Why Darwin Admired the Humble Earthworm

His charming experiments spotlighted their surprising intelligence. [View in browser]( [Join Nautilus]( Did a friend forward this? [Subscribe here.]( This Tuesday, your FREE member newsletter includes the week’s top science news—plus one full story, below, from The Porthole, our section for short sharp looks at science. Enjoy! DISCOVERIES The Top Science News This Week ABC Transporters Are Billion-Year-Old Maxwell Demons The thermodynamic thought experiment was alive all along. [Communications Physics→]( What It Means to Be Alive: A Synthetic Cell Perspective We’ll soon be entering a “brave new ‘bio’ world.” [Interface Focus→]( Near-Term Pathways for Decarbonizing Global Concrete Production It turns out making concrete—a major contributor to climate change—doesn’t have to emit so much carbon. [Nature Communications→]( Electron Transport Chains as a Window into the Earliest Stages of Evolution A bridge between abiogenesis and natural selection. [PNAS→]( ManQala: Game-Inspired Strategies for Quantum State Engineering How one of the world’s oldest games that people still play is helping quantum engineers. [AVS Quantum Science→]( “Still in Shock.” Amid Wildfire Tragedy, Maui Scientists Assess Their Research Losses “It’s never been this bad before.” [Science→]( The Temperature the Human Body Cannot Survive The danger of “wet bulb” events. [Medical Press→]( This Star Has Waves Strong Enough to Eviscerate Earth A surfer’s dream—or nightmare. [The Jerusalem Post→]( Experience the endless possibilities and deep human connections that science offers [JOIN TODAY]( The 2023 Jackson Wild Media Awards Finalists Jackson Wild has announced [the finalists]( for this year’s competition recognizing the best of the best in nature, science, and conservation storytelling. From 1,100 category entries filmed in 74 countries, find out [who made the cut](. [SEE THE LIST]( From The Porthole ZOOLOGY Why Darwin Admired the Humble Earthworm His charming experiments spotlighted their surprising intelligence. BY PHILIP BALL The mere fact that Charles Darwin’s last book was The Formation of Vegetable Mould, Through the Action of Worms, published in 1881, speaks volumes about the man’s character. Having revolutionized all of biology with his Origin of Species (1859) and then emphasized in The Descent of Man (1871) how his ideas about evolution transformed the understanding of our own position in the world, one might have imagined Darwin settling in later life into the role of grand speculative philosopher. Instead he stayed true to his passion for the minutiae of the living world by studying this most humble of topics: how soil is formed by worms. There was perhaps something in the modest but immensely important toil of these creatures with which Darwin identified. “It may be doubted,” he wrote, “if there are any other animals which have played such an important part in the history of the world as these lowly organized creatures.” Over a year the worms might move 8 tons of earth in every acre of land. Despite—or is it because of?—the apparently prosaic subject matter, Darwin’s book on mold and worms has tremendous charm. It is no sweeping synthesis in the manner of the Origin, but rather, based on careful observation and experiment, much of it conducted in Darwin’s own garden with the help of his family members. He and his children would set out early each morning from their country house at Down in Kent to examine the work of the earthworms in the cool, moist soil. These creatures munched through leaves and other vegetable matter, turning it in their gut into rich, fertile hummus. Their individual labors might seem trivial, but Darwin calculated that over a year the worms might move 8 tons of earth in every acre of land, and their actions could eventually bury entire ancient buildings and monuments. He was evidently impressed by what slow, almost invisible but steady labor can achieve, given time. [Like the story? Join Nautilus today]( The Formation of Vegetable Mould is filled with descriptions of experiments on worms and their habits, sometimes of delightful eccentricity—as when Darwin placed the creatures in pots of earth on top of his piano and watched their responses to the sounding of different notes (“C in the bass clef” and “G above the line in the treble clef” cause them to retreat into their burrows, though presumably not uniquely), or investigated how they responded to his breath when he chewed tobacco or placed drops of vinegar in his mouth. LABORATORY OF DIRT: Earthworm stone with a central measuring peg, used by Darwin for his garden experiments at Down House, Kent. Photo courtesy of the Wellcome Collection, London. But it is Darwin’s studies of the burrow-making activities in the wild that testify most to his boundless curiosity and inventive experimental style. Darwin wondered about the principles governing the way worms plug the openings of their burrows with leaves—an activity they perform with such vigor, he says, that at times the rustling sound may be heard on still nights. Whether they do it for protection from predators or rainwater or cold air, or for food, he admits to being unsure; maybe a bit of all of them. What fascinated Darwin most about this behavior was the evidence that it supplied of the worms’ intelligence. “If a man had to plug up a small cylindrical hole, with such objects as leaves, petioles [stalks] or twigs,” he wrote, “he would drag or push them in by their pointed ends; but if these objects were very thin relatively to the size of the hole, he would probably insert some by their thicker or broader ends.” Do worms likewise adapt their strategy to the objects at hand, or do they just perform their actions at random? Worms’ actions could eventually bury entire ancient buildings and monuments. Darwin reported that 80 percent of leaves he removed from worm burrows had been inserted tip first—a far from random distribution. He then proceeded to consider the differences for leaves of various species and shape. After nighttime observations in dim light with his son Francis (who became a distinguished botanist in his own right), Darwin attested that “It appeared to both my son and myself as if the worms instantly perceived as soon as they had seized a leaf in the proper [that is, the most efficient] manner.” Not content with these studies using natural leaves, Darwin made a more controlled and systematic investigation of the effects of shape on the worms’ behavior using cut-out paper triangles of varying proportions, “rubbed with raw fat on both sides” to protect them from damp. “We may infer,” he decided, “that worms are able by some means to judge which is the best end by which to drag triangles of paper into their burrows.” This suggested to Darwin that the humble earthworm is no mere automaton guided purely by instinct. “We can hardly escape from the conclusion that worms show some degree of intelligence in their manner of plugging up their burrows,” he wrote. “It is surprising that an animal so low in the scale as a worm should have the capacity for acting in this manner.” In an age when human exceptionalism was still the norm, Darwin was refreshingly open-minded about the potential cognitive powers of “lower” animals—an attitude now reflected in the “biopsychist” belief of some biologists that a kind of feeling or sentience obtains in all living things. Darwin’s book was an unlikely bestseller, shifting more copies in its day than the Origin of Species. Perhaps that says something about the English people, whose enthusiasm for overarching theories of nature pales before their passion for gardening. Reprinted with permission from [Beautiful Experiments: An Illustrated History of Experimental Science]( by Philip Ball, published by The University of Chicago Press. © 2023 by Quarto Publishing plc. All rights reserved. Lead image: Tasnuva Elahi; with images by Dauren Abildaev / Shutterstock and Chippyri from Pixabay More from The Porthole: • [This molecule may have seeded Earth life]( • [Destroying an idea is a path to progress]( Today’s newsletter was written by the Brian Gallagher [Gorongosa]( BECOME A MEMBER [Subscribe and $10 Goes to the Gorongosa Restoration Project]( Illegal poaching and the 15-year-long Mozambican Civil War almost entirely destroyed one of Africa’s greatest treasures, Gorongosa National Park, reducing its large mammal population by as much as 95%. But there is hope. Hailed as Africa’s most exceptional wildlife restoration initiative, the [Gorongosa Restoration Project]( is a 20-year public-private partnership to restore the park’s habitat, protect its wildlife, and support local communities. Nautilus is proud to [tell the story of Gorongosa’s extraordinary comeback]( the people fighting to protect it, and the flora and fauna that call it home. Our coverage spotlights the comeback of a peculiar beast almost [poached to the edge of extinction]( why scientists are using Gorongosa to understand how an ecosystem [heals from the depredations of war]( and how researchers are charting the [extraordinary web of life]( in one of the most biodiverse regions of the planet. You can now do your part to support Gorongosa’s guardians and protect its rich wildlife and landscapes. Subscribe to Nautilus, and we will donate $10 of all new one-year digital and print + digital subscriptions to support the Gorongosa Restoration Project. Read about Gorongosa’s remarkable resurgence while supporting the people who made this possible. [SUBSCRIBE TO DONATE $10]( Thanks for reading. [Tell us](mailto:brian.gallagher@nautil.us?subject=&body=) your thoughts on today’s note. Plus, [browse our archive]( of past print issues, and inspire a friend to sign up for [the Nautilus newsletter](. [Facebook]( [Twitter]( [Instagram]( Copyright © 2023 NautilusNext, All rights reserved.You were subscribed to the newsletter from [nautil.us](. Our mailing address is: NautilusNext360 W 36th Street, 7S,New York, NY 10018 Don't want to hear from us anymore? [Unsubscribe](