Safety advocates and some state leaders have been down this road before but are hoping the third try will be the charm.
â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â â [Los Angeles Times]
[Essential California Newsletter] May 16, 2023
[View in browser](
[Click to view images]( speed-limit sign near Bret Harte Elementary School in Burbank. (Tim Berger / Burbank Leader) By Ryan Fonseca Good morning, and welcome to the Essential California [newsletter](. Itâs Tuesday, May 16. Thereâs a common factor in many traffic collisions, one that plays a vital role in how severe or deadly a crash ends up: speed. Itâs basic physics: The faster we drive, the more force we create. Driving faster limits our field of vision and our response time â and means it takes longer to come to a full stop. That compounds the odds that hitting a person who is walking, biking or otherwise not traveling in a vehicle will result in severe or fatal injuries. An average of more than 3,800 people per year were killed in California traffic collisions [from 2018 to 2022.]( growing share of those deaths has been pedestrians and bicyclists who are struck by a car. California is not unique. Traffic deaths have surged across the U.S. in recent years. But dozens of cities have responded with a technology that has successfully reduced speeding. Automated speed enforcement programs, a.k.a. speed cameras, [have been used in other states]( as an effective tool to curb dangerous driver behavior and, by extension, serious and fatal crashes. Thereâs a new effort to try out the technology in a handful of California cities, though the state bill â now on its third iteration in as many years â is in jeopardy (again). ADVERTISEMENT
What the bill would do In its latest iteration, [Assembly Bill 645]( would establish a five-year pilot program in six cities â San Jose, Oakland, Los Angeles, Glendale, Long Beach and San Francisco â to allow speed cameras on select corridors: - School zones
- City streets with the highest incidences of fatal and severe injury crashes, designated as âsafety corridorsâ
- Streets with a history of races and side shows The bill mandates that the cameras capture solely rear license plates on vehicles going more than 11 miles per hour over the speed limit. It also prohibits the use of facial recognition technology and requires each city to develop a âracial and economic equity impact analysisâ in collaboration with community stakeholders to ensure that speed cameras are not disproportionately installed in low-income neighborhoods.
Tickets would start at $50 for vehicles traveling between 11 and 15 mph over the posted speed limit, then increase with a driverâs measured speed. Low-income residents would have the option of reduced fees or community service in lieu of the fine. The money generated through camera programs could be used only to sustain the program or to fund street safety upgrades in the areas where cameras are placed. An uncertain fate Damian Kevitt, executive director of the nonprofit [Streets Are for Everyone]( has been advocating for speed cameras for years. He and a coalition of safety advocates, community leaders and family members whoâve lost loved ones to reckless speeding crashes [gathered Monday at Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendonâs district office]( in Lakewood, calling on the leader to move AB 645 forward for a vote on the Assembly floor. They also delivered a report analyzing dangerous speeding in several school zones across the state, along with some 2,000 petition signatures in favor of AB 645. Right now, the bill is sitting in the Assembly Appropriations Committeeâs suspense file. If Assemblymember Chris Holden (D-Pasadena) does not move it to the Assembly floor by Friday (a key legislative deadline), it will die in the committee, which is what happened in previous years. Kevitt said there have been âreasons that are given on paperâ for why the legislation didnât make it but is concerned that there might be undisclosed motives that are never shared outside the Appropriations Committee, which he called a âdemocratic black hole.â All the while, [traffic violence]( continues to affect communities across the state. In Los Angeles, 312 people died in traffic collisions last year â the highest annual toll in at least 20 years. âEnough is enough,â Kevitt said. âThis is a tool that can be used to save lives â and should be used to save lives.â Assemblymember Laura Friedman (D-Glendale), who co-authored AB 645, wonders why the bill goes to the Appropriations Committee at all. âThis is an opt-in from cities, and theyâre bearing the cost of the program, not the state,â Friedman told me, adding: âWe have a waiting list of cities wanting to get in on this, because they feel that this is a tool that will address speed racing [and] really egregious reckless driving â and they know that their law enforcement just canât be everywhere at once. Theyâre asking: âLet us try this, let us see if this makes a difference.ââ A spokesperson from Rendonâs office said he âdoes not comment on bills that have not yet reached the Assembly floor,â adding that Rendon has received the groupâs report âand will look at it.â Holden was not available for comment. ADVERTISEMENT
An âeffective and reliable technologyâ with a history of opposition In New York City, speed cameras were added to some school zones beginning in 2014. In the following years through December 2021, speeding on those corridors fell an average of 73%. The city expanded the program in 2022 to run cameras 24/7 rather than during the previously limited school hours. A speed-camera pilot program on one dangerous street in Philadelphia resulted in 30% fewer crashes there compared with the citywide average and 50% fewer traffic deaths. The Federal Highway Administration [calls speed cameras]( âan effective and reliable technology to supplement more traditional methods of enforcement, engineering measures and education to alter the social norms of speeding.â Some also see cameras as a way to remove bias from traffic enforcement, as the technology can catch and cite drivers based solely on vehicle speed. The ACLU and other civil liberties groups have opposed this and previous versions of the bill, citing concerns about privacy. The latest version of the bill aims to address those concerns by requiring cities to destroy all photographic evidence âthat does not contain evidence of a speeding violation ... within five business days.â But privacy isnât the only concern: Some residents worry that speed cameras could become a cash cow for cities, though the billâs authors aim to address that with the restrictions on how money collected through the program can be spent. Some law enforcement groups have voiced opposition, arguing in part that speed cameras would make some of their traffic enforcement work obsolete and threaten their jobs. Friedman doesnât buy that argument. âCertainly thereâs a lot for law enforcement to do,â she said. âThereâs no shortage of very important work. ... I see this as something to supplement their efforts, not to replace them.â So what are the billâs chances this year? Friedman worries that âsomebody is opposing this bill and back-channeling opposition,â though sheâs not sure who. âI wish that they would come and talk directly to me, because we have been spending now four years trying to address every legitimate concern thatâs been raised about this bill,â she said. âI think itâs in a really good place, and Iâm hoping that this is the year.â Passage of the bill would be the first step. Itâs when citations start dropping that weâd see results from this sort of program â meaning drivers are slowing down, which would make streets safer for everyone. Maybe youâre reading this and are worried about being ticketed, should the bill pass. Thereâs a simple solution to avoid that: Slow down. âThis is not a speed trap,â Kevitt said, adding: âSigns are up. You know you are entering ... a school zone, where itâs going to fairly ticket you if youâre not traveling at safe speeds. And if youâre traveling at safe speeds, youâre fine. It causes that behavior modification, which is all that weâre trying to do.â And now, hereâs whatâs happening across California. Note: Some of the sites we link to may limit the number of stories you can access without subscribing. L.A. STORIES Gloria Molina has a lot of firsts in her political legacy: the first Latina Assembly member in California, the first Latina on the Los Angeles City Council, the first Latina on the L.A. County Board of Supervisors. Molina, 74, died Sunday night after a three-year battle with cancer. [Los Angeles Times]( [Gloria Molina poses for a portrait in sunlight, smiling. The LA City Hall is in the backgroung. ]
Gloria Molina in 2014, when she was on the City Council. (Barbara Davidson / Los Angeles Times) Can you imagine L.A. without the expertise and unmatched hustle of its landscapers? My colleague Julissa James has a photo-rich ode to the vital workforce, writing: âTheir bodies of work are all around â we are inside a live group exhibition created and cared for by workers who walk among us.â [Los Angeles Times]( POLITICS AND GOVERNMENT With Californiaâs population falling as its stock of new housing rises, when will we see homes become more affordable? Analysts say itâs complicated and advise hopeful homeowners against holding their breath. [CalMatters]( Oakland teachersâ seven-day strike ended Monday after their union reached a tentative agreement with the school district. The deal secures major pay raises for teachers, along with improved investments in classrooms. [KQED]( CRIME, COURTS AND POLICING âSeaWorldâs greed and arrogance are offensive, and [San Diego] will hold it accountable.â So said City Atty. Mara Elliott, announcing the cityâs intention to sue the theme park to recoup almost $10 million in back rent officials say was not paid during the pandemic. [San Diego Union-Tribune]( Support our journalism [Subscribe to the Los Angeles Times.]( HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT If you have young children or grandchildren, you might want to check this list. Dangerous levels of lead have been found in the drinking water of nearly 1,700 licensed child-care centers in California, according to data procured by the nonprofit Environmental Working Group. [Sacramento Bee]( An environmental group is suing the state to block oil drilling at 15 recently approved wells off the coast of Long Beach. The Center for Biological Diversity argues that the California Geologic Energy Management Division failed to facilitate public comment and based the approvals on outdated environmental reviews. [Long Beach Post]( CALIFORNIA CULTURE Some say California is a state of mind â and that mindset is alive and well on the other side of the world. In China, digital nomads have been flocking to Dali, a city in the southwestern part of the country. Its inviting climate and anything-goes reputation have led some to rebrand it âDalifornia.â But will it last? [Los Angeles Times]( [Graffiti in Dali, China.]
Graffiti in Dali, China. (John Wang) Californiaâs winter storms brought strong erosion around Sierra Nevada rivers â and now itâs bringing out the gold diggers. âFlood goldâ â fine flakes of the precious metal kicked up with all that churning water â has beckoned modern-day prospectors back to some of the stateâs historic Gold Rush sites. [Mercury News]( Free online games Get our free daily crossword puzzle, sudoku, word search and arcade games in our new game center at [latimes.com/games](. AND FINALLY Todayâs California landmark is from Michelle Barth of Waikoloa, Hawaii: the scenic coastline near Camp Pendleton. [A flock of seagulls hang out on the coastline with a nuclear power plant in the distance.]
Seagulls hang out near Camp Pendleton, with the San Onofre Nuclear Power Plant visible in the distance. (Michelle Barth) Michelle writes: I love the view up the coast from Pendleton area lookout. I grew up in Palos Verdes and still visit Cali often. What are Californiaâs essential landmarks? [Fill out this form to send us your photos of a special spot in California]( â natural or human-made. Tell us why itâs interesting and what makes it a symbol of life in the Golden State. Please be sure to include only photos taken directly by you. Your submission could be featured in a future edition of the newsletter. Please let us know what we can do to make this newsletter more useful to you. Send comments to essentialcalifornia@latimes.com. ADVERTISEMENT
Thank you for reading the Los Angeles Times
Essential California newsletter.
Invite your friends, relatives, coworkers to sign up [here](.
Not a subscriber? Get unlimited digital access to latimes.com. [Subscribe here](.
[Los Angeles Times]
Copyright © 2023, Los Angeles Times
2300 E. Imperial Highway, El Segundo, California, 90245
[1-800-LA-TIMES](tel:1-800-LA-TIMES) | [latimes.com]( *Advertisers have no control over editorial decisions or content. If you're interested in placing an ad or classified, get in touch [here](. We'd love your feedback on this newsletter. Please send your thoughts and suggestions [here](mailto:newsletters@latimes.com). You received this email because you signed up for newsletters from The Los Angeles Times.
[Manage marketing email preferences]( · [Manage newsletter subscriptions or unsubscribe]( · [Terms of service]( · [Privacy policy]( · [Do Not Sell My Personal Information]( · [CA Notice of Collection]( FOLLOW US [Divider](#) [Facebook]( [2-tw.png]( [Instagram]( [YouTube](