What Is The Stock Market Trying To Tell Us?

We speak with Nobel laureate Robert Shiller about stocks. Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe to [this newsletter]( and to [our podcasts](. Six Theories To Explain The Stock Market --------------------------------------------------------------- by Greg Rosalsky The United States has been grappling with a global pandemic, an economic meltdown, and massive protests — and yet, until recently, the stock market basically shrugged it all off. Between March 23 and late last week, the market [surged 45%]( erasing the drop it had seen at the start of the pandemic. That is, until last week, when apparently the market rediscovered that there’s a freaking pandemic still going on. Public health experts have been warning about the dangers of reopening without a solid plan for testing and tracing for months now. But they’re just uptight nerds, right? Economists consider the stock market a “leading indicator” of the economy, meaning it often signals where the real economy is headed. But it’s a notoriously faulty signal. The late MIT economist Paul Samuelson famously joked that big drops of the stock market had predicted nine out of the last five recessions. No one has hard evidence to explain why there seems to be a disconnect between the stock market and the broader economy right now. The best we can do is tell stories about the mass psychology of a gazillion buyers and sellers, who each are telling themselves their own stories about why they’re making the trades they’re making. That’s a central insight from a new book called Narrative Economics by the Nobel Prize-winning economist Robert Shiller. Jonathan Nackstrand/Getty Images Shiller says we’ve seen this head-scratching disconnect between the stock market and the real economy before. Despite the mass unemployment and turmoil of the Great Depression, he says, “we had a huge boom in the stock market from 1933 to 1937.” We talked with Shiller late last week about some of the narratives being told about why the stock market has, at least until recently, shaken off the pandemic. Here are some of them: The “Perfect Storm of Stupid” Theory Basically, Americans are super bored. They’re at home. Sports are canceled. The kids are screaming. The casinos are closed. And [around 800,000 additional people]( have decided to plop down money on the biggest roulette table of them all: the stock market. Bloomberg columnist Matt Levine calls it “the boredom markets hypothesis.” Business Insider columnist Linette Lopez [calls it]( “the perfect storm of stupid.” Shiller didn’t shoot this theory down. “This is just speculation," Shiller says, "but it seems like people want to do something.” The Corporate-America-Is-Immune-From-Pain Theory The stock market represents only a fraction of the economy: publicly traded corporations. While restaurants, mom-and-pop shops, and other small businesses have clearly been hammered, the majority of them are not listed on the stock market. Meanwhile, Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix, and Google represent something [like 20%]( of the overall value of the S&P 500, and they've been making out pretty well during the pandemic. Corporate America has also been getting a boost from the Federal Reserve, which is [buying trillions]( in corporate bonds to stimulate the economy. The Fed Theory This theory says the Fed is using its unlimited money-printing machine to single-handedly prop up the stock market. “The Fed is itself an important narrative,” Shiller says. In reality, he says, the Fed’s magic over the real economy is limited. But its statements clearly move markets and it has lots of power as a storyteller. The FOMO Theory “I think the fear of missing out is a prominent thing amongst investors,” Shiller says. Time and time again, the stock market has tanked and then rebounded, and investors have been conditioned to put their money in even when things look bad. The TINA Theory Then there is the “There Is No Alternative” theory, aka TINA. It basically says that with interest rates so low, stocks are the only money-making game in town. [Paul Krugman has floated]( a version of this. And Shiller thinks it’s plausible. “You have to put your money somewhere,” he says. Related to the TINA theory is a theory known as secular stagnation. Economists have been telling us about this issue for years. Basically, the economy has slowed, resulting in fewer good investment opportunities. Meanwhile, people and institutions have a crapload of savings and nowhere to put it. It explains why interest rates have been so low (read [our newsletter]( about it here). And it might explain why stock prices have been so high. The Efficient Market Theory The efficient market theory has captivated generations of economists. It paints the stock market as a supermachine for information processing, where knowledge about the happenings of the world are all aggregated by brainiac investors, who rationally buy and sell stocks based on the best information of their future performance. The theory basically says stock prices are always right. Under this theory, the rally of the stock market over the last few months reflected rational investors seeing signs that the pandemic wouldn’t be too bad and that the recovery was going to be really good. Shiller is famously critical of efficient market theory. He’s a behavioral economist who believes we’re not the perfectly rational creatures that the theory assumes. Instead, he believes, we’re prone to all sorts of quirks and cognitive biases, and we’re influenced by narratives that may — or may not — have a good relationship to what’s actually happening. This, he believes, matters for assessing the stock market. Instead of a rational assessment of the pandemic and its future effects on the economy, Shiller sees potentially “wishful-thinking bias in people’s thinking” over the last few months. He says, “If a politician tells you it’s time to reopen and the epidemiologist is skeptical — maybe the politician will win out because he’s a better storyteller.” It might explain why markets were rattled when the thing that public health experts have been warning about for months — a spike in COVID-19 cases if we reopened without a solid testing and tracing plan — actually happened. Or, maybe this recent turbulence is a blip, and the boom on the stock market the last couple months is a signal we're headed for a recovery. We don't know. If you want to share this newsletter on social media, [it can be found on npr.org here]( --------------------------------------------------------------- Newsletter continues after sponsor message --------------------------------------------------------------- On Our Podcasts --------------------------------------------------------------- Patent Racism — Violence, including racist attacks, stifles innovation and the economy. Dr. Lisa Cook proved how. It took 10 years to be heard. [Listen here]( The Very First Vaccine — We've only made vaccines for so many diseases. Let's look at the history. [Listen here]( The Business Of Police Surveillance — The companies that lead the field in surveillance technology are turning against it. The Indicator has the story. [Listen here]( Also on The Indicator: [Story Of A Paper]( [The Cost Of Contact Tracing]( [The Post Pandemic City]( and [The Minnesota Paradox]( --------------------------------------------------------------- What do you think of today's email? We'd love to hear your thoughts, questions and feedback: [planetmoney@npr.org](mailto:planetmoney@npr.org?subject=Newsletter%20Feedback) Enjoying this newsletter? Forward to a friend! They can [sign up here](. Looking for more great content? [Check out all of our newsletter offerings]( — including Daily News, Politics, Health and more! You received this message because you're subscribed to Planet Money emails. This email was sent by National Public Radio, Inc., 1111 North Capitol Street NE, Washington, DC 20002 [Unsubscribe]( | [Privacy Policy](