☕️ Going public

How 2020 revealed the close public/private relationship December 30, 2020 [View Online]( | [Sign Up]( [Daily Brew]( [Brightcove]( Good morning and welcome to another special end-of-year edition of the Brew, where we're tackling the biggest themes of 2020. This one is from daily writer Eliza Carter, who still hasn’t decided on a New Year’s resolution. Will daily lunges or getting up earlier serve me better in 2021? I don’t even remember what my 2020 resolution was, so maybe just “keep eyes on prize” is resolution enough. GOVERNMENT [The Pubvate Sector]( [A man saying "shut down" ] Giphy Normally, we think of government and business as operating like schoolkids and faculty. Even though one group supervises the other, they each do their own thing, occasionally quarreling but generally maintaining a state of peaceful coexistence. Enter 2020. Facing the historic scope of the Covid-19 crisis, a School of Rock scenario emerged where divisions between the supervisors and the supervised were muddled as they collectively worked to learn about music and this thing we call life contain the coronavirus. The first instance came in mid-March, when state governments [ordered]( certain businesses to close so we could “flatten the curve.” Suddenly, life got more local. We all became very familiar with our governors [and their body piercings](. And without federal guidelines, those governors had flexibility in determining which businesses deserved the “essential” badge and would therefore be allowed to stay open. - States [very much differed]( on that determination. And all of a sudden, whether or not you could open a hair salon depended mainly on whether that salon was in Atlanta or Albany. Early on, business owners clashed with their elected leaders over social distancing restrictions. Those clashes continued over the summer, from [New Jersey gyms]( to [California restaurants](. Just this month, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo’s decision to halt indoor dining in NYC [caused an uproar](. Of course, business has always had to work with the government; 2020 didn’t invent the concept of regulation. But it has shown us the most extreme forms of government intervention in the private sector. Another example? The Defense Production Act (DPA) This little-known law allows presidents to give businesses homework in service of imperiled national defense. Trump invoked it in mid-March to direct companies, including iconic automaker GM, to shift their operations and produce sorely needed ventilators. A debate over the DPA and how to use it ensued, reflecting Americans’ ambivalence about the government going from “give that fryer another wipe if you want a license” to “we order you to make medical equipment instead of cars.” - Trump had [initially resisted]( using the DPA, comparing it to nationalization in failed states like Venezuela. - But his critics quickly pointed out that the DPA is used thousands of times per year for military purposes, drawing attention to the significant amount of public-private sector overlap in the U.S. defense system. In other words, while 2020 was a year of crisis, it exposed—and perhaps helped us to contemplate—just how intertwined government and business are in non-crisis times. Then there’s the stimulus In March, the U.S. economy was chugging along with historically low unemployment, then it turned left at a sign marked “coronavirus” and chugged off a cliff. Congress [quickly passed]( a rescue package of unprecedented scale: $2.2 trillion. In 2019, you would have been shocked to learn that a few months into 2020 you would pine for that overcrowded, overpriced bar where it takes an hour to get a drink. You’d be even more shocked to learn that $2 trillion in government spending would be criticized as insufficient. But it was. The social distancing mandates necessary to getting the virus under control put businesses and the labor market in existentially dire straits. Remember this awful graph?  [Economic Policy Institute]( That’s initial jobless claims for the week before March 26, the Labor Department’s biggest spike on record. Many economists agree the magnitude of the stimulus was beyond warranted, and for many critics, it wasn’t anywhere near enough. - One University of California Berkeley economist [argued]( that to support testing early on, the government should have inserted itself even more into the private sector by guaranteeing test makers a return on their investments.  NYT economics reporter Noam Scheiber wrote, “Employers are generally willing to make investments when they believe that these investments will benefit their business. But they are reluctant to take on costs when it is primarily the public that benefits, in which case it falls to the government to step in.” In 2020, the government stepped in to a degree not seen before in our lifetimes. Now, even after a second $900 billion stimulus package was passed, lawmakers are in a heated debate over whether to send additional $2,000 checks to Americans. The public x private collab’s greatest challenge is ahead Much of the lightning-quick rollout of vaccines can be attributed to [Operation Warp Speed](, a government program that worked to grease the skids for pharma companies. And over the next few months, those companies will partner with the government to solve the logistical equivalent of a 100-sided Rubik’s cube: distributing vaccines to enough of the population to clamp down on the coronavirus once and for all. - The early results are not encouraging. With states slow to get shots in Americans' arms, the U.S. is unlikely to hit the Trump administration's goal of 20 million vaccinations by the end of 2020, reports Bloomberg. Bottom line: President-elect Joe Biden will be inaugurated on January 20, and he’s likely to take a more hands-on approach with the private sector than President Trump. He’s [promised]( to wield the DPA to support healthcare efforts and [called for]( even more stimulus.  �  �  �  mailto:?subject=Check%20out%20this%20story%20from%20Morning%20Brew%21&body=2020%20in%20Review%3A%20Coronavirus%20Explodes%20Distinctions%20Between%20Public%20and%20Private%20Sectors%3A%20https%3A%2F%2Fwww.morningbrew.com%2Fdaily%2Fstories%2F2020%2F12%2F23%2F2020-review-coronavirus-explodes-distinctions-public-private-sectors%0A%0AWant%20more%20great%20content%3F%20Subscribe%20to%20Daily%20Brew%20%E2%80%94%20Delivering%20the%20latest%20business%20news%20from%20Wall%20St.%20to%20Silicon%20Valley%2C%20daily.%0Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.morningbrew.com%2Fdaily%2Fr%2F%3Fkid%3D4904f90a%26utm_source%3Demail_share%0A SPONSORED BY BRIGHTCOVE [You Wouldn't Want a Mountain Goat to DJ Your Wedding](#) [Brightcove]( And just like you shouldn’t trust a four-legged ungulate to bump the right tunes on your big day, you shouldn’t trust an amateur when it comes to handling your business’s videos. For video that means business, trust [Brightcove](. Brightcove lets businesses [create memorable, personalized virtual experiences]( without any technical hiccups or behind-the-scenes panic attacks. So your virtual event will be flawless—not like it was organized by mountain goats. You see, Brightcove’s video virtuosos aren’t just experts in video—they helped define the industry. Whether you need [video hosting, streaming services, or new ways to monetize your video content](, Brightcove’s video chops will have your event comin’ in hot hot hot. Brightcove has powered successful virtual events for some of today's most successful brands and organizations—like [PTC, HubSpot, AnitaB.org, Dropkick Murphys, and more](. Don’t leave your video to amateurs (or mountain goats). [See what Brightcove can do for your brand today](. IMAGE [Snapshot From 2020](#) [A woman receives the Covid-19 vaccine from an RN ] Joe Raedle/Getty Images I’ve spent most of this year in stupefied awe of healthcare workers. I especially want to mention a moment I had with some nurses in Brooklyn. I went to get a Covid test about a month ago, waited in line for an hour, and braced myself for a painful nose swabbing from an exhausted, overworked, irritated person. Instead, the woman who swabbed my nose was gentle, kind, and even gave me directions to a place with gluten free bagels (I have Celiac disease). It’s not just the caring for people—it’s the maintaining a supportive bedside manner throughout that most impressed me. Q&A [Behind the Brew: Eliza Carter]( Get to know the Brew writers better with a quick round of icebreakers. Hometown: Millwood, VA...it’s technically too small to be an incorporated town. The closest real town is Berryville. What you would be doing if not writing for the Brew: Trying to figure out a marketable use for earnings call-related wordplay. One thing you are snobby about: Leather. Whether it’s shoes or belts, if it’s not properly oiled, I’m not interested. First R-rated movie: Shakespeare in Love...yes, I’m still recovering. What is something fun you did that you’d never do again? Snowboarding. I enjoyed it, but for whatever reason, I like to slide down snowy hills on two fiberglass planks, not one. If you could safely eat any inedible object, what would it be? Most things that I love aggressively—my friends, my dogs, Andrew Rannells. Recommend literally anything: This tip is now outdated, but I’m going to share it because it shocks people and it really, actually works. If you have a CD or DVD that’s smudgy (like I said, outdated, but let me finish) put it in...the toilet. Then flush. I’m not kidding. It works. �  �  �  mailto:?subject=Check%20out%20this%20story%20from%20Morning%20Brew%21&body=Meet%20Brew%20Writer%20Eliza%20Carter%3A%20https%3A%2F%2Fwww.morningbrew.com%2Fdaily%2Fstories%2F2020%2F12%2F23%2Fmeet-brew-writer-eliza-carter%0A%0AWant%20more%20great%20content%3F%20Subscribe%20to%20Daily%20Brew%20%E2%80%94%20Delivering%20the%20latest%20business%20news%20from%20Wall%20St.%20to%20Silicon%20Valley%2C%20daily.%0Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.morningbrew.com%2Fdaily%2Fr%2F%3Fkid%3D4904f90a%26utm_source%3Demail_share%0A SPONSORED BY BRIGHTCOVE [Brightcove]( Tribeca Film Fest still happened—and was a heck of a good time. [Brightcove](’s tech prowess powered the [Tribeca Film Festival’s first ever virtual transition]( in 2020. The result? [Higher engagement across all platforms](. Get the full scoop on how Brightcove took the Tribeca Film Festival to new virtual heights, [right here](. BREW'S BETS Miss driving? On [this website]( you can cruise around in dozens of cities—from Buenos Aires to Tokyo—while listening to the local radio. Boyhood IRL: Every day for 20 years, Noah Kalina took a photo of himself. When you [watch him grow up]( you will feel things in your tummy. If you want to make a similar video of your own (or of your cat), [this app]( is a great tool. GAMES [Fun With the Alphabet](#) Today’s trivia question is adapted from our second [Zoom Trivia Night package](. Within the categories below, what is the first entry in alphabetical order? For example, if we said “months of the year” the answer would be April. - U.S. national parks - Zodiac signs - Seven dwarfs - Sports at the Summer Olympics - Fellowship of the Ring members - Dow companies (not including a number) - Cities home to an Ivy League college - First name of Backstreet Boys band members SHARE THE BREW When you [share the Brew]( with your network, you earn free swag like our classic Morning Brew t-shirt. Are you one of those people who is always going places? Then you probably need a shirt. Might as well be this bad boy with the Morning Brew logo plastered across the chest. [Click here to get free swag.]( Hit the button below to learn more and access your rewards hub. [Click to Share]( Or copy & paste your referral link to others: [morningbrew.com/daily/r/?kid=4904f90a]( GAMES ANSWER 1. Acadia National Park, Maine 2. Aquarius 3. Bashful 4. Archery 5. Aragorn 6. American Express 7. Cambridge, MA 8. AJ McLean             Written by [Eliza Carter]( Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up [here](. WANT MORE BREW?  Retail newsletter → [Retail Brew](  Tech newsletter → [Emerging Tech Brew](  Marketing newsletter → [Marketing Brew](  Recommendations newsletter → [Sidekick](  Business podcast → [Business Casual]( [ADVERTISE]( // [CAREERS]( // [SHOP]( Update your email preferences or unsubscribe [here](. View our privacy policy [here](. Copyright ©2020 Morning Brew. All rights reserved. 40 Exchange Pl., Suite #300, New York, NY 10005