The “Dead Money” Economy

Lots of Bucks, Little Bang Were you forwarded this email? [Sign-up to The Daily Reckoning here.]( [Unsubscribe]( [Daily Reckoning] The “Dead Money” Economy - The broad money supply has multiplied 12 times since 1981, but the velocity of money has collapsed… - “Ours is a Dead Money Economy”… - A financial system teetering on the brink… Recommended Link [Write Down This Ticker Symbol…]( There’s a new way to make money in cryptos. And top crypto expert Teeka Tiwari says it could mint millionaires in the months ahead. It’s not Bitcoin… or any other crypto asset you’ve likely heard of. It’s a special new subsector of crypto Teeka calls, “Tech Royalties.” And learn how to get in on the ground floor… [See The Replay Of Teeka’s First-ever “Tech Royalty” Summit]( San Francisco, California March 20, 2021 Editor’s note: The money supply has exploded while the velocity of money, the rate at which it changes hands, has collapsed. Today, Charles Hugh Smith argues that ours is a “dead money” economy. [Charles Hugh Smith] Dear Reader, While the broad measure of the money supply in the U.S., M2, has gone up 12-fold since the start of 1981, the velocity of money — how many times it changes hands over a period of time — has collapsed. What does this tell us about the U.S. economy and what lies ahead? The Federal Reserve's FRED database provides a definition of M2 that's a good starting place. Note that the Fed refers to money stock, where the word stock refers to the sum total of money in the system, as in "the store is fully stocked with merchandise." They're not referring to the stock market, but to all the money that's in the "store" of our financial system: cash, money in checking accounts and money market funds, etc. Here's the definition of M2: Beginning May 2020, M2 consists of M1 plus (1) small-denomination time deposits (time deposits in amounts of less than $100,000) less IRA and Keogh balances at depository institutions; and (2) balances in retail MMFs (money market funds) less IRA and Keogh balances at MMFs. Put somewhat more directly, M2 is all the money in the financial system which people can spend. It doesn't include the money in individual retirement accounts because that has been set aside for the long-term and is not available (except in cases of early withdrawal) to spend. Velocity Here's the definition of the velocity of money: The velocity of money is the frequency at which one unit of currency is used to purchase domestically produced goods and services within a given time period. In other words, it is the number of times one dollar is spent to buy goods and services per unit of time. If the velocity of money is increasing, then more transactions are occurring between individuals in an economy. A decreasing velocity might indicate fewer consumption transactions are taking place. You might have seen one of the illustrative tales circulating around the web about the one $10 bill that ends up paying a half-dozen debts as it circulates through the town: the grocer pays a debt owed the baker who uses the $10 to pay a debt to the florist and so on. This is an example of a high velocity of money: the $10 bill changes hands many times in the space of a few hours, funding transactions that all lead back to the exchange of a good or service. There's one part of the definition that is often overlooked: the velocity of money only tracks domestically produced goods and services, so all the transactions that end up in a container of goods from China being unloaded in Long Beach aren't counted. Recommended Link [How did a farmer grow his accounts up to $1.4M through trading???]( [Read more here...]( I don’t think ANYONE expected this man to create the trading breakthrough of the past 25 years... But, the truth is… He grew his accounts up to an unbelievable $1.4 million after he started trading this novel strategy. And once you watch this short 2-minute video… You’ll see what this farmer has agreed to do for you. [Click Here Now]( Not Much Bang for the Doubling of Bucks We’ve seen an unprecedented expansion of the stock of money and an equally unprecedented collapse of money velocity. In short, while America's GDP (gross domestic product) has gone up 6.5-fold since the start of the financialization-globalization boom in 1981, the stock of money has risen 12-fold. This is striking: money stock basically doubled from 2009 (the brief Global Financial Crisis recession) to last February, before the pandemic had any impact on the economy. In other words, setting aside the extraordinary vertical expansion of money stock in the past year, the U.S. economy's stock of money doubled in a bit over a decade, just to keep GDP ("growth") at an anemic, barely-above-flatline rate of expansion. Put another way, there wasn't much bang for doubling the supply of bucks. Meanwhile, the velocity of money has absolutely tanked. In the era of widespread prosperity in the 1960s and 1970s, the velocity of money ratio remained in a band between 1.7 and 1.8. It moved up toward 2 in the inflationary late ‘70s, as it made sense to trade cash that was losing value for goods and services before it lost even more purchasing power. Velocity returned to this range in the 1980s boom, and then rocketed to postwar highs at 2.2 in the Internet boom of the 1990s. Since that top in 1997, money velocity has been in a secular decline. The Dead Money Economy As every Fed-inflated financial bubble pops, money velocity takes another leg down. Even before the pandemic, it was in a steady free-fall even as the supply of money steadily rocketed higher. So what do we make of this stunning expansion of money and equally stunning collapse of money velocity? Ours is a Dead Money Economy. New money is created in the trillions of dollars, but it is either shipped overseas to exporters selling goods to Americans or it's being stashed somewhere rather than being exchanged for domestically produced goods and services. In other words, our financial system is pushing on a string: it keeps creating trillions in new money which is either stashed away or sent overseas, having been spent on imported goods. This is the acme of a Dead Money Economy. Recommended Link [Billionaire: This Ticker Is “Like Investing in Google Early”]( [Read more here...]( There’s a mad rush right now into this one ticker symbol… Because experts are projecting gains as high as 1,530% by the end of this year. Famous hedge fund manager Paul Tudor Jones poured $183 million into this ticker and said this is similar to “investing in Google early.” To see for yourself why billionaires are betting big on this ticker… [Click Here To Learn More]( The Lesson of MZM Lastly, let's consider the Fed's broadest measure of money, MZM which is inexplicably being discontinued, just as the measure it replaced, M3, was discontinued. (Do we need to keep moving the goalposts on money stock to mask the abject trajectory of our Dead Money Economy?) Here's the Fed's definition of MZM money stock: MZM (money with zero maturity) is the broadest component and consists of the supply of financial assets redeemable at par on demand: notes and coins in circulation, traveler's checks (non-bank issuers), demand deposits, other checkable deposits, savings deposits, and all money market funds. The velocity of MZM helps determine how often financial assets are switching hands within the economy. In other words, if we want a summary of America's financial system, we look at the velocity of MZM money. MZM money stock has skyrocketed right along with M2 money stock — no surprise there. The surprise is that the velocity of MZM money topped out in the inflationary peak of 1981 and has been in a free-fall since the start of the financialization-globalization era began. Not to put too fine a point on it, but this aligns with the secular stagnation of earnings/wages which began in earnest at the same time (1981), and the rising dependence on central bank intervention/stimulus which has reached the extreme absurdity where the U.S. stock and bond markets and its entire financial system now teeter on the edge of collapse if there is even a slight hint that: 1) The Fed won't give more free candy to Wall Street or 2) The Fed has lost control of the Dead Money Economy it has created. If you think a Dead Money Economy is a healthy economy, you might want to cut your intake of Delusionol. Because it isn’t. Regards, Charles Hugh Smith for The Daily Reckoning Editor’s note: A multi-millionaire who used to run his own hedge fund is issuing a live challenge. And this is your invitation to take part. It’s a LIVE event called [“The 5-Days To $500 Challenge.”]( And it takes place this Monday, March 22, at 2 PM Eastern. The goal is simple... He wants to show you exactly how you can make $500 in instant income… starting with as little as $7,500! How? By sharing a [simple income secret so powerful, and so lucrative...]( This controversial multi-millionaire believes he can teach ANYONE how to do it. That’s why he’s issuing this LIVE challenge – open to the public for anyone that wants to learn exactly how this is possible. You can participate right from the comfort of your home. But space is limited and because it’s a LIVE event, there’s no time to waste. Circle your calendar for this coming [Monday, March 22, at 2 PM Eastern.]( [Click here]( now for more details about the challenge and to see if you qualify. --------------------------------------------------------------- Thank you for reading The Daily Reckoning! We greatly value your questions and comments. Please send all feedback to [feedback@dailyreckoning.com.](mailto:dr@dailyreckoning.com) [Charles Hugh Smith][Charles Hugh Smith]( is an American writer and blogger, and serves as the chief writer for the blog "Of Two Minds". Started in 2005, this site has been listed No. 7 in CNBC's top alternative financial sites, and his commentary is featured on a number of sites including Zerohedge.com, The American Conservative, and Peak Prosperity. Add feedback@dailyreckoning.com to your address book: [Whitelist us]( Additional Articles & Commentary: [Daily Reckoning Website]( Join the conversation! Follow us on social media: [Facebook]( [LinkedIn]( [Twitter]( [RSS Feed]( [YouTube]( The Daily Reckoning is committed to protecting and respecting your privacy. We do not rent or share your email address. By submitting your email address, you consent to Paradigm Press delivering daily email issues and advertisements. To end your Daily Reckoning e-mail subscription and associated external offers sent from The Daily Reckoning, feel free to [unsubscribe here.]( Please read our [Privacy Statement](. For any further comments or concerns please email us at [feedback@dailyreckoning.com](mailto:feedbackdailyproof@dailyreckoning.com). If you are having trouble receiving your Daily Reckoning subscription, you can ensure its arrival in your mailbox [by whitelisting The Daily Reckoning.]( [Paradigm Press]© 2021 Paradigm Press, LLC. 808 Saint Paul Street, Baltimore MD 21202. Although our employees may answer your general customer service questions, they are not licensed under securities laws to address your particular investment situation. No communication by our employees to you should be deemed as personalized financial advice. We expressly forbid our writers from having a financial interest in any security they personally recommend to our readers. All of our employees and agents must wait 24 hours after on-line publication or 72 hours after the mailing of a printed-only publication prior to following an initial recommendation. Any investments recommended in this letter should be made only after consulting with your investment advisor and only after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company. Email Reference ID: 470DRED01