[Are You A Top Down Or Bottom Up Investor?](
By Sven Carlin on April 10, 2017
- It’s best to use a bottom up and not a top down approach to investing if you want to lower your risk and increase your returns.
- A value investor doesn’t like risk and invests with a huge margin of safety, is patient, happy to stay in cash if there are no bargains, constantly looks at balance sheets, and buys the present. Positive future developments in a business are just a bonus.
Introduction
We’ve covered more than half of Seth Klarman’s book Margin of Safety: Risk-Averse Value Investing Strategies for the Thoughtful Investor. I’ve received amazing feedback on the series and hope you will be satisfied with the summary and comment on the second half of the book. You can read the previous articles on the topic [here](.
Today we’ll focus on Chapter 7, At the Root of a Value-Investment Philosophy, where Klarman discusses the psychology necessary to reach extraordinary investment returns and elaborates on the necessary skillset.
The three central elements discussed are a bottom up strategy to finding undervalued investments, being absolute and not relative performance oriented, and that the focus should be on what can possibly go wrong (risk), more than on what could go right (return).
Top Down Investing Strategy
Top down investing starts by looking at the future and predicting what will happen. This is how the majority of market participants approach investing. Two simple examples are Tesla (NASDAQ: [TSLA]( and Snapchat (NYSE: [SNAP](. Both companies are hemorrhaging money every month, but investors are focused on their potential. TSLA could become the largest vehicle manufacturer in the world, while if SNAP continues to grow like it has in the last two years, it will eventually be larger than Facebook (NASDAQ: [FB](.
Nobody has a crystal ball to see what will happen in the future, and therefore such a future oriented strategy is vulnerable to error at every step. For example, we can’t know—and not even Elon Musk knows—what the production cost of the Model 3 in 2018 will be because there are so many factors that influence production costs. One factor is the price of lithium, an essential component of the battery pack. The price of lithium has doubled in the last 4 years while mass electric car production hasn’t even started yet.
Figure 1: As demand for lithium increases so will its price, consequently increasing production costs. Source: [Metalary](.
It’s impossible to know whether TSLA will be able to get enough Lithium to produce 500,000 cars while GM, Mercedes, Hyundai, and many other companies will also want the material as they are also producing electric vehicles. On the other hand, if a recession comes along, a $40k electric car could soon turn from a cool thing to an unnecessary luxury.
Figure 2: Elon Musk’s predicted sales numbers are huge. Source: [Bloomberg](.
I’m not saying TSLA will miss their forecasts, I’m just saying that it’s impossible to know what will happen. The impossibility of knowing what will happen in the future increases the investing risks as a recession or higher lithium prices would be extremely detrimental to TSLA’s success story.
Such a future oriented approach to investing is the opposite of what a value investor does as there is no margin of safety, your investing is based on a trend, concept or theme and it is impossible to know how much of the positive expectations are already included in the price of a stock as there is no way to assess the fundamental value of it. Going back to TSLA’s example, nobody can know whether TSLA will sell 500,000 cars in 2018, nor at what margin, nor what the financial result will be. TSLA could get to $5 billion in profits if the net profit on every car sold is $10,000, or it could get to $5 billion in losses if there is a similar loss on every sold car. Again, it’s impossible to analyze the fundamentals of a company with such uncertain outcomes.
[Misunderstood Option Strategy Earns Novice Trader $41 Million In Only 3 Years](
Find out how you can use it to immediately generate substantial income when the market opens on Monday... even if you're starting with limited funds.
It's safe, reliable, and can be duplicated over and over again to generate income you can use right now if you want. Or you can let it snowball into even more.
[Click Here To Learn This Strategy](
[Easy-to-use Signal System Picks Stocks With Uncanny Accuracy](
Here are several stocks our system said to buy:
WNC shot up 288% after system said BUY
VCI shot up 233% after system said BUY
ETM shot up 953% after system said BUY
Plus ... get over $398 worth of valuable books, videos, and reports just for trying this system risk-free for the next 30 days!
[Click Here To Try It Risk-Free For The Next 30 Days!](
Bottom Up Investing Strategy
A bottom up approach to investing doesn’t look at what will happen and therefore it’s much easier to apply. The focus lies on fundamental analysis, or to go to the extreme and back to Graham and Dodd, you want to ask the question of what the business is worth dead, thus if it goes into liquidation. Such an approach would quickly show that TSLA is not an investment for the risk averse investor as its book value is $29.12, or just one tenth of its stock price.
However, if TSLA’s price were $20, then the risk averse investor would buy it. If the projections don’t work out and the company goes into liquidation, you can expect to get at least your money back. If the projections materialize, then the upside is unlimited. TSLA at $20 would be a perfect example of a low risk, high return investment. Unfortunately, TSLA isn’t trading at $20, but there are many companies that are trading below their book values.
A characteristic of the value investor is that they constantly analyze security by security by using the fundamental bottom up approach and invest only when they find an investment with low risk and a margin of safety, i.e. “whatever happens I don’t lose money,” and high potential returns.
If there are no investments available that meet the required criteria, a value investor simply stays in cash and waits for the market to crash and create new investment opportunities. Sitting and doing nothing while the market is euphoric is perhaps the most difficult characteristic for an investor to achieve.
When a bargain investment is found, the only thing to do is to buy and wait. So, on top of constantly digging through balance sheets and annual reports and not investing all the time, you also have to be patient and wait for the market to acknowledge the value you have found. From personal experience, I can tell you that this waiting period can last a few years.
An Example Of A Bottom Up Strategy
Just as an example of investing in what there is and not in what there might be is Bank of America Corporation (NYSE: [BAC](. Its stock price is $23.17 while its book value per share is $24.13. It has taken the stock 8 years to trade close to its book value again.
Figure 3: BAC’s stock price has finally reached its book value. Source: [Nasdaq](.
What’s important for the value investor using a bottom up strategy is that sooner or later the market always acknowledges value. This makes value investments extremely low risk.
If something would have happened to BAC that would have lowered its book value, then a value investor would look at the numbers and change his mind on the company if necessary. A value investor doesn’t let his emotions make his investment decisions, but mere facts. This describes another characteristic of value investors, the ability to change one’s mind and accept the losses by selling a stock that isn’t what it used to be.
Conclusion
In the current environment, the majority are focused on relative performance and are plowing money into stocks without too much care about valuations on the basis that stocks will continue to do well. Stocks might continue to do well for a certain amount of time, but will eventually enter into a bear market. A lot of positives are currently priced into stocks so there are extremely high probabilities for error.
It’s up to you to choose whether you want to follow the market or look at your portfolio from a value perspective in order to lower risks and maximize returns. It’s extremely hard to find bargains in this market by using a bottom up strategy, but it is possible. However, such an investing strategy will be opposite to the market’s sentiment and will probably lead to short term underperformance if the market continues to rally.
But if investors come to their senses and start looking for protection in value, your returns are guaranteed. You just have to be patient for the market to recognize value investments but always beware of value traps that are materializing in the oil and retail sector where structural trends disable a meaningful upside.
Keep reading Investiv Daily as we’ll continue to analyze Klarman’s investing masterpiece through a contemporary lens. The next topics we’ll be discussing are absolute vs. relative performance and how to approach risk.
[No Comments »]( | Filed under: [Investing Strategy]( [Investiv Daily]( [Seth Klarman]( | Tags: No Tags
---------------------------------------------------------------
If you are having trouble reading this email, you may [view the online version](
This email was sent to {EMAIL} by Investiv, LLC
3400 North Ashton Blvd. | Suite 170 | Lehi | UT | 84043
[Forward to a friend]( | [Unsubscribe](
Disclaimers
Investing is Inherently Risky
There are risks inherent in all investments, which may make such investments unsuitable for certain persons. These include, for example, economic, political, currency exchange, rate fluctuations, and limited availability of information on international securities. You may lose all of your money trading and investing. Do NOT enter any trade without fully understanding the worst-case scenarios of that trade. And do NOT trade with money you cannot afford to lose. Past performance of an investment is not necessarily indicative of its future results. No assurance can be given that any implied recommendation will be profitable or will not be subject to losses.
Hypothetical Results Are Reported
Results and examples used in the Companyâs advertisements, books, videos, websites, and other mediaâincluding on the Site and the Networkâare, in some cases, based on hypothetical (simulated) trades. Plainly speaking, these trades were not actually executed. Hypothetical performance results have certain limitations. Unlike an actual performance record, hypothetical results do not represent actual trading. Also, since the trades have not been executed, the hypothetical results may have under-or-over compensation for the impact, if any, of certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity. Hypothetical trading programs generally are also subject to the fact that they are designed with the benefit of hindsight. Hypothetical results also do not account for commissions or slippage.
The Companyâs simulations assume purchase and sale prices believed to be attainable. Yet traders are going to be getting into trades at different times and using various exit approaches, which may result in different pricing and outcomes. You may or may not receive the best available price on the purchase or the sale of a position in actual trading.
Information provided by the Company is not investment advice. The Company is not a registered investment adviser, stock broker, or brokerage. You agree that the Company does not represent, warrant, or take responsibility that any account will or is likely to achieve profit or losses similar to those shown. Examples published by the Company are selected for illustrative purposes only. They are not typical and do not represent the typical results of all stocks within the Companyâs software or its individual scans and searches. No independent party has audited any hypothetical performance contained at this Web site, nor has any independent party undertaken to confirm that they reflect the trading method under the assumptions or conditions specified.
Offers Disinterested Commentary and Analysis
The Company does not receive any form of payment or other compensation for publishing information, news, research, or any other material concerning specific securities on the Network that is intended to affect or influence the value of securities. The Company, and its personnel, do not engage in front-running of recommendations and do not trade against oneâs own recommendations.
The Company and its management may benefit from an increase or decrease in the share prices of the profiled companies, and/or may have other actual or potential conflicts of interest. If a particular security featured in a newsletter publication is concurrently owned by the Company in its corporate brokerage account, or in any of the individual accounts of the Companyâs principals or analysts / writers, that fact will be disclosed. The Company, its principals, analysts and writers may choose to purchase a security or derivative featured in one of its newsletter publications, but typically will wait three (3) trading days from the date of publication before initiating said purchase.
[Disclaimers, Terms & Conditions]( | [Privacy Policy](
Copyright 2017