The "TikTok for News" built by Instagram's co-founders shuts down [Read Online]( Why Artifact failed ð The "TikTok for News" built by Instagram's co-founders shuts down [Nicolás Cerdeira]( [fb]( [tw]( [in]( [email](mailto:?subject=Post%20from%20Failory&body=Why%20Artifact%20failed%20%F0%9F%92%80%3A%20The%20%22TikTok%20for%20News%22%20built%20by%20Instagram%27s%20co-founders%20shuts%20down%0A%0Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fnewsletter.failory.com%2Fp%2Fwhy-artifact-failed) Hey â Itâs Nico. Tomorrow is the last day to fill out [Failoryâs 2024 reader survey](. If you havenât done it yet, please take 3 minutes to do it. It helps me a lot! Between the people who complete it, Iâll be giving away 10 copies of my PMF eBook, 5 consultancy calls, and 3 licenses of my Pre-Sell to Validate course. [Hereâs the link to the survey.]( Hereâs what I got today: - The reasons why the âTikTok for newsâ startup, Artifact, failed ð - An explanation of how to convey Founder-Product Fit ð¥ - A question about a Twitter controversy around validating ideas â Presented by Artisan The Age of AI Employees Is Upon Us: [Meet Artisans]( [Meet Ava](, your new AI employee. Ava is an SDR with 10x the skills of a human appointment setter, but for 4% of the cost. Artisans are highly advanced digital workers, and Ava is the first one - she: - Forms your ICP and prospects from a database of 270M+ contacts - Warm up email addresses and sends 1000s of hyper-personalized cold outreach emails - Autonomously schedule meetings in your calendar [Hire Ava]( and 10x your leads, meetings & deals. This Week In Startups ð Resources [A guide by Hustle Fund]( to help first-time founders raise funding. [The story of a $475k/year Gen AI startup]( told by its CEO. [Ryan Hoover shares]( why heâs excited about profit-sharing startups. [How to increase ACV]( by asking customers about their willingness to pay. [How to run a great demo]( when youâre not a salesperson. ð° News Logistics startup[Flexport raises $260M]( from Shopify. Fintech startup [Brex lays off 20% of employees](. AI voice cloning startup [ElevenLabs raises $80M]( and achieves unicorn status. Identity protection startup [Silverfort raises $116M](. Indonesian unicorn [Xendit cuts 200+ jobs](. ð® Cool Stuff Marc Lou was [awarded Product Huntâs Maker of the Year](. Pieter Levels has open-sourced [his $120k/mo investment portfolio](. Alexander Belogubov [built 20+ products]( â most failed. Fail(St)ory Instagramâs Founders Failed to Build the TikTok for News In [last weekâs newsletter](, I shared that Artifact, the news AI startup from Instagramâs co-founders, was shutting down. It was fresh news, so there werenât many details â now we have some more data into what went wrong with the startup. What Was Artifact: - Artifact was initially said to be the âTikTok for news.â - It was an app that offered a blend of news reading, curation, and discovery, leveraging AI. - It was created by Kevin Systrom and Mike Krieger, who co-founded Instagram. - It was their first public venture since they left Meta in 2018, to which they sold Instagram for $1B in 2012. - It was self-funded by Kevin and Mike. A team of 8 were working on the project. Backstory: The app went through lots of changes over its short lifespan. - Artifact launched in February 2023 â 100,00 users downloaded the app that month. - The first features they launched were all focused on consuming news, like the ability to make comments, follow writers, and summarize the news using AI. - But over time, they started to dilute their sharp focus. - First, they launched the [ability to post links]( (no longer only news), resembling Pinterest. - Then they launched the [ability to post text content](, now looking more similar to Twitter/X. - In October, they [launched the option to share places](, turning Artifact into a recommendation engine. - App downloads and usage started to decline over the months. In October 2023, they only had 12,000 new installs. - On January 12, Kevin Systrom announced they were shutting down. Why Artifact Failed: [In a post-mortem article](, Kevin identified market size as the reason why they were stopping working on the project. âWe have built something that a core group of users love, but we have concluded that the market opportunity isnât big enough to warrant continued investment in this way.â With [various startups in the space being unicorns](, itâs hard to take this as the only reason for Artifactâs failure. Here are 5 things I think were equally (or more) important: - Lack of demand: [According to app intelligence provider Appfigures](, Artifact has had 444,000 downloads since February 2023. Most of them happened during the launch. After that, monthly downloads declined abruptly. From the outside, the app appeared to have traction, with news having plenty of reads and comments. There probably was a core group of users, but not significantly large. - Struggle to expand: They failed to catch a more mainstream audience and gain an international following. US accounted for 44% of their downloads, but no other country had more than a 4% share. - Competition: The news space is super competitive. SmartNews is one of the leaders (with a $2B valuation) â during Artifactâs lifespan, they got 2M downloads (5 times what Artifact did). Thereâs also Google News and Apple News, not to mention the hundreds of already-known news outlets. - Lack of focus: It seems like Artifact dilute its focus on delivering a better news reading experience using AI by launching features aimed to steal users from bigger players like Twitter and Pinterest. It wasnât clear what they wanted to be. - Funding: Since the startup was self-funded, chances are Kevin and Mike preferred to stop losing their funds earlier than later and decided not to raise external funding. Lessons: - Itâs hard to build a B2C app, particularly in competitive spaces like news. Users expect a lot, as there already are incredible products. - Itâs important to balance your businessâ original purpose with the need to evolve. You need to adapt without losing core value propositions. - âMaking the tough call earlier is better for everyone involved,â says Mike in the post-mortem post. Instead of raising funds to keep trying to grow Artifact (which they could have easily done due to their background), they decided to put an end to the project early on â sometimes thatâs better. Go Deeper: - [Artifactâs post-mortem article]( by Kevin Systrom. - [Appfiguresâs analysis]( of Artifactâs performance in the App Store and Google Play. Hot Take Founder-Product Fit Is A MUST VCs only look at 6% of the deals theyâre presented with and end up investing in less than 1%. Slava Heretz is the founder of [Camlann](, an AI-powered video game distribution and release operating system. To date, he has raised $830K from several VCs. This week, [he wrote a guest post for Failory]( explaining whatâs the thing that increases x10 your chances of raising funds. What: - The âTeamâ slide is frequently left behind by founders building their pitch decks. - This slide conveys why you and your co-founders are the best people to be running this startup. - In other words, it shows Founder-Product Fit. How: As a first step, get with your co-founders and ask yourself the following 3 questions: - Why did you pick you for this startup, and why did you pick your co-founders? - What are the greatest strengths that you and your co-founders bring to the table? - What would be completely missing and impossible to do without you or them? This Team slide from [Slidebeanâs pitch deck]( is a good one: Each of these founders alone wouldnât make a compelling slide by themselves, but together, theyâre exactly the pieces needed to show potential for this startup. Hint: Two more tips. - Donât assume something is not relevant. All your experiences define you. - Don't be afraid to tell stories. Investors like understanding the behind of a startup. Go Deeper: Read [Slavaâs article on Founder Product Fit](. Question Can Landing Pages + Ads Validate an Idea? On Tuesday, Andrea Bosoni [tweeted a hot take](: âStop telling people to create a landing page and run ads to it to validate their idea. In 99% of cases they will simply waste money and get zero conversions.â Other founders soon joined the conversation and shared varied points of view. The Argument: - Unless itâs an impulse purchase, people need more than one touchpoint (one ad) before theyâre ready to buy. - Andrea knows a founder who almost quit after getting zero sales doing this test and is now at $1M ARR. - Itâs [statistically irrelevant](. $100-$200 spent on ads at $1-$3/click means nothing. Other POVs: - [This founder]( believes itâs still a great strategy to test if people are willing to pay for your product. - [A founder shares an alternative](: use ads to take users to blog posts explaining how to solve a problem with your product rather than to a landing page. - This startup was [validated using Google Ads]( and is now making $Ms (we did [an interview with them](). Your Turn Is it possible to validate a startup idea using a landing page + ads? [â
Yes, Iâve done it](
[ð Yes, but I havenât done it](
[â No, itâs meaningless]( Iâll be sharing the results. Iâm interested in reading your justifications as well. Refer Failory, Get Rewards Share Failory Chances are you have some more friends who would enjoy Failory as much as you do. Share Failory with these friends and cash in on premium resources and swag. You currently have 0 referrals, only 1 away from receiving the 2024 Startup Failure Report. [Share Failory â]( Or copy and paste this link to others: Help Me Improve Failory How Was Today's Newsletter? If this issue was a startup, how would you rate it? [ð Launches to the moon!](
[ð¤ Room for a pivot](
[ð Crashes and burns]( That's all of this week. Cheers, Nico Update your email preferences or unsubscribe [here]( © 2024 Failory 1309 Coffeen Avenue
Ste 1200, Sheridan, Wyoming 82801, United States of America [[beehiiv logo]Powered by beehiiv](