What Aladdin—and Napoleon—Teach Us About Copyright

Disney's first wish: Longer copyright protection. And Congress was their genie. Was this forwarded to you? Subscribe to [this newsletter]( and to [our podcasts](. [NPR] What Aladdin Owes Napoleon --------------------------------------------------------------- by Darian Woods A whole new Aladdin is back at movie theaters. We went to see it last week. It’s got some amazing Bollywood-style dance scenes, a resplendent palace, and the best magic carpet rides over Agrabah that money (and Industrial Light and Magic) can provide. At about 56% approval, Rotten Tomatoes didn’t love it, but we enjoyed it, maybe because we were watching it with one eye on the dancing and one eye on economics, intellectual property rights, and history. In all, it cost $183 million to make. And, partly thanks to Disney’s lobbying efforts, the Disney corporation will control the rights to this film for 95 years. That’s because Disney has long been a major political force in the fight to lengthen copyright. In past decades, Congress has approved copyright extensions just when the copyright to Mickey Mouse was about to expire. The 1998 Copyright Term Extension Act is pejoratively nicknamed the Mickey Mouse Protection Act. As Disney will argue, you don’t want intellectual property law to be too permissive, or there will be little incentive to create new music or movies. But, when copyright is too broad and strong, the consumer loses out. Great stories and characters can’t enter the public domain, which makes it harder to riff on old ideas. Like many of Disney’s products, Aladdin itself is a remix of an old story, one well out of reach of modern copyright laws. Daniel Smith/Disney Enterprises, Inc These are the kinds of arguments that cropped up last year when Congress considered the Music Modernization Act. Also, when the TPP trade agreement was negotiated, convincing other countries to adopt American copyright law of life of the creator plus 70 years was a sticking point in negotiations. A Long History But who’s right? How long should copyright be? Some data comes from a surprising person: Napoleon Bonaparte. When Napoleon invaded Italy in 1796, he created French-controlled regions of northern Italy that included Milan and Venice. And in 1801, French copyright law was brought to these areas. Artists now had rights to their work for their lifetime, plus 10 years. But most other Italian regions—like those containing Rome and Naples—did not pass copyright laws until decades later. Economists Michela Giorcelli and Petra Moser at UCLA and NYU dug through records of 2,598 Italian operas across eight Italian states between 1770 and 1900. They found that, prior to 1801, each Italian state would, on average, produce fourteen new operas a decade. Venetia produced a little less than this. But after copyright was introduced to Venetia, the region’s opera production ramped up to 34 a decade. Venice, with Milan, became a world-leading hub for opera composition. Giorcelli and Moser [estimate]( that, overall, Napoleon’s introduction of copyright led to a 150 percent increase in the number of operas composed each year. (Freakonomics, by the way, had a fun segment with Moser telling her story in [March]( The Demanding Composers Composers could demand royalties from their works if they were performed by other theaters. Operas became better financed, and composers, who might have in the past emigrated to places like Paris, decided to remain. Copyright boosted creativity. Eventually Italian states lengthened copyright periods to the duration of a composer’s life plus 30 years. Giorcelli and Moser find that extending copyright to life plus 30 years produces, on average, one more opera a year in each state. But there might be a turning point if copyright is too long: they find that going further to life plus 40 years may actually decrease the number of new operas produced. This suggests American copyright lengths could be too long. Maybe you’ve heard the song from the opera Rigoletto, "[La Donna è Mobile]( You might have heard it in advertisements selling [body spray]( [tomato paste]( [chocolate]( or [Doritos](. It’s more than just a classic, it’s also the kind of opera that might not have been made if not for copyright. In this case, life of the composer plus 30 years. Rigoletto was composed by Giuseppe Verdi in Venice in 1851, half a century after Napoleon’s invasion had paved the way for strong copyright. Verdi intentionally chose grand, challenging source material, and took a risk by parodying a womanizing King. The opera soon entered the theater circuit, with each performance incurring a fee to Verdi and his publisher of about 400 francs. That was a lot back then. Thanks to these royalties, Verdi’s ambitious, risky bet paid off. And, with about $600 million in gross earnings in just over two weeks, so too has the new Aladdin. Merci, Napoleon. On Our Podcasts --------------------------------------------------------------- Planet Money Shorts: Government Cheese — In 1976, Jimmy Carter made a single campaign promise that snowballed into a longstanding cultural phenomenon—government cheese. It shows up in comedy sketches, songs, even a cooking show by Martha Stewart and Snoop Dogg. So what is government cheese? And how did the U.S. government end up buying two pounds of cheese for every American? [Watch here](. The Day Of Two Noons — Two guys want to abolish time zones completely. Make it the same time in Istanbul, in Seattle, in Shenzhen. It sounds a bit far-fetched. But in the 19th Century, one man, William F. Allen, had a similarly bold idea to improve how our clocks and watches work. [Listen to the Planet Money episode here](. The Salmon Taboo — Salmon sushi was pioneered in the Norwegian Embassy in Tokyo. But convincing the Japanese to eat raw salmon turned out to be harder than expected. [Listen here](. On The Indicator: All WeWork And No Play — WeWork has been dominating the real estate market. More broadly, growth in "flexible" offices or spaces that offer short-term leases and co-working is high. So the Indicator team went to a Manhattan WeWork to try to get some work done. [Listen here](. Also on The Indicator: [Weaponized Interdependence: The End Of Globalization?]( [Returning To Paradise]( [The Battle For The Office Thermostat]( and [Jobs Friday: Summer Slowdown Edition](. What We're Learning --------------------------------------------------------------- From Nick Fountain: I ride my bicycle to work. And there’s nothing more stressful than weaving through double-parked vehicles. I used to shake my fist and yell. But this week I found another option—and I could even earn a little cash while doing it. If I rat out idling trucks and buses to New York’s Department of Environmental Protection, I keep a quarter of the proceeds. Now, to be clear, I don’t plan on doing this, but a few guys [netted thousands of dollars doing this last year](. Snitches get stitches. But so do cyclists dodging idle trucks. --------------------------------------------------------------- What do you think of today's email? We'd love to hear your thoughts, questions and feedback: [planetmoney@npr.org](mailto:planetmoney@npr.org?subject=Newsletter%20Feedback) Enjoying this newsletter? Forward to a friend! They can [sign up here](. Looking for more great content? [Check out all of our newsletter offerings]( — including Daily News, Politics, Health and more! You received this message because you're subscribed to our Planet Money emails. | [Unsubscribe]( | [Privacy Policy]( | NPR 1111 N. CAPITOL ST. NE WASHINGTON DC 20002 [NPR]