“Revolution Within the Form”

The Original Constitution Is Dead Were you forwarded this email? [Sign-up to The Daily Reckoning here.]( [Unsubscribe]( [Daily Reckoning] “Revolution Within the Form” - Are all men created equal?… - The Constitution has undergone a revolution within the form… - France was a beacon of civilization before the revolution… Recommended Link [Special offer from Jim Rickards]( [Read more here...]( Last month Jim Rickards went live to share details on a massive cross-borders conflict that’s quietly taking place. You can still join Jim with his brand-new Charter Membership today! [Click Here To Get The Details]( Annapolis, Maryland July 15, 2021 [Brian Maher]Dear Reader, Yesterday we maintained that the American Revolution was a “revolution not made but prevented.” Less a revolution than an anti-revolution… we might properly label the thing a revolt. A child may revolt against parental sovereignty. But is he a revolutionary? Here was the American colonists’ animating purpose: To retake preexisting rights the crown had muscled away from them. They were not out to create the world anew. They had no care to carve out an “indispensable nation,” or “shining city on the hill.” No ideological stars dazzled them, no ideological sugar plums waltzed within their skulls. They were grounded in the good American earth. Historian Clinton Rossiter: However radical the principles of the Revolution may have seemed to the rest of the world, in the minds of the colonists they were thoroughly preservative and respectful of the past… The political theory of the American Revolution, in contrast to that of the French Revolution, was not a theory designed to make the world over. Adds historian and political theorist Russell Kirk: For novel abstract theories of human nature and society, most of the men who subscribed to the Declaration and the Constitution had no relish. All Men Are Created Equal Did not Mr. Tom Jefferson claim that all men are created equal? He did, yes. Yet as Kirk noted: Jefferson, not unaware of his own remarkable talents, scarcely could have thought that every man… could become the intellectual peer of Thomas Jefferson… There were some demagogues in the Continental Congress, but Jefferson was not of their number, and the large majority of the Declaration’s signers were realists with broad experience of the world, not given to sentimental or false slogans... The men of the Continental Congress... did not take Jefferson’s equality clause as an affirmation of literal equality in body and mind. (In one early draft of the Declaration, the phrase is “equal & independent”; in another rough draft, “& independent” is crossed out… they did not look upon the average American, let alone the average man everywhere, as their literal equals. They did subscribe to two venerable concepts of human equality: equality before the law, and equality in the judgment of God. To this day scholars flog their brains to decode Jefferson’s riddle. But after America’s “Second Founding” -- following the Civil War and the 14th Amendment -- the Declaration and the Constitution underwent a transformation. They began to give off ideological glows previously undetected. That is, they began to radiate the crusading ideology of egalitarianism previously undetected. As Mr. Lincoln had declared at Gettysburg: The American nation “shall have a new birth of freedom.” Recommended Link [#1 Futurist Says: Get Ready for This Global “Reboot”]( George Gilder has a shocking message for anybody with money in the bank… with a job that pays in dollars… or who carries a smartphone in their pocket. “Brace yourself,” he says, “for the coming $16.8 trillion global ‘reboot’ ahead.” It could radically transform the way just about every major corporation does business. It could change the way you get paid, save and invest for retirement. And, says George, it could make you exceedingly rich... [Click Here To See Why]( The New Freedom The new birth of freedom demanded the death of the old freedom. It required an energetic, centralizing government... busy with the business of equality on ever-expanding and heavily contested fronts. The civil rights legislation of the 1960s was perhaps its high moment, its culmination. For good? For ill? Neither? Both? Here we offer no judgment. We merely report the record, as a sportscaster reports the action, or an obituarist reports a death. Yet equality’s reach forever exceeds its grasp. Today the very concept of equality is being shouldered out of the way by “equity.” That is, equality in opportunity is yielding to equality in outcome. Again, for good or ill? We once again reserve judgment. Revolution Within the Form Yet this we maintain with confidence: The United States Constitution has endured what old Aristotle labeled “a revolution within the form.” A revolution within the form? “Old Right” journalist Garet Garrett: Aristotle observed that “People do not easily change, but love their own ancient customs; and it is by small degrees only that one thing takes the place of another; so that the ancient laws will remain, while the power will be in the hands of those who have brought about a revolution in the state.” The Constitution, the original Constitution, throbs with such vitality, such life... it is so alive… it is nearly dead. The outer structure remains, yes. The skeleton, the form, is intact. Yet scalpel your way through to the innards. Cut your way through the outer layers... to the vital organs. You will discover a corpse. The old confederation of sovereign and independent states, mightily jealous of their rights, has yielded to the leviathan central state we enjoy so much today. Every last detail of American life this creature watches, regulates and controls. Where does it locate its authority in the Constitution? Not in the text. The original words remain, yes. Yet their meaning is not what they once were. They have undergone a sort of revolution — a revolution within the form. The Constitution has become an ideological battle axe in the service of an abstraction. Let us now, briefly, direct our attentions to the French Revolution… Recommended Link [Free invite to a LIVE trading session with a millionaire trader]( [Read more here...]( Would you like to trade alongside a master trader this monday at 12 PM EST? If you would, please click the link below to see how to secure your spot. Once you get in… You’ll see her hottest stocks to trade, the exact price point she wants to get in at and she’ll even answer your most pressing trading question practically for FREE. [Click Here To Claim Your Seat]( The Ideological Revolution The French Revolution, in contrast to the American Revolution, sizzled and crackled with ideology. It looked to build society anew — from root to branch, from cellar to attic. It blasted away all existing social and political foundations. God, Himself was chased out of France, deported, banished, exiled. Revolutionists sat “reason” down in the vacated throne. Savagery, barbarism and slaughter on the wholesale followed. Yet how did it come to be? France had become a dazzling star of Europe by the 1700s, attaining fantastic civilizational heights. Explains our co-founder Bill Bonner: By the 18th century, France had become the greatest power in Europe, the richest and most populous country in the western world, and the clear leader in art, science, philosophy, education, cuisine, fashion, architecture...and, of course, viticulture. It had the richest people in the world, the prettiest women, and the best booze. It also had the most enlightened economists - the physiocrats - from whom Adam Smith was boosting some of his best ideas. A poll taken in the early 1780s might have shown the French to be extremely optimistic and confident. And why shouldn't they be? The last major financial crisis - caused by John Law's Mississippi Bubble - blew up over 60 years before. And had the world ever seen anything approaching the splendor of Versailles? Then came the revolution: But in 1789, Paris mobs came to the crossroads of history and veered left. They replaced an absolute monarch who had very limited power, with a people's republic restrained neither by common sense nor common decency. Why then did France plunge into revolutionary psychosis in 1789? Does it offer a worrying tale of caution to 21st century America? These questions we tackle tomorrow… Regards, [Brian Maher] Brian Maher Managing Editor, The Daily Reckoning Editor’s note: Have you seen Jim Rickards’ [new blockbuster video on the Sixth Domain of War?]( It’s the talk of our office. You’ll see why when you [click here]( to see it. [Jim recently revealed his proprietary secret]( for profiting from a massive, $6.6 trillion daily flow of capital. Jim initially got over 100,000 signups. But a few hundred lucky attendees were able to join him in his brand-new V.I.P. membership. Now Jim’s launching the next step in this project… You can join him with his brand-new Charter Membership by [clicking here.]( We’ve got to warn you though… This membership is only for folks serious about learning how to make money using shocking Jim’s $6.6 trillion discovery. [Click here now for details.]( --------------------------------------------------------------- Thank you for reading The Daily Reckoning! We greatly value your questions and comments. Please send all feedback to [feedback@dailyreckoning.com.](mailto:dr@dailyreckoning.com) [Brian Maher][Brian Maher]( is the Daily Reckoning's Managing Editor. Before signing on to Agora Financial, he was an independent researcher and writer who covered economics, politics and international affairs. His work has appeared in the Asia Times and other news outlets around the world. He holds a Master's degree in Defense & Strategic Studies. Add feedback@dailyreckoning.com to your address book: [Whitelist us]( Additional Articles & Commentary: [Daily Reckoning Website]( Join the conversation! Follow us on social media: [Facebook]( [LinkedIn]( [Twitter]( [RSS Feed]( [YouTube]( The Daily Reckoning is committed to protecting and respecting your privacy. We do not rent or share your email address. By submitting your email address, you consent to Paradigm Press delivering daily email issues and advertisements. To end your Daily Reckoning e-mail subscription and associated external offers sent from The Daily Reckoning, feel free to [unsubscribe here.]( Please read our [Privacy Statement](. For any further comments or concerns please email us at feedback@dailyreckoning.com. If you are having trouble receiving your Daily Reckoning subscription, you can ensure its arrival in your mailbox [by whitelisting The Daily Reckoning.]( [Paradigm Press]© 2021 Paradigm Press, LLC. 808 Saint Paul Street, Baltimore MD 21202. Although our employees may answer your general customer service questions, they are not licensed under securities laws to address your particular investment situation. No communication by our employees to you should be deemed as personalized financial advice. We expressly forbid our writers from having a financial interest in any security they personally recommend to our readers. All of our employees and agents must wait 24 hours after on-line publication or 72 hours after the mailing of a printed-only publication prior to following an initial recommendation. Any investments recommended in this letter should be made only after consulting with your investment advisor and only after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company. Email Reference ID: 470DRED01