[Bloomberg](
Todayâs Agenda
- Did the era of big government end 20 years ago? [Yes, no and maybe](.
- Trumpâs State of the Union speech [didnât give much reason for hope](.
- Female executives are making [smart choices]( in [retail](.
- The EU may [soon change its tune]( about [big mergers](.
Is the Government Growing or Shrinking? Yes.
In a State of the Union address 23 years (gack!) before President Donald Trumpâs last night, Bill Clinton [declared]( âthe era of big government is over.â It turns out the truth of that depends on what the meaning of the word âoverâ is.Â
Certainly, in the first of [a series of government-spending charts]( put together by Justin Fox, you can see Clinton spoke at a time when spending was steadily retreating from a high mountain. But you can also see the valley didnât go too deep or last too long:
But by other measures, such as hiring and investment, the government has been shrinking steadily since the 1950s:
But on the other other hand, government regulations have ballooned:
In other words, as with most data, thereâs ammunition here to back up any argument. You can see [all of Justinâs charts here](.
Chewing on the State of the Union
As mentioned, Trump delivered his own State of the Union speech last night. Your reaction likely depends on your political affiliation; a promised call for bipartisanship didnât go very far. It nodded enough to comity to [make open-minded listeners almost optimistic](, Bloombergâs editorial board writes. But now we have to see if Trump follows up, and the odds already [donât look good](.
Jonathan Bernstein is less charitable, calling the speech â[another wasted opportunity]( from a president who has wasted plenty of them.â Trumpâs few calls for cooperation were drowned out by poor delivery, lies and combativeness, Jonathan writes.Â
One shocker in the speech was Trumpâs ad-libbed claim he wants to see âthe largest numbers everâ of legal immigrants. This is jarring, notes Ramesh Ponnuru, because Trump has been trying to squeeze, not increase, legal immigration. Itâs one reason he keeps blowing up border-wall deals. But [nobody should take anything Trump says seriously]( anyway, Ramesh writes; Trump certainly doesnât, and neither do the people who work for him. Consistency and follow-through just arenât his style.Â
One concrete promise in the speech was that Trump would meet North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un in Vietnam at the end of this month. But [Trumpâs eagerness to cozy up to North Korea](, even as that nation does little to earn trust, hurts Americaâs moral authority, writes Eli Lake.Â
A Tale of Two Retail Operations
Apple Inc. last night announced its head of retail, Angela Ahrendts, is leaving the company. The timing couldnât be better, write Alex Webb and Andrea Felsted. Ahrendts [oversaw a boom in retail profitability for Apple]( â but her vision was maybe starting to fail her in China, where sales have been lumpy. This is a good time for Ahrendts to take a victory lap and for Apple to try something different in China. Â
Another woman in a high-profile retail job, though arguably even more challenging, is J.C. Penney Co.âs new CEO, Jill Soltau. She has wasted no time putting her stamp on the company, ditching an effort by her predecessor to catch some of the appliance sales that will scatter whenever Sears Holdings Corp. finally goes supernova. Sarah Halzack writes Soltau is [smart to focus her energies on apparel](, which makes up the bulk of J.C. Penneyâs revenue and could use some freshening up.
Giant Train Merger Derailed
EU regulators shot down a potential blockbuster merger between Germanyâs Siemens AG and French railway manufacturer Alstom SA. The companies tried to scare regulators about the rise of CRRC Corp., a ginormous Chinese train-gear maker. But the EU was right to say [Siemens-Alstom would have been a global behemoth]( far scarier than CRRC, which is mainly a domestic player, writes David Fickling. And anyway, Siemens and Alstom both helped CRRCâs rise by carelessly giving it key intellectual property. Stop doing that!
But despite â or because of? â the Siemens-Alstom rejection, the [tide may soon turn against the EUâs antitrust]( sentiment, Lionel Laurent writes. European Commission elections and Brexit could be opportunities for Siemens and other big companies to bend policy making more to their liking.
Telltale Charts
Americaâs educational system is bad at [identifying and helping poor and minority students]( who could be high achievers in college and beyond, notes Noah Smith. This is not only unfair, but it also hurts Americaâs economic potential.
Snap Inc.âs latest quarterly results were the picture of stability, but [stability wonât be enough](, warns Shira Ovide.Â
Further Reading
The Walt Disney Co. has adopted [a new identity as a streaming]( video provider. Details to follow. â Tara LachapelleÂ
Activist Elliott Management Co. has [gotten almost everything it wanted at Arconic]( Inc. â except for a higher stock price. â Brooke Sutherland
The EU and U.K. have agreed to [avoid blowing up the credit-derivatives market]( in the event of a no-deal Brexit, but thatâs just the start of years of wrangling. â Lionel LaurentÂ
Trumpâs World Bank nominee, David Malpass, does seem to have a sense for what the bank needs. But itâs [past time a non-American]( ran it. â Mihir SharmaÂ
ICYMI
Lloyd Blankfein and Bernie Sanders are [Twitter-fighting](. Elizabeth Warren [called herself an âAmerican Indianâ]( on a form in 1996. Inside [Wisconsinâs disastrous Foxconn deal](.
Kickers
Clothes-stealing dorm-room ghost is actually [a dude camping in the closet](. (h/t Joel Brill)
A newly discovered species of arthropod may have [survived the Ice Age underground](. (h/t Scott Kominers)
Active-shooter drills in schools [may be doing more harm]( than good.Â
The best movies that [lost best picture]( at every Oscars so far.
Note:Â Please send Oscars and complaints to Mark Gongloff at mgongloff1@bloomberg.net.
New to Bloomberg Opinion Today? [Sign up here]( and follow us on [Twitter]( and [Facebook](.
[FOLLOW US [Facebook Share]]( [Twitter Share]( SEND TO A FRIEND [Share with a friend]
You received this message because you are subscribed to Bloomberg's Bloomberg Opinion Today newsletter.
[Unsubscribe]( | [Bloomberg.com]( | [Contact Us](
Bloomberg L.P. 731 Lexington, New York, NY, 10022