât hire him for a regular job with that cloud hanging over him. And even less should he get a lifetime role judging women and men alike. Read [my Sunday column]( on the case!Â
Weâre publishing this newsletter early because the Senate Judiciary Committee just voted to approve Kavanaugh, so weâve also put [my Sunday column]( online early. I think we should avoid a rush to judgment about the sexual assaults, but we should also avoid a rush to confirmation. We need an investigation to address the allegations and determine the facts as best we can.
Because of a push by Senator Flake, there may be a one-week F.B.I. investigation, but thatâs still uncertain. And the tight limit of one week is arbitrary, when what is important is finding out the truth. So a one-week F.B.I. investigation would be a step forward if it happens, but it remains inadequate.
The bottom line is this: A president who has faced more than a dozen allegations of sexual assault is attempting to appoint a second Supreme Court justice who has credibly been accused of sexual misconduct, and those two justices might well help form a new court majority to chip away at abortion rights in the United States. And remember that since Clarence Thomasâs confirmation, [new evidence]( has arisen that makes it pretty clear that Thomas was lying and that Anita Hill was telling the truth. If the same happens with Kavanaugh, one-third of the courtâs male justices will have been tarnished by sexual misconduct.
[My column]( also notes that while we canât be sure exactly what happened (and Kavanaugh himself may not have clear memories of what happened), his credibility has been undermined by other lies. He told senators that his high school yearbook claim of being a â[Renate alumnius]( wasnât a sexual insinuation. Look, anybody who was ever a high school boy can clarify that that was 100 percent a sexual boast.
I also worry about the aftermath if Kavanaugh rises to the court. He abandoned any pretense of neutrality or a judicial temperament in this hearing Thursday, and he would contribute to a politicization of the court in a way that diminishes it and the rule of law in our country. Bottom line: This has been a dispiriting week for America. [Please read the column.](
ADVERTISEMENT
Recent Columns
[Be Outraged by Americaâs Role in Yemenâs Misery](
By NICHOLAS KRISTOF
The United States supplies bombs and other support for the war thatâs killed civilians and is creating famine.
I welcome suggestions for what to include in this newsletter. You can connect with me on [Twitter]( [Facebook]( [Google]( [Instagram]( and [Pinterest](. If you have friends who might enjoy this newsletter, forward this email; they can [sign up here](. Send feedback or tech questions to newsletters@nytimes.com.
ADVERTISEMENT
FOLLOW NICHOLAS KRISTOF
[Facebook] [FACEBOOK](
[Twitter] [@nickkristof](
[Instagram] [nickkristof](
Get more [NYTimes.com newsletters »](
|
Get unlimited access to NYTimes.com and our NYTimes apps. [Subscribe »](
ABOUT THIS EMAIL
You received this message because you signed up for NYTimes.com's Nicholas Kristof newsletter.
[Unsubscribe]( | [Manage Subscriptions]( | [Change Your Email]( | [Privacy Policy]( | [Contact]( | [Advertise](
Copyright 2018 The New York Times Company
620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018
EDM Keywords (78)
yemen
way
war
voted
view
upshot
undermined
truth
thomas
think
telling
tarnished
support
signed
sign
senators
rush
rule
role
resisted
remember
record
received
push
publishing
pretense
president
politicization
pinterest
outraged
newsletter
neutrality
need
moment
misery
message
may
makes
lying
lies
law
kavanaugh
judgment
investigation
include
important
hire
happens
happened
get
friends
finding
facts
faced
ever
email
diminishes
determine
credibly
credibility
court
connect
confirmation
clarify
case
best
avoid
attempting
assaults
arisen
arbitrary
appoint
america
also
allegations
aftermath
address
accused
abandoned