My Interview With Two Investment Legends

Last week, I had the opportunity to interview two investment legends - Burton Malkiel and Jeremy Siegel - live on YouTube. [Shield] AN OXFORD CLUB PUBLICATION [Liberty Through Wealth]( [View in browser]( SPONSORED [Putin's boneheaded mistake could make Americans INCREDIBLY RICH!]( [Putin Infuriated]( Source: [Wikimedia Commons]( The mainstream media isn't talking about this, but Americans who catch on early to this mistake made by Vladimir Putin... could become wealthy. This will be sure to infuriate him! [ Click Here to See How]( EDITOR'S NOTE Alexander Green always points to insider buying as [one of his favorite ways to identify great stocks](. After all, insiders know more about a company's [inner workings]( than industry analysts will ever know. More about its products, suppliers, competitors, employees, customers, research and development, and, most importantly, sales. So [Alex always watches insiders closely](. And just a few days ago, he found something very unusual happening at a [$12 energy company](. [Alex shares the details here.]( - Nicole Labra, Senior Managing Editor THE SHORTEST WAY TO A RICH LIFE [Why I (Mostly) Agree With Burton Malkiel]( [Alexander Green | Chief Investment Strategist | The Oxford Club]( [Alexander Green]( On Friday, my friend and fellow financial analyst Mark Skousen and I had the opportunity to interview two investment legends - Burton Malkiel and Jeremy Siegel - live on YouTube. ([You can watch that video here.]( Both men have written investment classics. Siegel is the author of [Stocks for the Long Run](. Malkiel is the author of [A Random Walk Down Wall Street](. Both are long-term bulls on equities - and have been for many decades. Malkiel, in particular, is one of just a few individuals alive today who have profoundly affected modern investment thinking. His position is straightforward. He believes that rational, self-interested investors take all public information and immediately incorporate it into the prices of stocks. This is where we get the term "efficient market." He therefore concludes that market timing and stock selection are unwise, that it is simply not possible to beat the market over the long term, and you would be well advised to give up that dream and just own a broad selection of index funds. I agree with much of what Malkiel says. Much... but certainly not all. SPONSORED [RETIREMENT ALERT]( [Debt Bomb]( U.S. Debt now over $30 trillion! Discover the IRS loophole that can protect your life's savings before it's too late. [GET THE FREE KIT NOW.]( For starters, you can always count on investors to be self-interested. But rational? Not always. Take a look at recent history. How rational were investors 23 years ago when they bid internet and technology stocks to the skies, forgoing sales and earnings for financial metrics like "eyeballs" and "web hits"? How rational were they 15 years ago when they put themselves deeply in hock to flip land, rental properties, vacation homes and condos because "real estate always goes up"? How rational were they when they dumped stocks en masse during the financial crisis of 2008 - with the Dow at 6,500 - and plunked the proceeds into money market funds just as yields reached an all-time low? And how rational were they a few years ago when they bid crypto to the moon? Investors behave rationally most of the time. But it is certainly not the case that all (or even most) investors behave rationally all the time. And that creates opportunity. Here's another flaw in the "random walk" argument. Malkiel mentions that investors incorporate all "public information" into the prices of stocks. But [how about nonpublic information]( Most investors don't have access to nonpublic information. But that doesn't mean no one has access to it. Some of the best trades I've ever made have resulted from visiting a retailer and asking the manager how regional and national sales are going. Are they supposed to talk about these things? Absolutely not. But do they? Yes, sometimes they do. [Gaining a bit of key information by talking to customers, suppliers, competitors and employees can give you an edge.]( How about the insiders themselves? Officers and directors have access to all manner of [material, nonpublic information](. That can give them [an enormous advantage]( over ordinary investors when they trade. It's also why Uncle Sam requires them to file a Form 4 with the Securities and Exchange Commission, divulging how many shares they bought, at what price, and on what date, any time they buy or sell their own company's shares. If you watch what the insiders are doing, you won't access the nonpublic information that they possess. But [you'll certainly know whether they think their companies' shares are overvalued or undervalued](. And that's crucial information. In short, Malkiel is right that it's difficult to beat the market. But futile to try? Not only have men like Warren Buffett and Peter Lynch disproved that line of thinking, but so has our own Oxford Trading Portfolio in [The Oxford Communiqué](. We have beaten the S&P 500 by a wide margin for more than 20 years now. But while Malkiel is mistaken on some points, he is absolutely right on others. For example, he believes it is a fool's errand to try to time the market. I agree. It's easy to look back and see what you should have done. But when you look forward it's always a blank slate. At the beginning of the year, for instance, many analysts were bearish due to high inflation and rising interest rates. Yet the S&P 500 rose 15% in the first six months of the year. And the Nasdaq more than doubled that return, turning in its best first-half performance since 1983. Sitting on the sidelines - timing the market, in other words - cost many investors dearly. Malkiel insists that an index fund will outperform the vast majority of actively managed funds over time. He's right. Studies show that 3 out of 4 actively managed funds underperform their benchmarks each year. Over periods of a decade or more, 95% of them underperform. In short, I agree with Malkiel far more than I disagree with him. His research - and similar work by John Bogle, Jeremy Siegel and others - has had a profound impact on the development of my own investment philosophy. In fact, our Gone Fishin' Portfolio is the very embodiment of much of what he espouses in A Random Walk Down Wall Street. Our Oxford Trading Portfolio? That's a different story. It shows that careful analysis and due diligence can lead to market-beating performance. I'd call that a nonrandom success. It's smart to make index funds the foundation of your portfolio. But [you can add a potential performance kicker by carefully selecting individual stocks]( - and sticking to a proven sell discipline to protect your principal and your profits. Good investing, Alex [Leave a Comment]( [IU 2024]( WEALTH OPPORTUNITIES - [We've Gone From an Income Desert to an Income OASIS...]( - [Discover the Top Passive Income Opportunity for 2023...]( [Panic?]( [Click here]( to watch Alex's latest video update. JOIN THE CONVERSATION [Facebook]( [Facebook]( [Twitter]( [Twitter]( [Email Share](mailto:?subject=A%20great%20piece%20from%20Liberty%20Through%20Wealth...&body=From%20Liberty%20Through%20Wealth:%0D%0A%0DLast%20week,%20I%20had%20the%20opportunity%20to%20interview%20two%20investment%20legends%20-%20Burton%20Malkiel%20and%20Jeremy%20Siegel%20-%20live%20on%20YouTube.%0A%0D [Email Share](mailto:?subject=A%20great%20piece%20from%20Liberty%20Through%20Wealth...&body=From%20Liberty%20Through%20Wealth:%0D%0A%0DLast%20week,%20I%20had%20the%20opportunity%20to%20interview%20two%20investment%20legends%20-%20Burton%20Malkiel%20and%20Jeremy%20Siegel%20-%20live%20on%20YouTube.%0A%0D MORE FROM LIBERTY THROUGH WEALTH [Gambling Table]( [The Stock Market Is Like a Casino (And That's a Good Thing)]( [SEC America]( [Follow Insiders to Profits]( [American Celebration]( [What's So Great About America]( [Economic Inequality]( [The Shocking Cause of U.S. Economic Inequality]( SPONSORED [Five Dividend Stocks to Buy Now (FREE INSIDE)]( Marc Lichtenfeld - income expert and author of Get Rich with Dividends - is giving away his Ultimate Dividend Package... Completely free of charge! Seriously, no credit card required. Inside, you'll get the names and ticker symbols of his TOP FIVE dividend stocks right now, including... - An "A"-rated, ultra-safe dividend stock with a huge 8% yield - Three of Marc's favorite "Extreme Dividend" stocks, which could supercharge your income - And finally, his No. 1 dividend stock for a LIFETIME of income. [Click here before the download link expires.]( [The Oxford Club]( You are receiving this email because you subscribed to Liberty Through Wealth. Liberty Through Wealth is published by The Oxford Club. Questions? Check out our [FAQs](. Trying to reach us? [Contact us here.]( Please do not reply to this email as it goes to an unmonitored inbox. [Privacy Policy]( | [Whitelist Liberty Through Wealth]( | [Unsubscribe]( © 2023 The Oxford Club, LLC All Rights Reserved The Oxford Club | [105 West Monument Street](#) | [Baltimore, MD 21201](#) North America: [877.806.4508](#) | International: [+1.443.353.4610](#) [Oxfordclub.com]( Nothing published by The Oxford Club should be considered personalized investment advice. Although our employees may answer your general customer service questions, they are not licensed under securities laws to address your particular investment situation. No communication by our employees to you should be deemed personalized investment advice. We allow the editors of our publications to recommend securities that they own themselves. However, our policy prohibits editors from exiting a personal trade while the recommendation to subscribers is open. In no circumstance may an editor sell a security before subscribers have a fair opportunity to exit. The length of time an editor must wait after subscribers have been advised to exit a play depends on the type of publication. All other employees and agents must wait 24 hours after publication before trading on a recommendation. Any investments recommended by The Oxford Club should be made only after consulting with your investment advisor and only after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company. Protected by copyright laws of the United States and international treaties. The information found on this website may only be used pursuant to the membership or subscription agreement and any reproduction, copying or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including on the world wide web), in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of The Oxford Club, LLC, 105 West Monument Street, Baltimore, MD 21201.