The Edge: How College Leaders Can Bridge the Growing ‘Trust Gap’

Harmony on campus is hard to come by even when the stakes are lower. But internal conflicts aren’t inevitable. ADVERTISEMENT [logo] We’ve made some changes and improvements to [chronicle.com]( such as ending the distinction between free and premium articles. Now free registration is all that’s required to read any Chronicle article. [Read about these and other changes](. Was this newsletter forwarded to you? [Please sign up to receive your own copy.]( You’ll support our journalism and ensure that you continue to receive our emails. [Read this newsletter on the web](. I’m Goldie Blumenstyk, a senior writer at The Chronicle of Higher Education, covering innovation in and around academe. As the Covid-19 crisis continues, here’s what I’m thinking about this week. How college leaders can bridge the growing “trust gap” with their faculty and staff members. Harmony on campus is hard to come by even when the stakes are lower. The brutally tough decisions colleges have been or soon will be making — how to teach in the fall, where to cut as budgets tighten — are among the most challenging that institutions have faced, at least since 2008. And for the foreseeable future, it’s not going to get any easier. But internal conflicts aren’t inevitable. I became more convinced of that after hosting a conversation last week with three presidents, as part of the [Remote conference](. They shared ideas like avoiding “the bunker mentality” (Mark Rosenberg of Florida International University); ensuring that the institution’s values are reflected in its actions (Lori S. White, DePauw University); and creating formal opportunities for people to voice complaints and concerns (Joseph Castro, California State University at Fresno.) Here are some of the lessons that seemed the most useful — and universal. ADVERTISEMENT Subscribe to the Chronicle Our mission, at a time of crisis and uncertainty, is to ensure you have the information you need to make the best decisions for your institution, your career, and your students. Please consider subscribing today to sustain our continuing coverage. [Subscribe Today]( In stressful times, people appreciate when you invest in them. Since March, and especially over the summer, all three institutions have put time and resources into professional development for faculty members. Fresno and FIU have relied heavily on their teaching and learning centers to train hundreds of professors on remote instruction, and DePauw has created faculty “communities of practice” to focus on teaching issues that arose this spring. Fresno is even paying professors a stipend for going through the training; FIU is including its adjuncts. Connecting with colleagues is vital — and not just for newbies. White, who was in Week 3 of her presidency when we spoke, is deliberately organizing a host of virtual meetings with her new colleagues. It’s her only way to meet them right now, and for them to get a better sense of her priorities. Even longer-serving leaders shouldn’t forget to touch base regularly. Inclusive decision making pays off. (Yeah, more committees!) Rosenberg couldn’t imagine moving forward without input from two committees: one his provost created to guide the eventual “re-population” of the campus and another that decided how to use federal Cares Act funds. Fresno convened a group to help set protocols for the limited amount of face-to-face teaching it expects to conduct this fall. Meanwhile, the presence of unions can be a plus. Both presidents said that existing union-administration relationships facilitated communication and made it easier to resolve disagreements, like one at Fresno over who would be doing Covid-19 testing. It’s worth making room for dissenting views. Rosenberg, the longest-serving of the presidents, was adamant on this point, noting how he’d seen people at other institutions suffer when leaders became too insulated, too reliant on their hand-picked inner circles. “I’m very worried about groupthink” he said, especially now, with so much happening so fast. “We have to be very open.” Castro uses an online feedback page to publicly air and answer questions that come to him. That openness includes paying attention to rumors. Even if they’re not completely true, White added, it’s important to identify the circumstances that got them going. A college’s mission and values should guide its actions. Talk is easy. In the end, institutions will be judged by what they do. Especially when it comes to putting the health and safety of the campus community first, said White, “the more we demonstrate that by our actions,” the better. DePauw is trying to do that by respecting faculty members’ choices on how they want to teach in the fall. Castro has heard grumbling from local alumni who own businesses about the Cal State system’s decision in mid-May to stay mostly remote in the fall. “Some people thought we were making a decision prematurely,” he said. “I’m guided as an educator by the mission of our university.” Are these foolproof ideas? No. But they seem like good starting points. For the whole conversation (along with dozens of other sessions), register and look around [here](. Hopes — and doubts — about new attention to skills in hiring. This month [I wrote that I wasn’t sure]( what to make of President Trump’s executive order urging federal agencies to look beyond degrees in hiring, especially since it came as colleges face their biggest headwinds in memory. I appreciate the insights many of you shared. Advocates for skills-based hiring tend to see it as a way to level the playing field for qualified job candidates who happen not to be college graduates. And some of you see the federal move as an opportunity for higher ed. Rovy Branon, vice provost for the University of Washington’s Continuum College, said that while degrees can signal mastery of skills, colleges need to do a better job of accurately capturing and verifying that. Now is the time, he said, “to create faster and cheaper pathways for a new market that wants and needs it.” And Shalin Jyotishi, of the Association of Public and Land-Grant Universities, noted that “sometimes a degree isn't the only/right credential a learner needs, and that's OK.” Jyotishi, the assistant director for economic development and community engagement at APLU, also put in a plug for an op-ed he just co-wrote, arguing for [embedding industry certifications into degree programs]( an approach that was popular with readers of The Edge when [I wrote about it in December](. Less positively, I heard from folks wondering whether the new order would create confusion — and perhaps worse. Matthew Hora, of the Wisconsin Center for Education Research, worried that implementation could emphasize assessments of so-called “soft skills” like communication that are “cultural constructions” and could “open the door to even more hiring discrimination.” A related concern for me: In recent weeks, we’ve seen a bevy of announcements from colleges, companies, and nonprofits about new programs to help people skill up, especially in the digital realm. The list includes [Google’s]( career certifications and scholarships, [Microsoft’s]( “global skills initiative,” the [Digital US]( and the new nonprofit [Skill](. As well meaning as these initiatives seem, they miss the bigger issue — that many of the 40 million newly unemployed people didn’t lose their jobs because they lacked skills. They lost them because the pandemic shut down their workplaces. Maybe that’s the jolt that will prompt some to find better jobs, but skills alone won’t guarantee a shiny new career. Better coordination of state work-force policies, as [this new effort]( calls for, could help. Ultimately, though, we need a much stronger, growing economy, and [that is at least a few years away]( if we’re lucky (and if more people would [just wear masks](. Without a recovery, [this]( Post]( assessment]( is worth remembering: “Re-skilling is sort of like playing musical chairs: People are racing to grab a job and sit down, and not everyone will get a seat.” Join our discussion today on equity in remote education. Remote education this spring was especially difficult for students without reliable technology and internet, dedicated places to study, and other resources that a campus provides. Now, as more colleges realize they’ll be operating mostly online into the fall, ensuring equity remains a major challenge. In this virtual forum today at 2 p.m., Eastern time, experts with a diverse set of experiences will join me to discuss the policies and strategies that provosts, deans, and other campus leaders should consider to make remote learning more equitable. My guests will be: Alison Byerly, president of Lafayette College; Sharon Davies, provost of Spelman College; Charles H.F. Davis III, an assistant professor of higher education at the University of Michigan; and Enrique Murillo Jr., a professor of education at California State University at San Bernardino and executive director of its Latino Education and Advocacy Days. Sign up [here]( to watch live or later on demand. Got a tip you’d like to share or a question you’d like me to answer? Let me know, at goldie@chronicle.com. If you have been forwarded this newsletter and would like to see past issues, [find them here](. To receive your own copy, free, register [here](. If you want to follow me on Twitter, [@GoldieStandard]( is my handle. Goldie’s Weekly Picks A SHIFT IN COLLEGES' PLANS [Colleges Hoped for an In-Person Fall. Now the Dream is Crumbling.]( By Lindsay Ellis [image] Announcements on Monday by the University of California at Berkeley, Miami Dade College and others signal a retreat from optimism that NEWS [For First-Generation Students, a Disappearing ‘College Experience’ Could Have Grave Consequences]( By Alison Berg [image] As on-campus study and life fall victim to Covid-19, experts say such students will suffer as a result. NEWS [What College Activists Want]( By Katherine Mangan and Marc Parry [image] Defunded police. Inclusive coursework. Faculty who look like them. Students are demanding radical change for racial justice, and they’re not backing down. Paid for and Created by EAB [Virtual Tours Key Factor in College Decision Process]( Future college students are relying on EAB’s YouVisit interactive virtual tours to experience key components of what student life would be like on campus including exploring a dorm, sitting in on a class, and meeting current students and faculty. ADVERTISEMENT job announcement Internal Medicine Residency Faculty position available at University of Texas Rio Grande Valley [Visit jobs.chronicle.com]( for more details. Paid for and Created by Southeastern Conference [SEC Professors highlight conference’s academic excellence across array of fields]( Built on a strong foundation of teaching and research, the SEC has a strong history of recognizing and supporting academic success across an array of fields. The Chronicle's Latest Featured Report: Preparing For Tough Conversations The coronavirus pandemic has been the catalyst for exceptionally tough conversations between campus leaders and their faculty, staff, and students. [This Chronicle brief]( offers strategies and advice for approaching sensitive topics and leading difficult dialogues. Job Opportunities [Search the Chronicle's jobs database]( to view the latest jobs in higher education. What did you think of today’s newsletter? [Strongly disliked]( // [It was OK]( // [Loved it](. [logo]( This newsletter was sent to {EMAIL}. [Manage]( your newsletter preferences, [stop receiving]( this email, or [view]( our privacy policy. © 2020 [The Chronicle of Higher Education]( 1255 23rd Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20037