News from Edge
To arrive at the edge of the world's knowledge, seek out the most complex and sophisticated minds, put them in a room together, and have them ask each other the questions they are asking themselves.
September 4, 2019
THE THIRD CULTURE
[Emergences](
A Talk By W. Daniel Hillis
My perspective is closest to [George Dyson's](. I liked his introducing himself as being interested in intelligence in the wild. I will copy George in that. That is what Iâm interested in, too, but itâs with a perspective that makes it all in the wild. My interest in AI comes from a broader interest in a much more interesting question to which I have no answers (and can barely articulate the question): How do lots of simple things interacting emerge into something more complicated? Then how does that create the next system out of which that happens, and so on?
Consider the phenomenon, for instance, of chemicals organizing themselves into life, or single-cell organisms organizing themselves into multi-cellular organisms, or individual people organizing themselves into a society with language and things like thatâI suspect that thereâs more of that organization to happen. The AI that Iâm interested in is a higher level of that and, like George, I suspect that not only will it happen, but it probably already is happening, and weâre going to have a lot of trouble perceiving it as it happens. We have trouble perceiving it because of this notion, which [Ian McEwan]( so beautifully described, of the Golem being such a compelling idea that we get distracted by it, and we imagine it to be like that. That blinds us to being able to see it as it really is emerging. Not that I think such things are impossible, but I donât think those are going to be the first to emerge.
There's a pattern in all of those emergences, which is that they start out as analog systems of interaction, and then somehowâchemicals have chains of circular pathways that metabolize stuff from the outside world and turn into circular pathways that are metabolizingâwhat always happens going up to the next level is those analog systems invent a digital system, like DNA, where they start to abstract out the information processing. So, they put the information processing in a separate system of its own. From then on, the interesting story becomes the story in the information processing. The complexity happens more in the information processing system. That certainly happens again with multi-cellular organisms. The information processing system is neurons, and they eventually go from just a bunch of cells to having this special information processing system, and thatâs where the action is in the brains and behavior. It drags along and makes much more complicated bodies much more interesting once you have behavior.
W. DANIEL HILLIS is an inventor, entrepreneur, and computer scientist, Judge Widney Professor of Engineering and Medicine at USC, and author of The Pattern on the Stone: The Simple Ideas That Make Computers Work.
[ [Continue...]( ]
Edge Foundation, Inc. is a nonprofit private operating foundation under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
[EDGE.ORG](
John Brockman, Editor and Publisher; Russell Weinberger, Associate Publisher; Nina Stegeman, Associate Editor
Copyright (c) 2019 by Edge Foundation, Inc., 260 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10001. All Rights Reserved.
---------------------------------------------------------------
Visit [edge.org]( "Fabulous" âThe New York Times ⢠"Thrilling" âFrankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung ⢠"Wonderful" âThe Wall Street Journal ⢠"Fantastically Stimulating" âBBC Radio 4 ⢠"Astounding" âThe Boston Globe ⢠"Splendidly enlightened" âThe Independent ⢠"Audacious" âLa Vanguardia ⢠"Brilliant" âThe Sunday Times ⢠"Enthralling" âThe Daily Mail ⢠"Exhilarating" âThe Evening Standard ⢠"Stunning" âNew Scientist ⢠"Enjoyable" âSalon ⢠"Provocative" âLa Stampa ⢠"Marvelous" âProspect ⢠"Awesome" âWired ⢠"The brightest minds in the known universe" âVanity Fair ⢠"A lavish cerebral feast" âThe Atlantic ⢠"An intellectual treasure trove" âSan Francisco Chronicle ⢠"The world's smartest website" âThe Guardian
---------------------------------------------------------------
Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can [update your preferences]( or [unsubscribe from this list](