Ignore Wall Street Groupthink on Banks

How lack of independent thought led to our economic downfall in 2008... [Turn Your Images On] [Ignore Wall Street Groupthink on Banks]( [Turn Your Images On] [Michael Carr, Senior Technical Analyst]( A few weeks ago, Adam O’Dell wrote about the importance of independent financial analysis to his Green Zone Fortunes subscribers. (If you’re [part of that group]( you know what I’m talking about.) As he noted, independent financial strategies and ideas are exactly what we provide here at Money & Markets. I want to emphasize this point, especially considering how the 2008 financial crisis could have been avoided with more minds in this camp. By now, you’re likely familiar with that story … the crisis started in the subprime mortgage market. Those mortgages propped up home prices and fueled a bubble. However, what you might not realize is that the entire process unraveled because of a lack of independent analysis. To understand why that happened, we need to first take a closer look at how the mortgage market operates and how it deviated from the norm… --------------------------------------------------------------- [Turn Your Images On]( [3 Times Bigger Than the 2008 Financial Crisis?]( Banks are in turmoil right now. But it’s much worse than people think. Which is why Adam O’Dell is going live on Wednesday, May 31 at 1 p.m. Eastern. He’ll share his latest research including how to help protect and grow your wealth in these turbulent times. [Go here to reserve your spot now.]( --------------------------------------------------------------- Mortgage Market Goes Rogue To put it simply, mortgage brokers get paid when they make loans. And if they aren’t held to high standards, some brokers will get loans for anyone. That’s why we count on underwriters to set independent standards. They set the rules and verify they’re followed. In the mid-2000s bubble, however, they eased the rules. There was a class of loan available to applicants with “no income, no job and no assets,” aka NINJAS. In normal times, no one would lend money to NINJAs for 30 years. But these weren’t normal times. Underwriters decided that property values can only go up. This allowed them to consider the potential returns on the property rather than the borrower’s ability to repay the loan. So what caused this shift? Well, the underwriters wanted to get paid. If they didn’t approve the loans, someone else would. In that position, many underwriters sacrificed their independent guidelines in pursuit of large paydays. Loans also need funding, and the funders (large banks and institutions) could have stopped the insanity. But they wanted high returns that subprime loans offered. That kept the money flowing for a time. Still, funding sources would have eventually dried up. Of course, before the funders ran out of money, Wall Street came to the rescue. How Derivatives Led to Economic Failure Mortgages have been packaged and resold for decades. This allows large institutions to invest in the market. Large funds don’t want to hold thousands of individual mortgages. So Wall Street derivatives sales reps would track down thousands of mortgages for them. They would assemble them into a single instrument with similar characteristics, aka mortgage bonds. Loan servicing companies collect payments and send the profits to the bondholders. This system worked well, and it still does. But derivatives sales reps also wanted a payday. They realized they could “slice and dice” the bonds into multiple securities with fees attached to each. As an example, think of a bank that issued 100 loans in a small town all maturing in 30 years. There are dozens of banks like that. A traditional mortgage bond collects these loans into one bond. Over time, some of the mortgages will be paid off early, some will default and some will provide bondholders with steady income over 30 years. Derivatives teams saw this as an opportunity to create new products. They might slice the bond into 30 pieces. The interest due in each year would be a separate bond. Income in the first year was likely to be high. Interest in year 30 would be significantly lower. Each slice could be priced and resold. But no one could quickly assess the risk of each slice. So independent bond rating agencies took on the task. Raters decided the bonds would be AAA-rated if they were geographically diversified. They reasoned that defaults might occur in one town when a factory closes. But if there were hundreds of towns represented in each slice, the risks were spread out enough. Even though the ratings agencies said they were independent, their analysis wasn’t. No one wanted to rock the boat and challenge the model as questions led to lower ratings. Derivatives teams would take bonds elsewhere if they couldn’t get a AAA rating. It’s not quite that simple, but it’s also not that complex. Independence gave way to groupthink. There weren’t many truly independent analysts looking at the problem. But independent minds like Michael Burry and John Paulson profited from the crisis they saw coming. They realized the loans were so bad, problems would develop everywhere. These derivatives had transformed real estate from a local problem to a national economic risk. Burry made [$100 million]( for himself and $700 million for his investors. Paulson made [$4 billion]( and billions more for his investors. This is worth remembering now as we face another crisis. --------------------------------------------------------------- [Turn Your Images On]( From our Partners at Banyan Hill Publishing. [The Greatest Threat to America Starts July 2023]( I’ve been warning about this threat for six months. And FINALLY, politicians are starting to pay attention to this grave threat to American freedoms. In a recent press conference, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis rightly echoed my warnings, saying: “The reckless adoption of a ‘centralized digital dollar’... will stifle innovation and promote government-sanctioned surveillance.” That’s why I want you to [go here now](. Because the plot I first warned about six months ago — originally called “Project Hamilton” — is about to become reality this July... Project Hamilton’s “official” research ended this past December — but its impact will soon affect every man, woman and child in America for generations to come. [Because this July — the Federal Reserve officially launches what I believe to be the first step toward a full digital dollar.]( --------------------------------------------------------------- Avoid the Dangers of Groupthink in a Crisis Groupthink is setting in again. Many believe the worst of the crisis is over. Wall Street analysts have an incentive to believe that. If they downgrade banks in trouble, they may lose access to the management teams for those institutions. That means less detail for research reports. It also means potentially being shut out of deals to help prop up the banks. Those deals can generate millions in fees which creates a strong incentive to say nice things. Unfortunately, that keeps many blind to what’s going on. Truly independent analysts aren’t trying to generate investment banking business. They aren’t worried about maintaining access to company insiders. Truly independent analysts like Adam and myself just want to make money — and we want to help you do the same. We do that with honest insights into the financial world. Our work doesn’t always overlap — but it certainly does right now. I agree with Adam that the banking crisis isn’t over. And we both believe there will be significant opportunities to profit from this. Adam’s sharing [his latest insights]( into this crisis later today… He’s been tracking the financial sector for months — since even before Silicon Valley Bank collapsed in March — and he’s flagged 282 U.S. financial stocks as ones to avoid. On top of that, he’s putting together an “off Wall Street” trade on a small handful of companies that post immense systemic risk. He wants to show you [how to follow]( those independent minds that turn collapse into opportunity. And if you want to be one of the first to learn about how to follow Adam’s guidance during this crisis, [click here]( to make sure you’re on the list for his 1 p.m. Eastern time presentation later today. Until next time, [Michael Carr signature] Michael Carr Senior Technical Analyst, Money & Markets --------------------------------------------------------------- Check Out More From Stock Power Daily: - [TIME TO PARTY LIKE IT’S 2008]( - [THE OTHER SIDE OF THE BANKING CRISIS]( - [2 FACTORS HELP YOU SPOT HIGH-RISK BANKS LIKE KEYCORP]( Privacy Policy The Money & Markets, P.O. Box 8378, Delray Beach, FL 33482. To ensure that you receive future issues of Money & Markets, please add info@mb.moneyandmarkets.com to your address book or [whitelist]( within your spam settings. For customer service questions or issues, please contact us for assistance. The mailbox associated with this email address is not monitored, so please do not reply. Your feedback is very important to us so if you would like to contact us with a question or comment, please click here: [( Legal Notice: This work is based on what we've learned as financial journalists. It may contain errors and you should not base investment decisions solely on what you read here. It's your money and your responsibility. Nothing herein should be considered personalized investment advice. Although our employees may answer general customer service questions, they are not licensed to address your particular investment situation. Our track record is based on hypothetical results and may not reflect the same results as actual trades. Likewise, past performance is no guarantee of future returns. Certain investments carry large potential rewards but also large potential risk. Don't trade in these markets with money you can't afford to lose. Money & Markets permits editors of a publication to recommend a security to subscribers that they own themselves. However, in no circumstance may an editor sell a security before our subscribers have a fair opportunity to exit. Any exit after a buy recommendation is made and prior to issuing a sell notification is forbidden. The length of time an editor must wait after subscribers have been advised to exit a play depends on the type of publication. (c) 2023 Money & Markets, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Protected by copyright laws of the United States and treaties. This Newsletter may only be used pursuant to the subscription agreement. Any reproduction, copying, or redistribution, (electronic or otherwise) in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Money & Markets. P.O. Box 8378, Delray Beach, FL 33482. (TEL: 800-684-8471) Remove your email from this list: [Click here to Unsubscribe](